Brothers Pizza & Italian Restaurant
455 NJ-23 #4, Wantage
(973) 702-1436
Customers' Favorites
Chicken Parmigiana Pizza
Meatball Parmigiana Sub
French Fries Tater Tots
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Grilled Chicken
Pepperoni Pizza
Pepperoni Roll
Cheese Pizza
Taco Pizza
Wings
Menu
Photos
+39 photos
+38 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Randomly stopped in one evening. They had whatever slices were left (as expected). I got 1 pep and 1 sausage Togo. Pizza was great! People were very nice. I feel so bad to see these BS reviews hammering this place!!!! MAYBE dont order seafood from a pizza shop for your husbands birthday ( unless you like your boyfriend more 🤷‍♂️ then it was a great way to show your husband how you feel ) ! Esp being “a professionally trained chef” one would think you would have...
The negative reviews are WiLd. This review is for the food! Pizza was excellent, fresh and delicious. The Cheese Steak sandwich was amazing and delicious. I would highly recommend this place. I wouldn’t go by the Bad reviews / the place was busy the food was super clean, fresh and very yummy!
My family and I have been going to Brothers for years and we've never had a bad meal. The food is tasty and hot. My husband and I are convinced that there isn't one bad item on the menu. Even our daughter with ARFID loves Brothers and she started liking pizza because of Brothers. Also, thank you for keeping our zeppoli cravings happy!
You May Also Like
Eastern Garden - 455 NJ-23
![]()
Chinese, Japanese, Vegetarian
EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN - 9 Main St
![]()
Bar & Grill, American, Cocktail Bar
Annabel Pizza - 70 E Main St #72
![]()
Pizza, Caterers