SCARSELLA'S ITALIAN DELI & RESTAURANT
285 NJ-23 North, Wantage
(973) 552-9118
Menu
Photos
+3 photos
+2 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I grew up in Bergen county and since I moved to Sussex county I've yet to find food as good. I still can't find good pizza anywhere in this county. That being said this place makes amazing sandwiches. I got a spicy Sicilian sub and it was perfect. It was loaded thick with meats and the perfect amount of cheese. It had the right amount of lettuce, onions, tomatoes, oil and vinegar. The bread was superb, super soft inside with just the right amount of strength in the crust....
This place is one of my go to delis for a great sandwich. I'm pretty particular with how a sandwich is made. I grew up working in a deli and my boss was very particular on how to make the best sandwhich. It sounds silly but you can totally make it wrong and I've experienced that in other places, but not here! You know how to make em! Bread is perfect, fresh ingredients and friendly service!
Incredible establishment - among the best sandwiches in the area. We were in town for a wedding at the nearby Mountain Creek Lodge, and needed to feed 10-15 hungry groomsmen on wedding day. We called around to a few different restaurants in the area, asked for local suggestions, and all signs led us to Scarsella’s.Dave and his team (of childhood friends) that run this unassuming Deli are great people. They were kind, honest, and most of all cooked up a great 20 hoagies for us....
You May Also Like
Sussex Sit n' Chat Diner - 289 NJ-23
![]()
Diner, Vegetarian, Pancakes, Comfort Food, Pet Friendly
The Bagel Tree North - 205 NJ-23
![]()
Bagels, Vegetarian