Guerriero Gelato & Cakes
476 Pleasant Valley Way, West Orange
(973) 731-6011
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate and Vanilla Ice Cream Cone
Cookie Monster Cake Same Day
Ultimate Brownie Sundae
Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Ice Cream Milkshake
Chocolate Ice Cream
Soft Serve Cups
Hard Ice Cream
Birthday Cake
Frozen Yogurt
Menu
Photos
+37 photos
+36 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Great tasting ice cream and a nice selection of interesting flavors. My favorites included rainbow cookie and cherry pistachio. My kid loved their Unicorn (cotton candy) flavor. They also had orange soft serve which tasted like an orange creamsicle.
So many flavors like unicorn, cookie monster etc. great for kids! And they have a waffle cone with chocolate and sprinkles on it who wouldn't want that! Also options for soft serve frozen yogurt. The only downside was that they are using AI on their menus- come on you have a beautiful painted mural and used to have chalkboard menus why switch to AI 😭
I was hesitant about coming here because of the great legacy of Mark and Julie. But, their ice cream was delicious. Cullen was extremely attentive and made sure I found the perfect scoop! Will definitely come back!
You May Also Like
Fortissimo Osteria / Pizzeria - 484 Pleasant Valley Way
![]()
Pizza, Italian, Vegetarian
460 Bistro - 460 Pleasant Valley Way
![]()
Mediterranean, Turkish