Tony’s New York Pizza
4416 Pacific Ave, Wildwood
(609) 551-4306
Customers' Favorites
s10b Ziti with Garlic \u0026 Oil
Cheese \u0026 Meat Calzone
Cheese Tortellini Alfredo
Seasoned French Fries
Fried Zucchini Sticks
BBQ Chicken Finger
Grandma Pie
Beef Patty
Menu
Photos
+20 photos
+19 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I ordered a pepperoni pizza and a Grandma's Pie tonight on Dash and everything about my food was delicious . Absolutely 5 stars!! Amazing taste and everything was fresh!! I will be back!!!!
The family and I did an off boardwalk pizza tour to find the best pizza in Wildwood! We will not name those who did not come in first place out of respect since they also have good pizza. But Tony’s was an absolute winner!
Great, thin crust, strong, undercarriage, almost was a unanimous win across the board!
In addition to the great pizza, it is a great family environment. We enjoyed meeting the owners family while we were there. This will now be our...
Great, thin crust, strong, undercarriage, almost was a unanimous win across the board!
In addition to the great pizza, it is a great family environment. We enjoyed meeting the owners family while we were there. This will now be our...
100/10 recommend this place ! Being a fellow New Yorker it was great to have a taste of home here . We got the penne vodka chicken pizza . It was absolutely out of this world . Everything was so fresh and delicious ! The owner is awesome ! Had such great conversation with him. Very personable and hard worker ! I would go back to this place 100000 times . If you want the best pizza in wildwood go here !
You May Also Like
El Mariachi Loco - 4500 Pacific Ave
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
Garibaldis - 4220 Pacific Ave
![]()
Mexican, Vegetarian
Duffinetti's Restaurant and Lounge - 4600 Pacific Ave
![]()
Italian, Lounges, Venues & Event Spaces, Pet Friendly, Vegetarian