Bonfire Coffeehouse

249 A Main St, Amagansett
(631) 557-3125

Recent Reviews

Sort by
David

I enjoy everything there and the young boy serving my coffee was very pleasant and nice. Pretty sure his name was Bradley

Vanessa S Galindo

Make sure to ask for Bradley, best barista

Grant Kelly

I was a bit scared from the lack of espresso photos and the tacky logo but the pull and the quiche were on par. Great outdoor seating. Staff is attentive. Skip starbucks on your way out east… hit bonfire. Would recommend

Cat Vee

Excellent coffee. Excellent. Bacon egg in croissant. Excellent lemon poppy muffin. Exceeded my expectations. I did not want a reheated/frozen egg sandwich. The sandwich was Excellent and fresh. Sat outside and enjoyed the sun. Thank you!

Christian Lavados

Tasty but very slow service.

Mark Evans

As long time Hamptons locals, we can’t tell you how chuffed we are that this hidden gem is open year round, as we’d have to slog it west of the canal for a proper café style breakfast. So Yay! And fortunately, the coffee is fantastic, the food is fabulous, and the staff are super friendly. Had a wee chat with one of the lovely owners, Lisa, who is a lifelong local as well, so reckon that she & her fellow female partners are the reason the vibes are such old school Hamptons. Word is that they’re meant to be kicking off a Brunch Special next weekend, so we’ll mos def be popping in. And we suggest that you try to get in now when it’s chill, because it’ll be mental come season. Perhaps then you’ll become regulars, and can curry favour to cut the queue, as we’ll be sure to be trying to do too. Ha! Bang on job ladies!

Erin Sauchelli

I had a very different experience than others have described here. Agree that the staff is very nice, but the food was of the quality you would get on an airplane. We ordered a breakfast sandwich with “skillet potatoes” and a frittata. The skillet potatoes were presented literally in the container they must have been purchased in - one of those cardboard reheatable containers you’d get a frozen Stouffer’s lasagna in. The frittata also had no taste and a spongy texture, like it was a frozen food that was heated up. Maybe we just ordered the wrong items, but we were really disappointed.

Rick Canter

Excellent pastries and service. Their cinnamon bun and their rice pudding are exceptional

Friendly employees and a clean bathroom

Peter

I absolutely love this place. It has struck the perfect balance between good food, a great atmosphere, wonderful staff and prices that are reasonable for the Hamptons. It's one of the few places out here where u can sit for an hour or two with your laptop, get some work done, have good coffee and food at the same time, all in a cafe environment. I highly recommend it.

Fritz Butehorn

Small is very small, good with large, coffee was good

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

B D

We just had egg sandwiches and avocado toast; absolutely delicious. Chef Michael was terrific!! We highly recommend!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tyler Horn

Hidden Gem! Just discovered this place and now my favorite coffee and lunch in Amagansett! The food is off the hook and the coffee is perfect! I'm not easy to please when it comes to coffee. Generally America burns the coffee in roasting, this place does not!
Go Here! You will enjoy!

Parking: Park in the big public lot and enter from the back.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cappaccuino, Sandwich, Iced Latte

Chris and No Ding

Family run and omemade from the ❤!!
All of it...
Coffee, baked goods, gelato!!!
Delish!!!!?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jon Mullen

Tasty coffee and a relaxed outdoor space!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gabriella Yoo

Absolutely delish! I had the avocado toast with an egg & my husband ordered the breakfast platter. Our coffees were also delish! We would definitely be back here.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Iced Latte

Loading...