8 Best Coffee Shops near Amagansett

“One of my absolute favorite places in Amagansett! I come to Rosie’s for breakfast or brunch pretty much every weekend, and it never disappoints. The food is phenomenal—I’ve honestly tried every breakfast item on the menu, and I can’t pick a favorite because everything is that good!

And the scones… WOW! They are quite possibly one of the best things I’ve ever put in my mouth. 😂 Seriously, don’t come here without ordering them!

But what makes Rosie’s extra special is the people. The staff is always so warm, welcoming, and genuinely friendly. A special shoutout to Emi behind the bar, who is an absolute sweetheart and always makes us feel right at home. ❤

And then there’s the vibe! The space is gorgeous, and I love how they decorate for every season. It always feels thoughtfully done and somehow gets even more beautiful throughout the year. When the weather allows, the outdoor seating is lovely, and the inside is just as beautiful and inviting.

Amazing food, wonderful people, and such a beautiful atmosphere. Rosie’s has become one of those places that feels like home—and that’s pretty special. If you’re in Amagansett, this is a must! 🥂❤ oh, and they are PET-FRIENDLY!!!! Rosies has a special place in my heart!“

“Love the coffee and the staff—I’m there at least 5 days a week!“

“Its tight in there-with that being said, the staff works very hard. Coffee is good and so are sandwiches.
Here's some advice for anyone going-order your food, then get out of the way so other people can order-don't linger in front of the coffee because guess what? People will want to access that area to make coffee. Let the workers do their thing and be patient-follow those simple instructions and enjoy breakfast. You're welcome.“

“Best local coffee shop run by the friendliest people! Comes with nice selection of art books, and small selection of groceries, house wares, and clothing. Very short term bench seating only (no tables). Please don't come here with feisty fast-paced angry city vibes, slow down, it's small and it's sometimes hard to park during busy times of year (summers / weekends), so just relax!!“

“It’s a very unique Starbucks Shop.“

“I stopped by the Starbucks on Main Street and had a great experience. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming which made the visit even better. The inside of the store was very clean, comfortable and nicely set up making it a perfect spot to enjoy a coffee or get some work done. Definitely one of the nicer Starbucks locations I have been to.“

“Best coffee and cappuccino in all Long Island Really nice outdoors space and great fun Italian manager !!! It’s definitely a place to stop and fun to be!! Love it !“