10 Best Coffee Shops near Amagansett

“Incredible vegan pasta salad, and the best black bean burger, and the coffee was fabulous!“

“If I could give more than five stars, I would. Konstantin at Rosie’s in Amagansett is, without question, one of the best servers I’ve ever had.

From the moment we sat down, he made us feel genuinely welcomed. His knowledge of the menu was exceptional, his recommendations were spot-on, and he struck that rare balance of being attentive without ever hovering. Every detail was handled effortlessly, and his warmth, professionalism, and sense of humor elevated the entire experience.

What really sets Konstantin apart is that he doesn’t just provide great service - he creates an unforgettable dining experience. He anticipated what we needed before we even had to ask, kept everything flowing perfectly, and made us feel like valued guests from start to finish.

Rosie’s is already a fantastic restaurant, but Konstantin is the kind of person who turns a great meal into a memorable occasion. Hospitality like this is incredibly rare, and he deserves every bit of recognition. We’ll absolutely be back, and we’ll be asking for Konstantin every single time.“

“Love the coffee and the staff—I’m there at least 5 days a week!“

“Goldberg loves bacon! Not kosher or halal. Good everything bagel. Toasted to a crispy bite. Bacon cooked well. Eggs were fluffy fried. Cheese well melted. BEC porportions were just right. A bit too much ketcup. Service could have b3en friendlier. Topped off the meal with a large ice coffee. Came out to over 16. Not sure how but ok. I still may come back.

Stopped by again last weekend of summer 2025.
Was staying at hither hills campground and going fishing at 8am that day. Wanted to start the morning off early with a fresh bagel and ice coffee. They open at 6am and we got there around 620. They didn’t have bagels yet. The guy behind the counter couldn’t say when they would get their bagel delivery, “ could be in 10 minutes, could be twenty,” he exclaimed.
:( Bae was disappointed and I was a little too. I settled with a bacon egg and cheese or …. A roll. Ate it on the boat.“

“Best local coffee shop run by the friendliest people! Comes with nice selection of art books, and small selection of groceries, house wares, and clothing. Very short term bench seating only (no tables). Please don't come here with feisty fast-paced angry city vibes, slow down, it's small and it's sometimes hard to park during busy times of year (summers / weekends), so just relax!!“

“Iced latte and coffee were delicious and I got to choose from two kinds of espresso for my latte which was unique. Usually I'm never asked. The barista was super friendly too! The market has lots of great stuff and their backyard is beautiful. It is a little pricy (paid $13ish without tip for the coffee and iced latte) but I think that may be par for the course with this area. Would definitely return!“

“It’s a very unique Starbucks Shop.“

“I stopped by the Starbucks on Main Street and had a great experience. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming which made the visit even better. The inside of the store was very clean, comfortable and nicely set up making it a perfect spot to enjoy a coffee or get some work done. Definitely one of the nicer Starbucks locations I have been to.“

“Best coffee and cappuccino in all Long Island Really nice outdoors space and great fun Italian manager !!! It’s definitely a place to stop and fun to be!! Love it !“