Anderson's Frozen Custard

2369 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst
(716) 691-8970

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Vanilla Frozen Custard
Sweet Potato Fries
Curly Que Fries
Chicken Tenders
Ice Cream Cone
Ice Cream Cake
Carl's Choice
Whipped Cream
Baked Potato
French Fries

Menu

Monthly Features
4-Pint Party Pack
Includes 4 pints of your choice of our Signature Frozen Custard or Handmade Hard Ice Cream.
Mintzilla Sundae
Sweet Treat of the Month! Handmade mint chocolate chunk ice cream drenched with hot fudge and topped with crushed thin mint cookies.
Mint Cookie Fudge Arctic Swirl
Arctic Swirl of the Month! Our chocolate frozen custard blended with crushed thin mint cookies and topped with hot fudge and a dollop of real whipped cream.
Greek Fries
Loaded Fries of the Month! A large order of our golden curly fries, topped with Greek dressing, feta cheese, and banana peppers.

Signature Sandwiches
Signature All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich
Anderson's famous beef on weck. All natural roast beef traditionally on kimmelweck roll, most commonly dressed with horseradish. Made to your liking.
All Natural Turkey Sandwich
All natural turkey with no additives. Served hot or cold. Prepared to your liking.
Barbecue Beef Sandwich
Slow-cooked in Anderson's original tangy barbecue sauce.
Old Fashioned Roast Beef Sandwich with Gravy
All natural roast beef sandwich prepared on sliced bread and served with an optional side item, all smothered with thick gravy.
Old Fashioned Turkey Sandwich with Gravy
All natural turkey sandwich prepared on sliced bread and served with an optional side item, all smothered with thick gravy.

From the Grill
All Natural Angus Beef Burger
Hot Dog
Flame grilled locally popular Sahlen's hot dog on a Costanzo's bun. Includes your choice of condiments and toppings.
All Natural Grilled Chicken Sandwich
All-natural 4 oz. chicken breast with no preservatives, additives, or hormones, grilled to perfection, on a roll with your choice of toppings.
Vegan Black Bean Burger
A touch of spice brings out the delicious flavor of the Black Bean Burger. Includes your choice of condiments and toppings.
Salmon Burger
Flame grilled salmon burger made standard with honey cayenne sauce, lettuce, and red onion

Chicken Tenders, Fish & Shrimp
All Natural Chicken Tender Sandwich
Our crisp, all natural chicken tenders tossed in Buffalo wing sauce, with lettuce and blue cheese
All Natural Chicken Tender Basket with Fries
Wild Caught Fish Sandwich
Breaded wild caught cod, fried to perfection. Served standard with lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce.
Shrimp & Fries Basket
Six pieces of crispy and tender fried shrimp, served over a basket of golden curly fries with a side of cocktail sauce
Side of Shrimp
Six pieces of crispy and tender shrimp served with a side of cocktail sauce

Bistro Sandwiches & Wraps
Asiago Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled all natural chicken breast, wrapped up with lettuce, cucumbers, almonds, parmesan cheese, and Asiago Caesar dressing on a flour tortilla.
Veggie Wrap
Lettuce, tomatoes, red onion, cucumber, and avocado on a flour wrap, served with a side of creamy balsamic dressing.
All Natural Chicken in the Grass
Grilled all natural chicken breast topped with a mixture of steamed spinach, red onion, provolone cheese, and balsamic onion vinaigrette.

Salads
Mandarin Chicken Salad
Mixed greens, mandarin oranges, grilled all natural chicken breast, almonds, and chow mein noodles with orange sesame dressing.
Spring Salad
Mixed greens, mandarin oranges, feta cheese, red onion, and pecans with raspberry vinaigrette dressing.

Hot Sides
Homestyle Mac 'n Cheese
Preservative-free 4 rich cheese mixture.
Baked Potato
Freshly baked Idaho potato with your choice of toppings
Mashed Potatoes
Side of homestyle mashed potatoes with gravy or butter.
All Natural Turkey Chili
Preservative-free turkey chili with beans.

Fries, Rings & Things
Curly Que Fries
Cajun Fries with Cheese
Onion Rings
Sweet Potato Fries
Fried Pickles with Ranch Dip
Large Fries with Topping(s)
Greek Fries
Loaded Fries of the Month! A large order of our golden curly fries, topped with Greek dressing, feta cheese, and banana peppers.

Sides & Sauces
1/2 Deli Dill Pickle
Condiment Packets
Amount given will be appropriate for your order.
Side of Thick Beef Gravy
Side of Thick Turkey Gravy
Side of Melted Cheddar Sauce
Potato Salad
5 oz. portion of egg and mustard potato salad.

Kid's Meals
All Natural Roast Beef Sandwich Kid's Meal
All Natural Turkey Sandwich Kid's Meal
All Natural Chicken Tenders Kid's Meal
2 crispy all natural chicken tenders with a choice of dipping sauce.
All Natural Grilled Chicken Strips Kid's Meal
All natural grilled chicken breast, sliced into strips and served with your choice of dipping sauce.
Sahlen's Hot Dog Kid's Meal
All Natural Angus Burger Kid's Meal
Homestyle Mac 'n Cheese Kid's Meal
Entree portion of our Homestyle Mac 'n Cheese.
Peanut Butter & Jelly Kid's Meal
Peanut Butter & Banana Kid's Meal

Fountain & Bottled Beverages
Johnnie Ryan Fountain Drink
Based locally in Niagara Falls, Johnnie Ryan pop is made with real cane sugar and no high-fructose corn syrup.
Bottled Pop
We offer Pepsi and Niagara Falls based Johnnie Ryan products.
Bottled Iced Tea
Bottled Water
Homemade Iced Tea
Unsweetened. Freshly brewed each day.

Milkshakes & Dessert Beverages
Traditional Milkshake
Your choice of flavor, hand-mixed with our signature vanilla frozen custard.
Hard Ice Cream Milkshake
Blended with your choice of our handmade hard ice cream or frozen yogurt flavor.
Strawberry Sensation
Fat free, dairy-free original Lemon Ice blended with Johnnie Ryan lemon up and strawberries.
Johnnie Ryan Float
Johnnie ryan pop layered with our signature vanilla frozen custard.
Chocolate Soda
Handmade rich chocolate soda layered with signature vanilla frozen custard.

Frozen Custard and Desserts
Signature Famous Frozen Custard
Our famous signature frozen custard recipe. All custard flavors contain dairy and egg.
Handmade Hard Ice Cream or Frozen Yogurt
Choose from a variety of original flavors. All ice cream and frozen yogurt flavors contain dairy. Chocolate based ice cream flavors contain egg. Some flavors may contain wheat from the inclusions.
Original Lemon Ice
Anderson's original water-based lemon ice recipe. Dairy free, gluten free, and fat free.
Vegan Plant-Based Frozen Dessert
Dairy-free vegan frozen dessert made with Anderson's original rice and coconut recipe.

Signature Sundaes
Mintzilla Sundae
Sweet Treat of the Month! Handmade mint chocolate chunk ice cream drenched with hot fudge and topped with crushed thin mint cookies.
Reese's Pieces Deluxe
Signature vanilla frozen custard topped with hot fudge, peanut butter, and Reese's Pieces.
Turtle Sundae
Signature vanilla frozen custard topped with hot fudge, your choice of caramel or butterscotch, and pecans.
Mexican Sundae
Signature vanilla frozen custard topped with rich chocolate syrup and spanish peanuts.
Create Your Own Sundae
Signature vanilla frozen custard with your choice of toppings, nuts, candies, and whipped cream.
Strawberry Glacier Sundae
Our original lemon ice topped with fresh strawberry topping!
Choco-Peanut Butter Passion
Chocolate peanut butter ice cream, hot fudge, peanut butter, peanut butter cookie, whipped cream, and Reese's peanut butter cups.
Banana Split
Vanilla and chocolate signature frozen custard in between 2 banana halves. Chocolate syrup, strawberry, and pineapple toppings. Topped with handmade whipped cream and chopped nuts.
Brownie Overboard
Rich fudge brownie with vanilla and chocolate frozen custard, topped with hot fudge, handmade whipped cream and chopped nuts.

Arctic Swirls & Chiffons
Mint Cookie Fudge Arctic Swirl
Arctic Swirl of the Month! Our chocolate frozen custard blended with crushed thin mint cookies and topped with hot fudge and a dollop of real whipped cream.
Arctic Swirl
Signature frozen custard hand mixed with your choice of candy.
Lemon Chiffon
Signature vanilla frozen custard hand mixed with our original lemon ice.

Hand-Packed Pints & Quarts
4- Pint Party Pack
Includes 4 pints of your choice of our Signature Frozen Custard or Handmade Hard Ice Cream.
Signature Famous Frozen Custard (Packed)
Handmade Hard Ice Cream or Frozen Yogurt (Packed)
Original Lemon Ice (Packed)
Vegan Plant-Based Frozen Dessert (Packed)

Handmade Ice Cream Cake
Round Ice Cream Cake
Serves 8-10. 2 layers of handmade vanilla and chocolate ice cream with a cookie crumb center, topped with a buttercream frosting.
Small Sheet Ice Cream Cake
Serves 16-20. 2 layers of handmade vanilla and chocolate ice cream with a cookie crumb center, topped with a buttercream frosting.
Rainbow Fudge with M&M's Ice Cream Cake
Serves 8-10. Chocolate ice cream with a center layer of our rich chocolate fudge and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our vanilla ice cream, more fudge, and real M&M's.
Cookies 'n' Cream Dream Ice Cream Cake
Serves 8-10. OREO® ice cream with a center layer of real OREO® cookie chunks, frosting, our smooth rich fudge and more OREO® cookies.
Cookie Dough & Fudge Ice Cream Cake
Serves 8-10. Chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream with a center layer of cookie dough pieces and rich chocolate fudge. Topped with frosting and more of our delicious cookie dough pieces and fudge.
Mint Chocolate Fudge Ganache Ice Cream Cake
Serves 12-15. Chocolate Mint ice cream with a center layer of our rich chocolate fudge and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our Mint Chunk ice cream, all covered with our special chocolate ganache sauce.
Peanut Butter Fudge Ganache Ice Cream Cake
Serves 12-15. Peanut Butter ice cream with a center layer of our delicious peanut butter sauce and chocolate cookie crunch, topped with our Chocolate ice cream , all covered with our special chocolate ganache sauce.
Fudgie Turtle Ice Cream Cake
Serves 12-15. Handmade vanilla and chocolate ice cream with caramel and fudge toppings with hand placed pecans to make a turtle-shaped ice cream cake.

Handmade Ice Cream Pie
Slice of Ice Cream Pie
Whole Ice Cream Pie

Big Wheels
Original Big Wheel (Single)
Handmade vanilla ice cream sandwiched by 2 chocolate cookies.
Original Big Wheel 6-Pack
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Big Wheel
Handmade Vanilla Ice Cream nestled in 2 huge delicious chocolate chip cookies.

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+71 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+70 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I LOVE Anderson been going there since a small child. The quality of roast beef has stayed but in this economy portions seemed less then I remember. They forgot my horse radish... it happens, I walked up to kindly ask for it and I received it instantly. Ice cream is amazing from what I remember. Open face turkey sandwich over mashed potatoes has always been a 2nd favorite for me. Great curly fries with cheese!! Kid friendly, indoor and outdoor seating.
October 2025
Getting pretty overpriced. $3.00 for a medium fountain drink that likely cost them $0.25. I probably would not have even left a review but when my take out order of Max n Cheese didn't include a utensil to use, you get 3 stars. End of rant. For the price, you're better off at Charlie the Butcher.
September 2025
Anderson's Frozen Custard is a buffalo classic that might not be the home of the original Beef on Weck, but they sure know how to make a good one. Alongisde one of their shakes and a side of fries, it's a great spot to have a meal with a bunch of friends.
August 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Ted's Hot Dogs - 2351 Niagara Fls Blvd
Hot Dogs, Burgers, Fast Food, Gluten-Free
Checkers - 2374 Niagara Falls Blvd
Fast Food, Burgers
Just Pizza - 2319 Niagara Fls Blvd
Pizza, Vegetarian

Anderson's Frozen Custard

2369 Niagara Fls Blvd, Amherst, NY 14228
(716) 691-8970