The Better Bagel
45 Merrick Rd, Amityville
(631) 608-4831
Customers' Favorites
Everything Seeds & Sriracha Avocado Toast
Spinach Wrap w Breaded Chicken Cutlet
Plan Bagel Butter Sausage and Bacon
Bagels with Flavored Cream Cheese
Bacon Egg & Cheese Sandwich
Bagels with Cream Cheese
Fat Kitchen Sink Hero
Bacon & Egg Sandwich
Smashed Avocado Toast
Nutty Chicken Salad
Menu
Photos
+31 photos
+30 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I had picked up near $90 dollar purchase for lunch break. When I got back to work, ready to eat my meal, we realized that the order was wrong. The 2 Midwestern Turkey BLTs were egg sandwiches on a hero. I called about the mistake, they offered to fix it.
I HAD to drive back to the store from my job WITH the egg sandwiches, the employee gave me the corrected heroes. I did say if he plans on throwing these egg sandwiches out, I could keep them. The employee...
I HAD to drive back to the store from my job WITH the egg sandwiches, the employee gave me the corrected heroes. I did say if he plans on throwing these egg sandwiches out, I could keep them. The employee...
Their food is excellent. I drive past multiple bagel stores to come to this oneThe only reason they’re not getting five stars is because their automated order system is no good. When you place an order and it tells you to pick up in a half an hour and then you wait another half an hour when you get there that’s just not right…..Update, somebody apparently walked off with my order…
You May Also Like
Raimo's Brick Oven Pizzeria & Trattoria of Amityville - 45 Merrick Rd
![]()
Italian, Pizza, Vegetarian
Five Guys - 45-A Merrick Rd
![]()
Fast Food, Burgers, Hot Dogs, Vegan
These bagels are easily in my top 5 on Long Island. The place is clean, well-organized, and fully staffed to keep the line moving quickly—even during busy hours.
The whitefish salad is chunky and flavorful, and the chicken salad is another must-try. They’ve got a great drink selection and always have fresh, hot bagels coming out. The bagels here are softer and super fresh—not overly well-done,...