First time visiting from out of town. Had the special Philly Cheese Steak quesadilla, it was delicious and a huge portion. Great friendly staff also.
Amber Ludwinek
Great Deli and Sub spot. Hoagies are huge so can easily share. Kids also got slices of pizza. Cute store with Italian items too. The house made lemonade with lots of different fruit flavors was amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda Trackey
Always great food and great service at Anthony’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amy Mariee
first time eating there and did not disappoint! so gooooood 10/10 would definitely recommend 👌
Michelle Snell
I just had the most amazing chicken bacon ranch quesadilla! It wasn’t the special today but they made it for me. It was absolutely the most delicious quesadilla I’ve ever had! My co-workers had the fish fry and raved about it! We will be ordering more often!
Erin Allen
I ordered sandwich platters and sides for a work event for 50 people. The food was fairly priced, delicious, and was more than enough for everyone.
The service upon pickup was excellent. My food was ready when I arrived and several members of the team brought the large order directly into my car for me. I would absolutely order again and would recommend them to anyone.
Anthony's is fantastic! The food is incredible and the portions are very generous. I love how the shop itself is full of local goodies and a little something for everyone. Megan and her team provide not only quality food and yummy specials, but also a warm, welcoming atmosphere that truly supports local businesses again. I'm so happy they are available for delivery now too for those days I just can't get away from my desk for lunch. I've been there for dine in, take out and have gotten delivery. All fresh and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Thanksgiving Hoagie
Donna Soper
Stopped in for the first time and while we didn't realize it was close to closing time, Leah graciously told us it was fine and we had time to enjoy our meal, no rush. The sub and sandwich were delicious and we look forward to trying other items on the menu soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tiandre General
Honestly the best breakfast sandwich in Amsterdam customer service was amazing very friendly very clean
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, Fries
Kameryn Curtis
I LOVE IT HERE! The food is always top notch, the staff are always friendly, it's fast and affordable. 10/10 recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
iMacOfDeath
Was not expecting this to be anything more than a deli, I was very wrong.
Part deli, part market, part home goods store, part bakery, and part starbucks. All impressive. Made the journey on foot which makes this a bit more memorable, but I had been planning on visiting for dinner for a week now.
Ended up ordering the Thanksgiving Hoagie, the Mega Muni Crispy Wrap, and while I was not planning on it, as I already had some dessert at home, I also bought a Fruit Tart, a slice of Biscoff Cheesecake, and a Frosted Cookie. Coming to a grand total just over $50, which was more than expected but those desserts added up.
Starting with the wrap, I found it, while warm, to be far too sweet. I think they over did it with the honey mustard, however, as I did not finish the wrap, the second half that I refrigerated overnight was outstanding! Totally need to make getting the wrap cold and option. The hoagie on the other hand, goodness me, it was mind blowing! Truly tasted like I was scarfing down a sandwich from leftovers after the holiday, is was totally perfect, no complaints. Loved the slight sweet flavor from the mayo, which contrasted with the savory turkey and mild cheese. I really hope this is not a season thing, as I want more.
Now, those desserts. So the cookie was whatever, very similar to other grocery store brand soft frosted cookies. Nothing to write home about. The fruit tart was alright, weirdly more bready than a lot of fruit tarts I have tasted before. Could use more fruit. But put all those aside, because the biscoff cheesecake was the experience I needed. Softer than your typical cheesecake, and more mild than one too. The biscoff flavor was on point, just note that if you chill it, like I did with the leftovers, the soft texture will go away and it becomes rather dense.
If nothing else, I'm coming back for that Thanksgiving feast!
First time visiting from out of town. Had the special Philly Cheese Steak quesadilla, it was delicious and a huge portion. Great friendly staff also.
Great Deli and Sub spot. Hoagies are huge so can easily share. Kids also got slices of pizza. Cute store with Italian items too. The house made lemonade with lots of different fruit flavors was amazing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Always great food and great service at Anthony’s!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
first time eating there and did not disappoint! so gooooood 10/10 would definitely recommend 👌
I just had the most amazing chicken bacon ranch quesadilla! It wasn’t the special today but they made it for me. It was absolutely the most delicious quesadilla I’ve ever had! My co-workers had the fish fry and raved about it! We will be ordering more often!
I ordered sandwich platters and sides for a work event for 50 people. The food was fairly priced, delicious, and was more than enough for everyone.
The service upon pickup was excellent. My food was ready when I arrived and several members of the team brought the large order directly into my car for me. I would absolutely order again and would recommend them to anyone.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Salad, Wrap, Breakfast Sandwich
Great subs
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was good and the staff was friendly and helpful. I had the turkey hoagie which I liked but think $15 is a bit high. Bathrooms were clean.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 4
Most Delicious Italian sub ever. Most delicious and smooth cheesecake from NY to Florida
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Combo Sub
Restaurantji Recommends
Anthony's is fantastic! The food is incredible and the portions are very generous. I love how the shop itself is full of local goodies and a little something for everyone. Megan and her team provide not only quality food and yummy specials, but also a warm, welcoming atmosphere that truly supports local businesses again. I'm so happy they are available for delivery now too for those days I just can't get away from my desk for lunch. I've been there for dine in, take out and have gotten delivery. All fresh and delicious!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Thanksgiving Hoagie
Stopped in for the first time and while we didn't realize it was close to closing time, Leah graciously told us it was fine and we had time to enjoy our meal, no rush. The sub and sandwich were delicious and we look forward to trying other items on the menu soon.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Honestly the best breakfast sandwich in Amsterdam customer service was amazing very friendly very clean
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Breakfast Sandwich, Fries
I LOVE IT HERE! The food is always top notch, the staff are always friendly, it's fast and affordable. 10/10 recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Was not expecting this to be anything more than a deli, I was very wrong.
Part deli, part market, part home goods store, part bakery, and part starbucks. All impressive. Made the journey on foot which makes this a bit more memorable, but I had been planning on visiting for dinner for a week now.
Ended up ordering the Thanksgiving Hoagie, the Mega Muni Crispy Wrap, and while I was not planning on it, as I already had some dessert at home, I also bought a Fruit Tart, a slice of Biscoff Cheesecake, and a Frosted Cookie. Coming to a grand total just over $50, which was more than expected but those desserts added up.
Starting with the wrap, I found it, while warm, to be far too sweet. I think they over did it with the honey mustard, however, as I did not finish the wrap, the second half that I refrigerated overnight was outstanding! Totally need to make getting the wrap cold and option. The hoagie on the other hand, goodness me, it was mind blowing! Truly tasted like I was scarfing down a sandwich from leftovers after the holiday, is was totally perfect, no complaints. Loved the slight sweet flavor from the mayo, which contrasted with the savory turkey and mild cheese. I really hope this is not a season thing, as I want more.
Now, those desserts. So the cookie was whatever, very similar to other grocery store brand soft frosted cookies. Nothing to write home about. The fruit tart was alright, weirdly more bready than a lot of fruit tarts I have tasted before. Could use more fruit. But put all those aside, because the biscoff cheesecake was the experience I needed. Softer than your typical cheesecake, and more mild than one too. The biscoff flavor was on point, just note that if you chill it, like I did with the leftovers, the soft texture will go away and it becomes rather dense.
If nothing else, I'm coming back for that Thanksgiving feast!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...