Brothers pizzeria

$ • Pizza

43263 NY-28, Arkville
(845) 586-6556


Take-Out/Delivery Options

Reviews for Brothers pizzeria

I thought the margherita pizza was great, especially the dough. Good amount of cheese, not too salty, recommended. I had it there while it was hot, the restaurant itself is pretty barebones.Food: 5/5

I love this pizza of shop. Its tucked away in a small town between margaretville and arkville. The pizza is handmade. I always try to go and grab us fresh slice out of the oven of either cheese or mushroom pizza right before work. They even make the bottom a little crispy for me just the way I like it.Food: 5/5

I would highly recommend this place, this is our last day in Margaretville and we wished we found it earlier. We ate at several solid restaurants here (both in Phoenicia and Fleiscanns) and this was the best food. Not much of a place to eat in.We are pizza snobs and it’s on par with with some of NYC’s better places.We had a complicated order (half meatball, half pesto, + ricotta) and they got it right. Crust has a great crisp and sauce had solid flavor.Prices were full review

More Reviews(30)


Monday 11AM - 8PM
Tuesday 11AM - 5PM
Wednesday 11AM - 8PM
Thursday 11AM - 8PM
Friday 11AM - 8PM
Saturday 11AM - 7PM
Sunday Closed