Papa Paulie's Pizza

$$ • Pizza, Chicken Wings

247 Genesee St, Auburn
(315) 253-5371

Take-Out/Delivery Options

Customers' Favorites at Papa Paulie's Pizza

Reviews for Papa Paulie's Pizza

3.7 - 54 reviews
If there is a heaven I hope it smells like Papa Paulies!!!I used to love Piccirillos pizza and literally cut my first tooth on their crust 59 years ago. When they sold the business I was heart broken but Paulies made the transition with the same recipes, quality and amazing flavor I loved as a child FLAWLESSLY!!Hands down and second to none, they are the very best pizza!I drive in at least once a month from Oswego just to get a pie from them. Crazy? Until you've had one you' full review

First ever trying a new place for pizza near me. Was excellent! They have all the toppings I like. The pizza ? had a burnt crust on the edges, but not on the bottom, was excellent ?

It’s all in the pans and the oven. The most amazing pizza you will ever have. RIP Wheel..Thanks for keeping up with an amazing tradition. I worked that oven for 2 years with the old man. God Bless. Amazing food and service!

More Reviews(54)


View all photos


Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday 3:30 - 8PM
Friday 3:30 - 8PM
Saturday 3:30 - 8PM
Sunday Closed