Sal's Pizzeria

Name: Sal's Pizzeria
Address: 41 E Genesee St, Baldwinsville, New York, 13027, US
Telephone: (315) 638-8505
Price range: $
Rating: 3.9

$ • Pizza, Italian, American

Hours:
41 E Genesee St, Baldwinsville
(315) 638-8505

Menu Order Online

About Sal's Pizzeria

Sal's Pizzeria in Baldwinsville, New York remains a popular spot for pizza lovers in the area. The restaurant offers a variety of delicious pizza options, including the classic NYC-style white pizza, which has been described as "nothing short of amazing." Customers also enjoy the chicken Reggies, which are excellent, especially when ordered medium if a bit spicy, or hotter for more heat. The pizza slices are always excellent, with specialty slices being particularly phenomenal. The staff, especially Dom, is praised for their friendly and attentive service, and the recently expanded bar area provides a different vibe from the original side, giving customers a choice based on their mood. The crispy crust of the pizza is just the right thickness, soft in the middle, and the buffalo chicken wings are praised as perfect. The restaurant also serves garlic rolls at the beginning, which are appreciated. While wait times can sometimes be longer if short-staffed, the quality of food—including sausage rolls, calzones, riggies, and lobster ravioli—makes the experience worthwhile. The pizza, like the Meatzza, is highly praised, and the wings are juicy and flavorful. The side salad is simple, with iceberg lettuce and a few other ingredients. The restaurant offers a cozy, casual atmosphere with a changing Thursday specialty menu and a bar area with TVs for sports viewing. Dining in is always a great experience, with friendly staff ensuring customers leave happy and full, often with leftovers for tomorrow. Overall, Sal's Pizzeria is a go-to spot for satisfying pizza and a fun, creative dining atmosphere.