The Gatsby at Fortune's
8315 Park Rd, Batavia
(585) 343-3750
Recent Reviews
Sort by
Atmosphere: {{ item.info.Atmosphere }}
Food: {{ item.info.Food }}
Service: {{ item.info.Service }}
Recommended dishes: {{ item.info['Recommended dishes'] }}
The restaurant is fine. I know it is an "Italian steakhouse" with some pasta dishes, some seafood dishes and steak entrees at "market price". I hate asking for prices so I settled on a pasta dish. It was okay, but the tomato sauce was very heavy if you know what I mean. I had made the reservation in advance as we were staying there but I wasn't really in the mood for a big meal. I would have liked an option for a gourmet burger or steak sandwich, so I settled on the pasta because there was really no where else to eat at that establishment that had a decent dining atmosphere. Also, I was asked when I made the reservation through Open Table, if there was a special occasion. I added that it was my wife's birthday that day. Not sure why they asked because nothing came about from it. Open Table might as well not even ask if no one pays attention to it. Just my opinion for what it's worth.
Love this place, food is always good. They give you plenty. Also love they give free play when eat there.
The food was very good and our waitress was outstanding! Very pleasant and extremely helpful!
Pleasant local place to eat. Can always depend food will be good. Pricing is fair considering recent situation with costs. Always have a very nice server. All and all a nice experience.
We eat here almost every week, and have always had great tasting food, and outstanding service. However, three of us had the Prime Rib, and it was full of gristle, and absolutely tasteless . Maybe because it was Father's Day. First "bad" meal we have ever had. The service was just OK, normally the server boxes up our left overs for us, but this time we were just given boxes to do it ourselves. It was at 4:00- 5:00 when were were there and it was NOT because they were extremely busy (service wise) We will continue dining here, maybe just never the Prime Rib.
First time ever at Fortune's Italian Steakhouse. From being seated to receiving dinner was less that ten minutes. The food was EXCELLENT!! The waitress was extremely attentive. Definitely worth a return visit.
Our server Andrea was funny, friendly energetic and served our appetizers/ dinner and dessert perfectly spaced and the food was absolutely worth the price and cooked perfectly. The front counter greeter i don't recall her name was so bubbly and happy and when she greeted us congratulated us on our 35th anniversary and when we left did the same and wished us luck in the casino. Definitely going back more often
The atmosphere was great, noise level mild. The food on the other hand was very disappointing. I ordered French onion soup, which ended up being the best part of my and my wife's meal. We ordered steak, it was so tough you could hardly stab your fork in to it. We chose to do the up charge for broccoli as we both love broccoli. It was not cooked enough and tasted like dirt. Overall dissatisfied that we chose to eat here for our Anniversary. Will never eat here again.
There were hardly any people there, yet it took 45 minutes after ordering our food to get it. Our was room temperature when they finally brought it out. They sat a couple with a baby right next to us when there were clearly other tables that would've been more appropriate. The man at the table was swearing loudly so much so that we opted not to have dessert so we could leave. Incredibly disappointed. Their prices are not at all in line with the quality of food, service or atmosphere.
I ordered the chicken pram dinner it's was so delicious ?. The restaurant is beautiful. I First time dining there. It's was great well worth eating there. I will be going back soon.
Restaurantji Recommends
My husband and I both had the monthly special (crispy chicken carbonara). It was excellent! Hopefully, it will be offered again at some point. Service was excellent, Amanda was friendly, attentive, and extremely efficient.
Diner was excellent and will return for another meal. I had the grouper and it did not look appetising but was delicious and I will have again. in the past I have had the prime rib and is one of the best in the area ,but was not offered on Tuesdays. Server, Sue was very accommodating.
Good and table service were great. Admittedly we were arrived 10 minutes late. We had to stand in line for the hostess. The hostess kept walking away and we were reprimanded for being late for our reservation.
We always have a great experience at Fortune's. Our server was Red. He was the best server we have had so far. He was efficient, tentative very knowledgeable , and accommodating . He made our time at Fortune's enjoyable.
My husband and I both had steaks which were cooked perfectly. Everything was delicious. His meal didn't come with a side which seemed strange but he added a potato and salad for $6. Overall, good experience.
Loading...