New American Restaurants near Bath, NY

“1 of the nicer dining venues in the Keuka Lake basin. Upscale menu prepared by upper crust Chef. Servers are professional and delightful to dine with. Bar maids are outstanding as well and I've yet to stump them with my "old school" drinks & cocktails. A = 4 Stars“

“Had dinner reservations and seated quickly. Host was spacing diners but he put a table of 4 loud people next to us. I couldn't even hear our waitress explain things. Throughout whole meal listened to them about the limited dinner menu, etc.. Truly no dinner etiquette. We were celebrating two years together and wanted to make this dinner truly special. Food was delicious. Chef really is an asset to the restaurant. We were double charged for one of our beverages when we received our bill. Waitress took care of it.“

“We came here with a large bus group over the weekend, there weren’t many wineries in the area accepting buses and bully hill was the perfect stop. Lunch was quick and easy on the outdoor patio and Dustin was easily one the most entertaining bartenders we were served by over the weekend he handled two separate Bach parties at the same time with expertise. Highly recommend for groups big and small“

“From the moment you step into Timberstone Grill, you are welcomed by the rustic decor and the friendly staff. The food is freshly prepared, flavorful and crafted from locally sourced ingredients and meats. But what truly sets this place apart is the desserts – lovingly made by the chef's mom, they add a delightful touch of homemade goodness to the dining experience. From farm to table, every aspect of Timberstone Grill exudes authenticity and excellence, making it a must-visit for food lovers seeking a taste of local goodness.“