Fratelli Pizzeria
553 E Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 666-0458
Customers' Favorites
Grilled Shrimp Salad with Our Home Made Salad Dressing
Pepperoni Broccoli and Spinach Pinwheels
Saute Broccoli with Garlic and Olive Oil
Chicken Sorrentino over Spaghetti
Sausage Peppers and Onions Pizza
Chicken Francese over Spaghetti
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Sausage and Peppers
Grilled Vegetables
Shrimp Oreganata
Menu
Photos
+52 photos
+51 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Best pizza place on Long Island and that’s saying a lot because I am very picky with pizza. They spend the money on good cheese so you don’t get that extremely greasy pizza. Better than any chain pizzeria on Long Island. I drive 35-40 minutes just for their pizza. Their garlic knots are top tier as well! Great people running this business. I cannot recommend enough.
I’ve been going to Fratelli Pizzeria for over 20 years, and it remains my favorite go-to spot for classic pizza. The quality and flavor have been consistently excellent throughout the years. The pizza has a perfect crust, generous toppings, and a delicious sauce that never disappoints. I always make sure to order a side of their garlic knots as well—they’re the perfect complement to the pizza, with a flavorful, buttery, and garlicky finish. Fratelli Pizzeria is a cherished...
This place is an absolute gem - the Italian food is very high quality and everything I’ve tried from there is delicious. The people who work there are also very friendly and welcoming. 10/10 recommend!
You May Also Like
Sumou Sushi & Hibachi - 551 E Main St
![]()
Japanese, Sushi Bar, Vegetarian
Bagel Boss East - 555 Montauk Hwy
![]()
Caterers, Bagels
Tropical Smoothie Cafe - 567 E Main St Unit B
![]()
Juice, Juice Bar & Smoothies