Goldy's Gems

5 Third Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 665-9596

Recent Reviews

Ron Hughes

Recently held a surprise 60th birthday party for my mother in-law and honestly had a great experience. I’ve been a regular patron of Goldy’s for since their rebirth; however, recently I inquired about their party services. The process was simple. Even doing homework, price-wise they were competitive with the going rate per person.The staff was tremendous in making the event a hit! They were accommodating, attentive - overall made the experience a pleasure! Again, I would highly recommend and will continue to frequent Goldy’s as a regular patron!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Samantha

I recently had a Birds and Bubble Brunch Buffet here for a surprise party and I was extremely happy with my event. The staff, Tiffany and Michelle, were both amazing. Goldy’s Gems is a perfect spot for a party and the guests were all talking about how great of a place it was. The service was amazing and the two employees working the party were on top of everything. The price was reasonable per person and the brunch food was very good. We had no complaints and would definitely have another party here in the future!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Adams Sanchez (Ace31220)

Great spot for a drink, always has great DJs and good people, I perfer here over a lot of other places in BayshoreAlso try their chicken sandwich I swear on my mother it's better than Popeyes or chic filaVegetarian options: Multiple vegetarian options (it's also bar food)

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Sandwich

Meghan Polis

Awesome place, great atmosphere. Good times.

Dawn F.

Hosted my sister's baby shower this past weekend at Goldy's. The Shower went so well. The staff was great, they were so attentive and helpful. The Mom to be had such a great time and everyone said the food was delicious. Great place to host an event.

Amanda Stashin

Just had my bridal shower here this weekend and it was AMAZING. It was everything I could've imagined for myself. The venue was perfect. It was a great space, easy to mingle, and there was plenty of seating. It was exactly the vibe I was looking for. Melissa was great to work with and the staff on that day were all attentive and helpful. Would absolutely have an event here again.

Carlven Joseph

Simply a great bar/venue.I recently hosted my 30th birthday celebration here, and everyone had a blast! The staff is amazing and very professional. Melissa was helpful with getting everything assituated. Johnny and Tiffany especially, provided superb service throughout the whole night and it was greatly appreciated. Johnny was amazing with his bartending skills. Tiffany was superb and attentive throughout, keeping things running smoothly while always making you feel comfortable with any questions or concerns you may have. I couldn't have asked for a better host and bartender, so thank you again Johnny and Tiffany! If you're looking for a cozy, casual bar with great food, music, drinks, and a good time, be sure to stop at Goldy's Gems.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Sandwich

KaRa StRaLey

Had a fun time dancing there. Wish there were more vegan options.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 3

Brooke S

The chicken sandwich omg the FRIES! The food was delicious and the bartender was super cool. Nice beers on tap as well! I think this is a great casual addition to the Bay Shore area. A lot of restaurants around here are very fancy so it’s nice to have another casual bar option with killer food.

Scott Butler

About a year ago my partner and I walked into Goldy’s Gems. We were greeted with sincerity and had several drinks and apps. It was then that we wanted to have our joint birthday party which evolved into our engagement party here. We were not let down in the least!!! The party was a hit thanks to Melissa, Michelle, and Tiffany. My step mom from out of town said that she never had an empty glass. To me, that is above and beyond service and consideration. The DJ they offer knew exactly what to play and we let him do his thing. We have such gratitude for it being a beautiful celebration and we will always remember!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Debra Janusz

So fun sitting next to this little rescue pup and hearing her story. Enjoyed the specialty cocktail-had only stopped in for one and ended up having a couple. Bartender was great! Conversational and made drink perfectly! Will be back next time will get some food

Michael Curatolo

Not many places for great drinks and DJ! Fun night out

Leanne R.

went here for the first time with my mom and sister yesterday! i've been dying to try this place every time we'd pass it and i'm so glad we did! so cute inside and the patio is so nice it was gorgeous out yesterday it was perfect the manager michelle was so so sweet! we initially walked in on a private event there on accident (we felt horrible there were no signs or anything indicating it was private) we went up to the bar and spoke with michelle she told us to come back in an hour so we did! and she was so sweet and said this round was on her and that she was very happy we came back and honestly after yesterday we definitely would come back again we had such a pleasant time here i can't wait to come back

Mitchel Djurik

Melissa was very helpful and helped us pick this place for my wife's surprise 30th birthday party. We had the best party ! We had about 65 people and had more than enough space. The whole staff was amazing, and the food was excellent. Especially the chicken sliders and chickpea fries we're a big hit! Definitely would recommend this place for a private event or a night out filled with dancing and drinks.

Kimberly Ifrah

I had my baby shower at Goldy's Gems this past weekend, and the whole experience was amazing! Melissa was so responsive and accommodating throughout the entire planning process. We went with the brunch package and the food and drinks were delicious. The space itself was ideal for my event, it was casual and allowed for my guests to socialize easily. Goldy's is definitely a good choice for a shower with a fun, informal and relaxing vibe!

Load More