Goody Two Shoes

42 E Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 647-4856

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Fried Chicken Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Royale
Birria Egg Rolls
Steakhouse Burger
Brunch Burger
Shortrib Mac
Truffle Honey
Small Wings
Deviled Eggs
Double Smash

Menu

Featured items
FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH
Hand-dipped breast, pickled jalapeño slaw, comeback sauce.
PUPUSAS
House made masa cakes stuffed and griddled. Braised beef and mozzarella or bean and cheese
FRENCH DIP
Bacon, cheddar, onion haystack.
MEXICAN STREET CORN DOG
Cotija cheese, chili powder, charred corn, cilantro crema.
DOUBLE SMASH
Twin smashburgers, onions, pickles, American, ketchup
LARGE WINGS
BACON JAM RIBS
Half rack of baby backs, pickled jalapeño slaw.
CLASSIC COBB
Grilled chicken, Romaine, tomatoes, black beans, avocado, roasted corn, jalapenos, jack cheese, chipotle ranch.
BEET & ARUGULA SALAD
Spiraled beets, arugula, feta, sesame seeds, house vinaigrette.
JALAPENO POTATO PANCAKES
Cilantro sour cream
SMALL WINGS
Fresh Jumbo Wings. Choose your size and your sauce.
CHOP CHEESE TACOS
Cilantro relish, salsa verde.
DEVILED EGGS
Bacon and chives.

SNACKS & BAR BUDDIES
BACON JAM RIBS
Half rack of baby backs, pickled jalapeño slaw.
CHOP CHEESE TACOS
Cilantro relish, salsa verde.
DEVILED EGGS
Bacon and chives.
JALAPENO POTATO PANCAKES
Cilantro sour cream
MEXICAN STREET CORN DOG
Cotija cheese, chili powder, charred corn, cilantro crema.
MEZZE PLATE
Zucchini-wrapped feta kabob, garlic hummus, marinated olives, house tzaziki.
PUPUSAS
House made masa cakes stuffed and griddled. Braised beef and mozzarella or bean and cheese
QUESO FRIES
Gooey goodness poured tableside!
FLATBREAD
Ricotta, clover honey, cherry peppers.
HAND PIE
SHORTRIB MAC
Gooey goodness poured tableside!
YUCCA FRIES
Spicy ranch drizzle, avocado dip.

WINGS
SMALL WINGS
Fresh Jumbo Wings. Choose your size and your sauce.
LARGE WINGS
SMALL BONELESS
Choose your size and your sauce.
LARGE BONELESS WINGS

SOUP & SALADS
BEET & ARUGULA SALAD
Spiraled beets, arugula, feta, sesame seeds, house vinaigrette.
CLASSIC COBB
Grilled chicken, Romaine, tomatoes, black beans, avocado, roasted corn, jalapenos, jack cheese, chipotle ranch.
CHOPPED SALAD
Romaine, parmesan, croutons.
SIDE SALAD
Caesar Salad With Grilled Chicken
MATZO BALL SOUP
ROASTED ROOT VEGETABLE CHILI

BURGERS & SANDWICHES
FRIED CHICKEN SANDWICH
Hand-dipped breast, pickled jalapeño slaw, comeback sauce.
FRENCH DIP
Bacon, cheddar, onion haystack.
DOUBLE SMASH
Twin smashburgers, onions, pickles, American, ketchup
PAPI CHULO
Braised beef, bacon, quest, jalapeños.
GRILLED CHICKEN ROYALE
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, truffled mayo.
STEAKHOUSE BURGER
Bacon, cheddar, onion haystack.
THE TRUFFLER

EXTRA SAUCES
Sticky Sauce
Ranch
Bleu Cheese
Garlic Aioli
Honey Mustard
Buffalo
Piri-piri
Bbq
Mayo
Regular Mustard
Truffle Honey
Carolina
Caesar

N/A Beverages
COKE
DIET COKE
SPRITE
GINGER ALE
CRANBERRY
PINEAPPLE
OJ
GRAPEFRUIT
ENERGY DRINK
CLUB SODA
LEMONADE
Tonic

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+21 photos
Photo credit: google
+20 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Me and my husband started going to this place for drinks and desserts, every time we go the staff is always very friendly and polite. We kept going back, their food is very agreeable and flavorful. Service is A plus in particular Jadon, and other waiters as well. Goody two shoes is a cool spot for us to hang out eat, drink and relax or watch a game in a very warmth environment and we are always acknowledged by their friendly and professional staff.
September 2025
The restaurant is designed wonderfully.
It has ALOT of potential. However I think the menu needs a revamp. And I’m saying because I’m a chef owner operator w 25 years in the biz.
Staff was pleasant …
September 2025
Came here for lunch, this place has a nice atmosphere and the menu is diverse. Everything we had (short rib mac&cheese, grilled chicken sandwich, yucca fries) was very good. The service was good and staff is attentive and pleasant, I would recommend!
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Costa Verde - 12 E Main St
Tap Room - 44-46 E Main St
American, Sports Bar, Tapas Bar, Gastropubs
Kiseki Sushi Hibachi & Lounge - 33 E Main St
Asian Fusion, Japanese, Sushi Bar

Goody Two Shoes

42 E Main St, Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631) 647-4856