The Penny Pub
79 W Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 969-4061
Customers' Favorites
Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese with Chipotle Ranch for Dipping
Buffalo or Irish Whiskey BBQ Chicken Quesadilla
Penny Pub Chicken Club
The Penny Burger
Penny Pretzels
Fish & Chips
Dublin Dip
Menu
Photos
+49 photos
+48 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I stopped in for a couple of Guinnesses and something to eat. Decided on the Irish Grilled Cheese and waffle fries. The grilled cheese was good. Not great. The fries were great. The Guinness was good and the service attentive.
I have been coming there since 1986 ! Went it was the half penny
Great place to watch the football games and the people are really nice and friendly and the food is really good!
Great place to watch the football games and the people are really nice and friendly and the food is really good!
Sean Is the Heart of The Penny Pub
After a tough day, I walked into The Penny Pub in Bay Shore just looking for a place to decompress. What I found was more than just a great local spot—it was a reminder that good people make all the difference.
Sean, the bartender, immediately picked up on the fact that I wasn’t having the best day. Without being overbearing, he made me feel welcome, comfortable, and at ease. He struck that perfect balance...
After a tough day, I walked into The Penny Pub in Bay Shore just looking for a place to decompress. What I found was more than just a great local spot—it was a reminder that good people make all the difference.
Sean, the bartender, immediately picked up on the fact that I wasn’t having the best day. Without being overbearing, he made me feel welcome, comfortable, and at ease. He struck that perfect balance...
You May Also Like
Salt & Barrel - 61 W Main St
![]()
Seafood, American, Cocktail Bar, New American, Vegan
Pecado Mexican - 49 W Main St
![]()
Mexican, Cocktail Bar