The Penny Pub
79 W Main St, Bay Shore
(631) 969-4061
Customers' Favorites
Homemade Fried Mac & Cheese with Chipotle Ranch for Dipping
Buffalo or Irish Whiskey BBQ Chicken Quesadilla
Penny Pub Chicken Club
The Penny Burger
Penny Pretzels
Fish & Chips
Dublin Dip
Menu
Photos
+48 photos
+47 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I'm new to Long Island and this was the first bar I ever went to out here. The atmosphere is fun and they don't blast music to where you can't carry a conversation. The food is incredibly good and priced good. All of the bartenders I've had are nice and quick at getting your food orders in and keeping your drinks full. Highly recommend going here ?
Mike And Allison were great! They did a catering event for the Irish American Celebration ?? ? ? ? at the H Lee Dennison Building at 3/27 2:00 pm - 4:00 pm. They were both professional,.kind, smiling a lot, and had a great sene of humor. Mike and Allison great outfitd on support the Irish American Celebration. They brought the atmosphere with them. Allison the bartender deserves every tip she gets. Mike and Allison worked hard catering.They have a small kitchen and their quality...
Always come for the food was here on 2/20 and my id was scanned but a few weeks ago was not, so my issue was that people walked in and did not have to scan the id but my id was then my fiancé drinks cognac and they so not serve that so we asked what they have on the menu the bartender did not offer they margarita Monday special at all n charged us for a double if casamigo but we surely never asked for a double I was unleashed with how we were treated by the bartender he wasn’t...
You May Also Like
Salt & Barrel - 61 W Main St
![]()
Seafood, American, Cocktail Bar, New American, Vegan
Corks and Taps - 53 W Main St
![]()
American, Wine Bar, Cocktail Bar, New American, Vegetarian
Pecado Mexican - 49 W Main St
![]()
Mexican, Cocktail Bar