The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
11 Maple Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 686-3555
Customers' Favorites
Vodka Margherita Pizza with Mushrooms
Gluten Free Margarita Pizza
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Caprese Street Sandwich
Upside Down Caputo Pie
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Buffalo Garlic Knots
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Uncle Benny Slice
Chicken Parm Hero
Menu
Photos
+8 photos
+7 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I had the best chicken parm sandwich with vodka sauce, and it was nothing short of spectacular. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and the sandwich was cooked to perfection. My friend enjoyed an amazing chicken salad, which was fresh and full of flavor. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service made our visit even more enjoyable. A fantastic spot for a delicious meal!
“Fantastic pizza and a great atmosphere! Even in the outdoor room, the experience is cozy and welcoming. The staff is friendly, and the food is always fresh and delicious. Highly recommend for a casual and enjoyable dining experience!”
You May Also Like
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar - 12 E Main St
![]()
Cocktail Bar, Caribbean, Tapas/Small Plates, Vegan
Milano Bean Cafe - 6 E Main St
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee, Coffee & Tea
Frank & Maria's Italian Market - 10 W Main St
![]()
Italian, Butcher, Specialty Food
First, I went here with my parents after visiting Fire Island, and they enjoyed the pizza here. It was Sicilian and the taste of dough was fantastic. FYI, the pizza I uploaded is not Sicilian, I just regret not to take the photo of it.