The Pizzeria of Bay Shore
11 Maple Ave, Bay Shore
(631) 686-3555
Customers' Favorites
Vodka Margherita Pizza with Mushrooms
Gluten Free Margarita Pizza
Caprese Street Sandwich
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pie
Upside Down Caputo Pie
Buffalo Chicken Slice
Buffalo Garlic Knots
Buffalo Chicken Pie
Chicken Parm Hero
Uncle Benny Slice
Menu
Photos
+11 photos
+10 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Pizza for lunch, dinner and dessert! This is a fun bustling spot especially on a summer Sunday eve. We were four and tried four different slices. They all were honey glazed. The two with meat (pepperoni, homemade sausage) were fantastic with the sweet and salty thing really working. The other two, a plain and a margherita were very good, though we all thought they were too sweet.
A Bayshore Gem. Incredible Food & Even Better People! I can honestly say I’ve never been to a place that welcomes my family and me with such genuine kindness. From the moment you walk in, the team is extremely attentive, making you feel less like a customer and more like part of the family.
We love this spot so much that it has become our official weekly family date night. The regular menu is always amazing, but we also love checking out their seasonal specials....
We love this spot so much that it has become our official weekly family date night. The regular menu is always amazing, but we also love checking out their seasonal specials....
The Penne Alla Vodka was sooo delicious. ( I ate two plates of this by the way) the grilled chicken, soft and juicy with a side of there mini garlic knots! Definitely hit the spot. I love ordering from them.
You May Also Like
Coastal Kitchen & Daiquiri Bar - 12 E Main St
![]()
Cocktail Bar, Caribbean, Tapas/Small Plates, Vegan
Frank & Maria's Italian Market - 10 W Main St
![]()
Italian, Butcher, Specialty Food