Bella Pizza

376 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 931-0139

Recent Reviews

Lindsey G.

Ordered 2 chicken parmesan hero sandwiches and two large salads with ranch dressing everything was fresh well cooked and Taste delicious, highly recommend ordering here or dining in if you have not tried and are in the area

Jihye B.

I had to get a catering order in quickly for a weekday event. The gentleman who took care of my order was so helpful. He offered choices that were good for the event size and type. The storefront is a little difficult to get to during dinner time because it shares the parking lot with a very popular restaurant that does a valet service for their patrons, which means cars and crammed and lined up where you need to go. Villa Maria has a few of their parking spots, so as long as you're able to get through the mess in the front, there should be space in the back. They threw in garlic bread for free & made sure that the food was packaged very well. I had brought my own boxes to anticipate difficult transfer, but there was no need. Food was pretty good, stayed hot until I needed to serve it. It looks a little run down inside, but I would say this is a pretty solid joint for take-out. I would order a catering package from them again.

Diane V.

Great specia! Pizza delicious & ready when I arrived to pick up. Friendly service. I would definitely order & pick up again

Salvatrice M.

Take out is always fast, fresh and piping hot!Pasta dishes are authentic and impressive for a pizzeria!The Carbonara was excellent as are the arancini!We will order again!

Jeff K.

Pizza was satisfactory, price was very good, guys who work there seem like good guys. They're about 30 yards away from a dominos, if you go there instead of this place, you're crazy. Places like villa maria deserve our business.

Iacovos T.

Was there today. Thought the pizza was great. The crust was thin and crunchy, the cheese and sauce was flavorful. The garlic knots were also very good. Fresh garlic and a decent amount of olive oil. I will be coming back with the family!

Elisanna B.

They are generally good but they haven't gotten our order right a few times however they always make it right so I like that. There pizza is mostly consistent but not really a fan of the garlic knots. I really like mine with a crusty top and there's are always super garlicky. Even with this they are one of our regular places.

Seth R.

Great neighborhood Italian place excellent food at reasonable prices I think they started having special events on selected nights

Jeffrey S.

I grabbed lunch here, one regular slice with tomato's and one sausage. I would rate the pizza above average 7/10. It tasted good, nothing beats pizza from a NY pizzeria! The gentleman at the register was kind and in the future I will order more pizza again soon.

Michael S.

[this review is about the "Magic Bag" from the Too Good To Go app] Quick and smooth pick-up. Lots of food (see photo), Good quality. What more do you want? (No, really; what else should I write about it?)

Raven M.

My only regret is that I didn't order from them right when we moved to the neighborhood! The food is so delicious! They offer great specials and everything we have ordered has been yummy and large portions! The garlic knots are so good! And the pizza crust is crunchy and delish! This pizzeria is by far the best we've had since moving to the area in 2019. It has become a weekly go-to for us! Totally recommend!

Angie B.

I ordered the 18" pizza pie special. 12 knots. And a soda. Pizza is delicious. Flavorful. Garlic knots are the best I have ever had. Worth ordering from. Their specials are def worth the price.

Eric S.

We did the Christmas Eve special. The food was delicious and plentiful. I couldn't be happier. Great place

Charles Levine

grilled octopus and prosciutto w/ Bella Pizza appetizers highly recommended. for large groups, the pasta tasting menu is great.

Jack Williams

the pizza was excellent, but the appetizers and side dishes were equally good. Also, the service was excellent. the restaurant was casual but the service was fine dining.

Load More