Nostalgia

380 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 342-1732

Recent Reviews

Bryan Rose

Lives up to its name. Good bands and cold beers.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Frank Parisi

Bartender working was doing karaoke when we got there and not very attentive or service oriented. As someone in the industry for 20+ years I tend to be overly critical but wasn't the only one there that night who felt that way. Otherwise loved the atmosphere and concept. Great drink menu. Everything including the bathroom gave me all my 90s vibes and more

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 2

Patty Dodge

Great place with awesome staff and owners! Enjoy Live music and Good times

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Randy Tran

I went here for the first time last night for a local electronic dance music event and had a amazing time. The ambience, decor, and vibes were great! This place really gives me nostalgia for the 90's. Oh how time flies..Also, the bartender named Shaun was super helpful and friendly. Thank you Shaun for making me feel welcomed!

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Nicholas Jerome

didnt try food. a bit pricey but live entertainment dictates that. i enjoyed myself. rarely see edm or Dubstep in

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

A B

Honestly I saw this place on tiktok and thought it looked cool. Figured it was going to be a younger crowed but it wasn’t. Walked in and I don’t mind old people but I’m going to a 90’s throwback place that I drove an hour and a half to see. It was literally a “90 year old” throwback. Left in pure disappointment.

Atmosphere: 1

Mike Thompson

Parking is annoying, otherwise fun bar with live music and nostalgic

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

A Two No

The school quality cafeteria food is absolutely disgusting. The drinks are weak and the service is terrible. There are so many other places in the area, so don’t waste your money here. They use Kraft singles and don’t even toast the buns, tator tots were cold and soggy.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

anonymous

i went to nostalgia, the band was great, the bartenders were quick, and the drinks were delicious. I will definitely be

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: MB Piggy Nablanket

Carlos E.

5 star dive/vibe bar they got Guinness depending on the bartender you can have 5 diff experience all good though. Def go if u miss the 90's

Donna Hepworth

Memories of the 90s all over ! Awesome. .bartenders great. Live music.Cozy little bar but still room to move around and dance. parking on side road was only bummer. Parking lot is shared and small.Wheelchair accessibility: Too crowded for a wheelchair. But technically is accessible.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: New Wings, Totally Retro Fries

elle ash

Went here with friend this past weekend and the service was pretty terrible and awkward. They have an entire food and drink menu on their website and when we got there, we asked if there was a physical menu, to which the bartender (a lady) said, "we do but we aren't serving most of the food" with no other explanation. One of my friends asked if there were any burgers being served and she said "I have never cooked a burger in my life and we're out of buns"-- no apology or explanation of what was available. This continued for a bit and by q&a we learned they did have mozz sticks. She eventually switched shifts with another bartender and we watched him drop the garnishment on the dirty bar before just picking it up and putting it in another customers drink. Excellent theme/concept & decor, terrible service execution. Oh and it was almost $17 for a pretty basic cocktail. Parking was also terrible.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Samantha Sergio

It was too small and too crowded to even go in. The band was even blocking the entrance.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 4

Tiffany O.

Awesome experience at Nostalgia. Came for a trivia night. Service from Marco the bartender/trivia host was impeccable. The decor bought me back to my youth with the movies, shows, toys and games displayed. Some of the televisions even had shows playing. I loved the "child menu" food items such as pigs in a blanket, Dino nuggets, fries and pizza (but who am I kidding? I still eat that now). However, their menu is so fun with the names and displayed in a VHS cassette. Drinks were tasty and not too strong. Such a fun night out and will definitely be back! Highly recommend if you're a 80s/90s baby. 2000s babies stay away no one likes you (jk kinda)

Justin V.

I had a great time at Nostalgia, the night I went, there was a great group of indie artists coming together and performing right as you walk in. Good vibes all around, great artwork and 90s memorabilia. I didn't have too much to drink or eat, but the bartender was really chill and a musician as well (Marceux) As mentioned before, parking is really tight. See if you can park across the street a couple blocks away and hoof it over.

Load More