One Eye Jacks

380 N Wantagh Ave, Bethpage
(516) 342-1732

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Stevie Rodd

Under new ownership, named "Nostalgia". Really cool bar, nice layout, good drinks, good food, friendly bartenders and a GREAT vibe. You should definitely check this place out!

Lisa Giangregorio

Always A Great Time At One Eye Jacks Pleasant Works Behind Bar

Catch Me If You Can

Great local bar for live music in Long Island.

Kevin Torlincasi

Good times at One Eye Jack's. Pete and Lisa are the best.

Paul Engle

You have got to be kidding me for those of you that gave it 4 stars. YOU NEED TO GET OUT MORE. They were the worst bartenders I've ever experienced and I'm 56 go anywhere else

Kaneik Nasheim-Morris Brown O’Kennedy

Can’t wait to hit the stage

Sara Letterill

Great atmosphere, strong drinks and live entertainment. What's not to like ?

Anthony Cucci

How hard is it to get a bathroom that locks

Marianne Lee

Edwrds headlined at OEJ‘s yesterday and overall we had a fabulous show. Good was delicious and the drinks and shots were delicious!! Great bartender who kept up with us all. Pete and Juan run a really clean venue that is perfect for Artists who are looking for a a place that holds roughly 40-50 people easily and still be comfortable. There is also a patio in back with tables for people for the warmer months. We will be back!!

Deborah Williams

It was awesome!!!! Watched my friend Sara light up like a christmas tree. We had a very good time, even though I was tired from the drive. It was worth it.

al C

Came here to hear Collideoscope play on a Friday night. THE BAND Rocked. This place has a nice atmosphere and good selection of drinks.

Francis Senerchia

Great spot for comedy shows- quaint and cozy

Bethpage Taxi and Airport Service

Great bar in Bethpage NY

dave scheerer

There was the most beautiful blonde....

Krista Marie

I recently had my 40th birthday at One Eye Jacks and I honestly can not say enough about Pete and his staff. They were so attentive and on top of everything, there is not one thing that we had to ask for. They made sure I was enjoying myself and my hand was never empty, they always had a drink ready to go. Everyone who came to the party raved about what a great place it was and how it was the best party. I will for sure have another party there, 100%. If anyone is looking to have a party there I highly recommend them! Thank you again Pete and your staff for making it such a memorable birthday!

Loading...