This is the most casual dining spot at the Sagamore resort. Service is slower and attention to detail in food prep isn't as good as the other options at the resort. This seems to be the best spot to bring young kids for dinner. Might be worth trying if you're staying there, but I'd opt for Caldwell's or La Bella Vita instead.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Toni Haberacker
Came here for the ice bar event... I thought it would be a timely manner because we were seated so quickly.. 10 mins after we were seated the waiter finely came to take out drink order.. it took 20 mins for us to receive 3 non alcoholic drinks. When that finally came he took our order just for it to take another 30 mins to come to the table, the food was cold and I did not even get what I ordered, i was so annoyed i did not bother addressing it. we did not get the truffle fries that were ordered. my mother-in-law ordered a nother drink only for it to come 5 mins befor the check was given... unfortunately we will never eat here again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
C. K.
The hotel is the best - 5 out of 5 every time. But this new restaurant bugged me the most mainly b/c I ordered a wedge salad - standard restaurant fare. It was around $15. When it arrived I was shocked. A wedge is usually a half or a quarter of an iceberg head. This was a quarter of a quarter. It was two teeny tiny slivers (not wedges) of iceberg and then piled with all the good stuff. The iceberg is what they skimped on - the iceberg that probably costs 25 cents a head (I'm being generous). I was offended. I love the Sag but c'mon - really? Iceberg????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Morgan McNulty
Been here 3 times and food is phenomenal every time! Also priced wonderfully. 10/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Maddy Foley
First time here! Great appetizers! No reservations needed. They had live music on the night we went, which was great. We also sat outside and they had heaters out there in case it was too chilly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shyanne Rosetti
Had a fantastic dinner at La Bella Vita to kick off my best friend’s bachelorette weekend. Our server Riley took excellent care of us!
Jo-AnnVilla
Twice hit this bar, Friday and Saturday afternoon during the ice festival at the end of January. Chicken buffalo dish both times, absolutely delish. Cocktails pulled together by Piper - who is amazing- both refreshing and on point. Fantastic pub and wait staff, Sagamore, keep it up!
Dorothy R
The staff was lovely. Lots of personal attention and the view on the patio was spectacular. For two below average burgers @20 each, one lackluster watery martini special @15, a soda and one dessert the total price with tip was ridiculous. Since my tip covered the excellent service I guess the view cost 50 bucks.
ChestnutShed2021
Nice place to catch dinner and listen to live music - we also found that you can do take out from here, which when the kids are tired is a great alternative.
cyase
The waitress, i believe her name is Gayle, made me give this 5 stars. From the start she picked up on cues from my daughter and made it a personal experience. She heard my daughter saying a few of her sight words and with every visit to the table she would have those sight words written somewhere. Aside from the wonderful service the food was also top notch! We started with the nachos and had them topped with chili. The order was huge. We did not expect that big a portion size. My wife could have just shared that with me and not even order a main. I had the burger topped with bacon, mushrooms, and fried onions which was phenomenal. All in all it was a great introduction for us at the Sagamore
This super cozy and warm pub in the Sagamore Resort provides a unique getaway with a not so impressive menu. The bar is wonderful as was the bartender when we went. Had their burgers with chips. The menu is limited but the service is great and the main dining area is surrounded with large windows for optimal viewing of the grounds. If they upped their game on the food side we would make an effort to have meals here in the future. For now we prefer the Caldwells Bar and Lounge area on the main Sagamore Hotel Level
JDayts
Excellent choice for a meal at the Sagamore, downstairs with true pub atmosphere or eat on the terrace with heaters in the fall. Super burger and salad.
Kimberly I
They extended the outside seating for this spot due to COVID. Its more work for the servers, but it's a win for diners who want to enjoy the lovely evening weather and the views. Our sever was outstanding. He realized that the drink I ordered wasn't as he described it. Told me to keep sipping on that one while he went back to the bar and had them redo it. (I didn't ask him to do this, he offered). The hostess was also super friendly and helpful. They do enforce use of masks when not sitting, in full compliance with NY State regs, but are very polite. So give them a break and be kind. they are working hard and in masks the whole time. Our food was good. it took a bit longer to get to us than normal, but once again, they were traveling a lot further from the kitchen and working with COVID regs. So all in all, a pleasant eating experience.
KathleenAnn2019
Cozy Adirondack pub style dining experience. Good burgers. Great service at lunch but disappointed with dinner service when it was busy. My soup was cold by the time my waiter finally brought me a spoon. I’ve dined there several times and that as the only time I was not happy with the service. I’d definitely eat there again.
Augustus117
Good beer, good service, completely average food. Four of us ordered four different things. Burger, sandwiches, pasta dish. All totally average. Server was pleasant and working hard.
This is the most casual dining spot at the Sagamore resort. Service is slower and attention to detail in food prep isn't as good as the other options at the resort. This seems to be the best spot to bring young kids for dinner. Might be worth trying if you're staying there, but I'd opt for Caldwell's or La Bella Vita instead.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Came here for the ice bar event... I thought it would be a timely manner because we were seated so quickly.. 10 mins after we were seated the waiter finely came to take out drink order.. it took 20 mins for us to receive 3 non alcoholic drinks. When that finally came he took our order just for it to take another 30 mins to come to the table, the food was cold and I did not even get what I ordered, i was so annoyed i did not bother addressing it. we did not get the truffle fries that were ordered. my mother-in-law ordered a nother drink only for it to come 5 mins befor the check was given... unfortunately we will never eat here again.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
The hotel is the best - 5 out of 5 every time. But this new restaurant bugged me the most mainly b/c I ordered a wedge salad - standard restaurant fare. It was around $15. When it arrived I was shocked. A wedge is usually a half or a quarter of an iceberg head. This was a quarter of a quarter. It was two teeny tiny slivers (not wedges) of iceberg and then piled with all the good stuff. The iceberg is what they skimped on - the iceberg that probably costs 25 cents a head (I'm being generous). I was offended. I love the Sag but c'mon - really? Iceberg????
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Been here 3 times and food is phenomenal every time! Also priced wonderfully. 10/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time here! Great appetizers! No reservations needed. They had live music on the night we went, which was great. We also sat outside and they had heaters out there in case it was too chilly.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Had a fantastic dinner at La Bella Vita to kick off my best friend’s bachelorette weekend. Our server Riley took excellent care of us!
Twice hit this bar, Friday and Saturday afternoon during the ice festival at the end of January. Chicken buffalo dish both times, absolutely delish. Cocktails pulled together by Piper - who is amazing- both refreshing and on point. Fantastic pub and wait staff, Sagamore, keep it up!
The staff was lovely. Lots of personal attention and the view on the patio was spectacular. For two below average burgers @20 each, one lackluster watery martini special @15, a soda and one dessert the total price with tip was ridiculous. Since my tip covered the excellent service I guess the view cost 50 bucks.
Nice place to catch dinner and listen to live music - we also found that you can do take out from here, which when the kids are tired is a great alternative.
The waitress, i believe her name is Gayle, made me give this 5 stars. From the start she picked up on cues from my daughter and made it a personal experience. She heard my daughter saying a few of her sight words and with every visit to the table she would have those sight words written somewhere. Aside from the wonderful service the food was also top notch! We started with the nachos and had them topped with chili. The order was huge. We did not expect that big a portion size. My wife could have just shared that with me and not even order a main. I had the burger topped with bacon, mushrooms, and fried onions which was phenomenal. All in all it was a great introduction for us at the Sagamore
Restaurantji Recommends
This super cozy and warm pub in the Sagamore Resort provides a unique getaway with a not so impressive menu. The bar is wonderful as was the bartender when we went. Had their burgers with chips. The menu is limited but the service is great and the main dining area is surrounded with large windows for optimal viewing of the grounds. If they upped their game on the food side we would make an effort to have meals here in the future. For now we prefer the Caldwells Bar and Lounge area on the main Sagamore Hotel Level
Excellent choice for a meal at the Sagamore, downstairs with true pub atmosphere or eat on the terrace with heaters in the fall. Super burger and salad.
They extended the outside seating for this spot due to COVID. Its more work for the servers, but it's a win for diners who want to enjoy the lovely evening weather and the views. Our sever was outstanding. He realized that the drink I ordered wasn't as he described it. Told me to keep sipping on that one while he went back to the bar and had them redo it. (I didn't ask him to do this, he offered). The hostess was also super friendly and helpful. They do enforce use of masks when not sitting, in full compliance with NY State regs, but are very polite. So give them a break and be kind. they are working hard and in masks the whole time. Our food was good. it took a bit longer to get to us than normal, but once again, they were traveling a lot further from the kitchen and working with COVID regs. So all in all, a pleasant eating experience.
Cozy Adirondack pub style dining experience. Good burgers. Great service at lunch but disappointed with dinner service when it was busy. My soup was cold by the time my waiter finally brought me a spoon. I’ve dined there several times and that as the only time I was not happy with the service. I’d definitely eat there again.
Good beer, good service, completely average food. Four of us ordered four different things. Burger, sandwiches, pasta dish. All totally average. Server was pleasant and working hard.
Loading...