Sweet Sam's Baking Company

1261 Seabury Ave, Bronx
(718) 822-0599

Recent Reviews

Sort by
les zephyr

So, this is the first time this has EVER happened to me in 70 years. (Yes, kids, you will still like baked goods when you're mature) So, I find Sweet Sam's Cinnamon & Walnut pound cake totally by happenstance. OMGoddess! This was the best dang store bought cake I have ever had. It was just sweet enough. How the heck they are able to keep the moistness in a product and ship it across county is beyond me. So, since I have now fallen in love (yes, one can love a pound cake, keep judgements in the kale section) there is only one problem. I can't find the freaking cinnamon & walnut anywhere. Oh, I can find Sweet Sam's, but not the cinnamon/walnut. I have been to 8 brick and mortar stores, called even more and phoned the company.
The first guy I spoke with could have cared less about my situation. I was not to be detoured and pressed on. The second person I came in contact with was/is a lovely person named Lyn. She reached out via email and over the course of several days researched where I might find my love interest. Sadly, all she could do was find distributors....for no lack of trying and I thank her! There seems to be a disconnect between the company, distributors and the actual retail outlets. However, I can't afford $225.00 for a large order. No, I don't want to pay a shipping charge from the east coast that costs more than the 4 pack of cakes. I simply want to go into a store (yes, I'll travel) and purchase a pound cake. It should not be this difficult. It's as though I discovered a chest of gold in the desert and only found one doubloon inside. You get me hooked on a fabulous baked good only to deny me further enjoyment. So, as for the product....17 Stars, for the difficulty and obtaining said product....-*.

Nancy Petrone

I had one of your oatmeal raisin cookies at the Walnut Street Theater in Philadelphia. I try not to buy packaged cookies but the lady at the counter said they were delicious. She was absolutely correct!!! Best cookie ever. Read the ingredients and wow! Keep up the good work. Now I’ll get one every time we go to a show.

Anastasia Kincaid

Ab best pound cake I’ve ever had! Loved the lemon iced. Need to try carrot cake next!

Dawn Johnson

I came across this bakery on Christmas day. I wanted something sweet and everything was closed except for this app called Go Puff. I laid my eyes on this blueberry muffin with this buttery crumb topping and this streusel coffee cake. They were so moist and delicious that the next day I ordered the last they had. You can tell this company takes pride in high quality ingredients made with love because each sweet treat was consistently damn good. I went online but I think they only sell wholesale I wished they could sell to me cause I'll freeze some for later.

Yvonne S

Tried an oatmeal raisin cookie at the hospital my son is staying at. And oh my goodness I was shocked how great it tastes reminding me of my mom’s oatmeal raisin cookies. I went immediately to the ingredients and was so happy to see basic baking ingredients, no strange things I can’t pronounce.

Sally Ferguson

Best big cupcakes!!! Try at a new restaurant Georgnia's in New Hampshire. We went back foe more.

Josh Barrett

The Amtrak blueberry muffins need to have blueberries. QC!

Clara Baker

Sweet Sam's Baking Company has been an absolute gem to us their Cakes, Cup Cakes, and all other Treats are simply amazing I can eat them every day. Sweet Sam's Bakery is the best Bakery I have ever tried. Thank you Sweet Sam for always answering the call your company is THE BEST YOU ROCK!!!!!!!!

Steve Clark

Best B&Ws in all of NYC (and I’ve tried them all, or at least most of them!). I have them shipped to me here in Utah, and I don’t even care the shipping charges are a bit high, cause it’s worth every penny!

Skip Eick

Tried for the first time at the hospital where my mom is currently. Figured what the heck, hospital food is what it is....what a surprise!! Could not be further from the truth, moist, flavorful, and a true delicious piece of delight!! My wife laughs now, because as soon as we get to the hospital, it is a bee line to the cafeteria to get two or three pieces of their cake!!Hate that I am sharing this secret, but figure you all can't go to where I get mine-LOL!!Enjoy!!!

Chef Jose

Great products! Lemon Ice Cake is awesome!

Maria Mayancela

They have very good cakes ? and the bread ? very good

Coco Castro

The chocolate slice cake I'm addicted to it, very ?? good!

Matthew Manor

Great company! Great communication. Thoughtful of their customers. Product received fast.The pound cake is delicious.New customer, soon to be return customers.Big thanks from OHIO

Bria Flores

I love the cranberry walnut pound cake and the lemon pound cake melts in your mouth delicious ? I want to try EVERYTHING!!!

Loading...