No prices listed and very expensive compared to others in the neighborhood.
Thomas Murtagh
This has been my go to spot in terms of bagels ever since I moved here a year ago. The bagels are massive and it’s a great bacon egg and cheese. Definitely up there with some of the best bagel spots in the city for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jesse Chertoff
Got a gluten free bagel with veggie cream cheese, lox, onion, & tomato. I go to eat it nearby. After wolfing down a half in two bites I realized there was no fish on it. I brought it back and the staff asked me where the other half was. I told them it took me eating it to realize there was no fish on it. They looked at me like I was crazy or a problematic customer. They clearly made a mistake. No apology no nothing. They rushed to make me another one but it wasn’t toasted and the made it in a roughshod manner to get me out of their hair. It was no good without being toasted. I won’t ever be back. Staff was totally rude for no reason.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Bobby Blue
Their Pumpernickel bagel is the best in the world
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Louis Mazzei
A monstrosity of a bagel... but in a good way!
Got a pumpernickel everything with veg cream cheese, lettuce & tomato
Fran Ehrlich
Our family loves the Bagel Pub. The food is always fresh. The portions are generous and the service is first rate. There are a lot of reasons to choose this restaurant over all the others in the area. But the main reason we go is the wonderful JoAnna who manages this location. JoAnna welcomes us warmly every time we visit (and one of our family goes to "The Pub" every day!). JoAnna's team loves her. They are a well tuned machine that provide caring and gracious service to every customer. If you have to wait for your special order the wait time is brief. You'll never see the staff standing around, looking at their phones or disregarding you. JoAnna makes certain that everyone is well served with a genuine smile and gracious thanks for choosing Bagel Pub over other eateries. We initially went to the Bagel Pub for convenience. Now, we go there to see our friend JoAnna, and know that we are just one family of many who enjoy her warmth and expert management. Go to the Bagel Pub! You won't be disappointed. We hope you find this review helpful. Respectfully submitted
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anna Montanez
Love the muffins!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Sam S
Over 11 dollars for a BEC..
Michael Cheng
bagels are delish and huge cream cheese selection as well, wait is pretty intense during the breakfast rush tho, would come back for egg everything with lox on scallion cc
Sara Maples
Amazing place! In NYC for a few days & we plan to go back AGAIN. It was SO fantastic! Staff was friendly and it was such a fun vibe.
Please open one in the suburbs of Philadelphia or in Philly. It would do great in King of Prussia PA.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Any Bagel
erhmei yuan
Quality has gone way down. Have been coming here for 10 years. Don’t think I’ll be back soon.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Alicia Proulx
Delicious bagels with a huge selection of cream cheeses and freshly brewed coffee. We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael L
Really enjoyed my bagel. Cream cheese quantity was perfect, and the bagel was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sophie Woods
I love Bagel Pub! The bagels are delicious - some of the best in Park Slope. I was, however, disheartened when I arrived to pick up an order for 2 dozen bagels I had called in days prior and paid for over the phone. I arrived 30 minutes after the scheduled pick up time and the order was not ready. The person I spoke to at the counter was quite cold, dismissive and short with me. They seemed rather confident that the mistake was on my end. They suggested that I placed the order with the wrong location, that I hadn’t placed it at all, etc. Because I placed the order and paid over the phone, I did not have a physical receipt so I showed the staff member the transaction on my bank account and the phone call to their location in my phone’s history. I was still met with the same dismissive attitude and I was told “we need an actual receipt” though that was never even given to me. After a few minutes of waiting I was simply told “we have the order”. It was filled and I was grateful to be able to get what I had purchased. In a situation such as this, one would hope for a simple apology or even a small discount. But I received no such thing. I remained calm and cordial during this frustrating interaction and wish I had received the same in return. Bagel Pub is wonderful and I just hope this was a hiccup or the result of a bad day.
No prices listed and very expensive compared to others in the neighborhood.
This has been my go to spot in terms of bagels ever since I moved here a year ago. The bagels are massive and it’s a great bacon egg and cheese. Definitely up there with some of the best bagel spots in the city for me.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Got a gluten free bagel with veggie cream cheese, lox, onion, & tomato. I go to eat it nearby. After wolfing down a half in two bites I realized there was no fish on it. I brought it back and the staff asked me where the other half was. I told them it took me eating it to realize there was no fish on it. They looked at me like I was crazy or a problematic customer. They clearly made a mistake. No apology no nothing. They rushed to make me another one but it wasn’t toasted and the made it in a roughshod manner to get me out of their hair. It was no good without being toasted. I won’t ever be back. Staff was totally rude for no reason.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Their Pumpernickel bagel is the best in the world
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A monstrosity of a bagel... but in a good way!
Got a pumpernickel everything with veg cream cheese, lettuce & tomato
Our family loves the Bagel Pub. The food is always fresh. The portions are generous and the service is first rate. There are a lot of reasons to choose this restaurant over all the others in the area. But the main reason we go is the wonderful JoAnna who manages this location. JoAnna welcomes us warmly every time we visit (and one of our family goes to "The Pub" every day!). JoAnna's team loves her. They are a well tuned machine that provide caring and gracious service to every customer. If you have to wait for your special order the wait time is brief. You'll never see the staff standing around, looking at their phones or disregarding you. JoAnna makes certain that everyone is well served with a genuine smile and gracious thanks for choosing Bagel Pub over other eateries. We initially went to the Bagel Pub for convenience. Now, we go there to see our friend JoAnna, and know that we are just one family of many who enjoy her warmth and expert management. Go to the Bagel Pub! You won't be disappointed. We hope you find this review helpful. Respectfully submitted
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love the muffins!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Over 11 dollars for a BEC..
bagels are delish and huge cream cheese selection as well, wait is pretty intense during the breakfast rush tho, would come back for egg everything with lox on scallion cc
Amazing place! In NYC for a few days & we plan to go back AGAIN. It was SO fantastic! Staff was friendly and it was such a fun vibe.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Any Bagel
Restaurantji Recommends
Please open one in the suburbs of Philadelphia or in Philly. It would do great in King of Prussia PA.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Any Bagel
Quality has gone way down. Have been coming here for 10 years. Don’t think I’ll be back soon.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 1
Delicious bagels with a huge selection of cream cheeses and freshly brewed coffee. We will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Really enjoyed my bagel. Cream cheese quantity was perfect, and the bagel was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I love Bagel Pub! The bagels are delicious - some of the best in Park Slope.
I was, however, disheartened when I arrived to pick up an order for 2 dozen bagels I had called in days prior and paid for over the phone. I arrived 30 minutes after the scheduled pick up time and the order was not ready. The person I spoke to at the counter was quite cold, dismissive and short with me. They seemed rather confident that the mistake was on my end. They suggested that I placed the order with the wrong location, that I hadn’t placed it at all, etc. Because I placed the order and paid over the phone, I did not have a physical receipt so I showed the staff member the transaction on my bank account and the phone call to their location in my phone’s history. I was still met with the same dismissive attitude and I was told “we need an actual receipt” though that was never even given to me. After a few minutes of waiting I was simply told “we have the order”. It was filled and I was grateful to be able to get what I had purchased. In a situation such as this, one would hope for a simple apology or even a small discount. But I received no such thing. I remained calm and cordial during this frustrating interaction and wish I had received the same in return. Bagel Pub is wonderful and I just hope this was a hiccup or the result of a bad day.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Loading...