Brooklyn Farmacy & Soda Fountain

Cute spot but I went for the hot chocolate and it was not what I expected. It’s just powder cocoa, I was looking for the thick kinda hot chocolate.

This place is truly awesome. The decor is out of this world, and the desserts were excellent, as was the coffee. I really loved it.

Amazing selection of ice cream and perfect themeing inside.

I tried the ginger soda with vanilla ice cream and it was okay-ish, not a lot of ginger nor vanilla flavor on them. The service was okay tooish too, the person who seatted us was not very nice.

Not worth the hype. The sodas are good but skip the sundaes and save your money. We ordered the Sir Twix Alot ($16) and received a cup full of shortbread cookies and ONE scoop of vanilla ice cream with a little chocolate.

Thought it was a bit pricey at first but totally worth it was i tried the ice cream. Original flavors and great tasting over all becareful you dont put yourself in a sugar coma though.

Delicious as always

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amazing ambiance and desserts

Great vibe, Great customer service, and delicious chocolate fudge

Passed by to check out this place but unfortunatley they were closed for a private event.
Would have loved to try their famous egg cream but didnt have the time to wait.

Maybe next time

Went there with my wife and child. I see they have food get there's no food just desserts. I literally had to wait until they finished their ice cream and find a pizza shop on Columbia Street. Very time-consuming!

This place can be really good.

Sundaes and floats are very good, if very expensive.

But I got a coffee milkshake that was advertised as being a shot of espresso and vanilla ice cream. Standard.

I don’t know if the guy who made it was new, or overwhelmed, of if he was just kindof an idiot, because he gave me ground coffee grinds in a vanilla shake.

And because that shake was like $20, I still drank it.

Maybe they’re just hit or miss, idk. The people working there don’t have a lot of time per order and they’re usually under a crush of people, so maybe it was a one off.

But for how much that stuff Costs? No, I’m sorry.

The sundae looked beautiful, but for the $20 price tag, I was hoping for a more balanced flavor — it leaned heavily on sweetness without much depth.
Service-wise, the host was somewhat kind, which I appreciated. However, the experience was impacted by a staff member who seemed more focused on socializing with a guest they had invited. At one point, samples were being handed out to that guest while customers looked on, and a moment of genuine customer interaction was interrupted for introductions.
Overall, I had higher expectations given the pricing and presentation. With a little more attention to customer experience and balance in the dessert, this could have been a much more enjoyable visit.

I’m so happy to have stopped by here today. The establishment, workers, owner + ice cream all 10/10! …From the moment we walked in - everyone was welcoming & kind. The owner was super engaged with everyone - felt like it was a familiar place. The ice cream & sweets were worth every calorie! :)

Wow what a cool place. Loved the decor and the music! We split a sundae and it did not disappoint! Would totally recommend!