Butterly Bakeshop

263 Prospect Park West, Brooklyn
(929) 276-3617

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Brooklyn Blackout Cake
Lemon Blueberry Cake
Vegan Chocolate Chip
Apple Pie Cheesecake
Chocolate Cupcake
Birthday Cake
Cake Order

Cookies
Chocolate Chunk
Our signature chocolate chunk cookie is a customer favorite.
S'mores
Double chocolate cookie and graham cracker and toasted marshmallow.
Nutella Cookie
Double chocolate Nutella cookie, fleur de sel.
Butter Pecan
Butterful cookie studded with pecans and rounded with faint notes of espresso.
Vegan Chocolate Chip
Vegan twist to our classic Chocolate chunk
GF Oatmeal Cranberry
Chewy and crunchy. Impossible to tell our signature oatmeal cranberry cookie is gluten free.
Vegan Snickerdoodle
Snickerdoodle with a vegan twist

Cakes
Birthday Cake
Funfetti cake, Vanilla Bean Buttercream
Brooklyn Blackout Cake
Devils Food Cake, Chocolate Pudding, Chocolate Drip
Red Velvet Cake
Rich red velvet cake, luscious cream cheese frosting, vanilla bean buttercream
Turtle Cake
Chocolate cake, salted caramel buttercream, toasted pecans.

Cupcakes
Vanilla Cupcake
Our Tahitian vanilla bean cupcake.
Chocolate Cupcake
Our decadent chocolate cupcake.
Vegan Cookies and Cream Cupcake
Chocolate Cupcake topped with Cookies and Cream Frosting!
Red Velvet Cupcake
Red Velvet Cake, Cream Cheese Frosting.
GF Dulce De Leche Cupcake
GF Vanilla bean cupcake studded with butterscotch chips, dulce de leche buttercream.
Key Lime pie cupcake
Vanilla bean cupcake, stuffed with key lime curd, key like buttercream, graham crumbs

Cake By the Slice
Brooklyn Blackout Cake Slice
Devils Food Cake, Chocolate Pudding, Chocolate Drip
Birthday Cake Slice
Vanilla bean Funfetti cake, vanilla bean buttercream.
Red Velvet cake Slice
Rich red velvet cake, luscious cream cheese frosting, vanilla bean buttercream
Turtle Cake Slice
Devils food cake, salted caramel buttercream, toasted pecans

Bars and Individual Dessert
Banana Pudding
Pint full of the Quintessential summer dessert
Carrot Loaf Mini
Our signature carrot cake topped with our luscious cream cheese frosting.
Fudgy Brownies
Rich fudgy brownies topped with decadent chocolate ganache.
Apple Pie Cheesecake
Apple Pie and cheesecake in one bite, quintessential NY dessert!
French Macarons Classic Collection
Pack of 6 Vanilla, chocolate, coffee, pistachio, raspberry, creme brulee
Brownie Cheesecake
Brownie and cheesecake swirled together, truly match made in heaven.
Chocolate Mousse Cake Jar
Luscious chocolate mousse, chocolate cake, chocolate pearls

Beverages
Bottled Water

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
+44 photos
Photo credit: google
+43 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I saw this bakeshop while waiting for the bus in 25-degree weather, and I had a little bit of time to kill so I stepped inside and grabbed a treat. The Apple Pie Cheesecake and Fudgy Brownie are killer. The cheesecake isn't too sweet, and they have really solid ganache in the brownie. I'd high recc - so glad my bus was late!
December 2025
Butterly Bakeshop did an amazing job on my wedding cake! They were so accommodating with the cake tasting and designing our cake. It came out exactly how we wanted and it was delicious!
November 2025
Butterly Bakeshop helped me customize the most perfect cake and accompanying cupcakes for my baby shower. Easy to work with, and delicious product that all of my guests raved about. Would recommend for any occasion!
July 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Joe's Pizzeria - 259 Prospect Park West
Pizza, Vegetarian
Bedawi Cafe - 266R Prospect Park West
Middle Eastern, Halal, Vegetarian
Coco Thai Bistro - 268 Prospect Park West
Thai, Vegan, Vegetarian

Butterly Bakeshop

263 Prospect Park West, Brooklyn, NY 11215
(929) 276-3617