Buttermilk Bakeshop
264 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 987-3941
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough
6 Classic Birthday Cake
Salted Nutella Cookie
Sprinkle Cookie Dough
Whole Buttermilk Pie
Gluten Free Muffins
Baby Shower Cake
Pack of Cupcakes
Strawberry Cake
Rainbow Cake
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
I’ve been to Buttermilk Bakeshop for birthdays, rainy-day pick-me-ups, and random “we deserve a treat” moments, and it hits every single time. They keep dreaming up magical concoctions and confectionaries that somehow feel both nostalgic and brand new. The new space is such a glow-up from the old window stall, since now you can actually like....go inside hahaha. It’s bright, it’s comfy, and it just smells like happiness.
On my latest visit I tried...
On my latest visit I tried...
Buttermilk Bake Shop made us a gorgeous dairy-free cake for our daughter’s 2nd birthday. We shared a photo of her party invitation and they really brought it to life. The cake was delicious and loved by everyone! We couldn’t be more grateful an highly recommend for all events - big and small.
You May Also Like
Kos Kaffe - 251 5th Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
Fjord Fish Market - 249 5th Ave
![]()
Seafood Markets
The Commissioner - 247 5th Ave
![]()
Bar, Pubs
For a bakery with a high rating it’s not up to par.
In order to get a cake that’s readily available elsewhere, you have to order online and wait at least two days…