Buttermilk Bakeshop
264 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 987-3941
Customers' Favorites
Chocolate Chunk Cookie Dough
Salted Nutella Cookie
Classic Birthday Cake
Sprinkle Cookie Dough
Whole Buttermilk Pie
Gluten Free Muffins
Baby Shower Cake
Pack of Cupcakes
Strawberry Cake
Rainbow Cake
Menu
Photos
+42 photos
+41 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
The cake buttermilk created for us was out of this world. The flavor and presentation were equally as outstanding. They also created our wedding cake, and I find myself back in there any chance I get. I make any excuse I can find to get some cookies, cupcakes, brookie (brownie/cookie) and cake ! Do not sleep on this bakery!!
We LOVE this shop! We go to get treats and have started ordering cakes for everything from special occasions like birthdays to what we’ve come to call ‘happy day of the week’ celebration cakes. They are a huge hit. Delivery service was amazing, too!
We continue to use Buttermilk Bakeshop for our Daughter’s Birthday. Not only are they super reliable, they are consistent and they never disappoint.
This year they did a Barbie theme and once you tell them what you are looking for, they never disappoint. It is also a cake that actually tastes good and always a hit at every birthday party.
It is worth every penny.
This year they did a Barbie theme and once you tell them what you are looking for, they never disappoint. It is also a cake that actually tastes good and always a hit at every birthday party.
It is worth every penny.
You May Also Like
Kos Kaffe - 251 5th Ave
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Coffee
The Commissioner - 247 5th Ave
![]()
Bar, Pubs
Brooklyn Burgers & Beer - 259 5th Ave
![]()
Hamburger, Burgers, Beer Bar, Cocktail Bar, Pet Friendly