Emmy Squared Pizza

315 5th Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 966-1003

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Ander Dingus

my friends and i went to this place and it was amazing. we got 2 brownie skillets and it was heavenlyyy!!! shay is amazing and we were lucky to have him as our server.

Mona Younas

The pizza is so fluffy, the crust is perfectly crispy, and the parsley pesto is surprisingly nut free, highly recommend this place for a great Detroit Style pizza!

ON TM

This place is always empty. I wonder how they afford their rent.

John Fahrenwald

I had a good skinny margarita. I just wanted a piece of pizza but the whole pizzas seemed daunting so I got a blue cheese burger for $27. When it arrived I was aghast but I told myself to have no expectations coming here so I just said Thank you. It was a big brown plate and smothered with diabetes causing waffle fries, which I had about four out of 40. The burger had a lot of meat at least, it it was super well done— I think— as the sauce was very brown, and I could barely pick it up. I had indigestion for hours. Service was fine. With tip it was a burger, cocktail and a landslide of waffle fries for $57. I would go back for just the cocktail.

matt sudol

Happy not to have to go to North BK to enjoy this food. Creative flavor combos and sturdy portions

Steve Ignatious

Emmy Squared offers excellent Detroit style pizza, with a shockingly adventurous cocktail menu for a pizzeria. It seems like the kind of place that caters mostly for parties and large events, but went on a date for 2 and was left more than pleasantly full and satisfied. The cocktail menu is unique and delicious but a couple bucks more than other specialty drinks in the area. Will still be definitely returning. The vibe is cool and casual but can be a little rowdy with large groups of parties.

Ronald Crandall

VIP pizza was excellent, must try with the pesto sauce well blended.

Avapte Apte

Authentic america pizza.

Kaylene Hung

Great garlic bread :)

Steven Thomas

There pizza, I mean, what can I say, a big pile of dough to eat, wow. I’ve never seen so much dough in my life….except when I look down at my stomach. There toppings, (I’m vegan so…at least I thought was when I came here) the toppings….well, on to the next thing. The sauce….i brought a microscope so I could see it. It was tasty, a bit bitter but tasty. I’m guessing canned, yeah, canned tomatoes. Overall I’d rate this place a 10, no I’m kidding I can’t do that,(even though I’d love too) this place is an 8, no I’m kidding again. This place should go back to hell, you know, where it came from.

Bradley Weprin

Unfortunately waited 20 minutes beyond expected time and watched people who ordered 35 minutes after me receive their orders. Cold, soggy pizza sans the pepperoni that I ordered was no bueno!

eddy c

Great food! Kevin made sure we all had a great time.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Natalie Davis

Absolutely obsessed with this pizza!! So yummy.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza

Will G

Just WOW! I stopped by this place after a long day of walking around. Everything looked so good. The manager Kyle was so helpful with suggestions and being funny and patient with my indecisive self. I went with the Colony pizza which was so good! That little kiss of honey with the perfectly done crust made it extra delicious. Cannot wait to come back and try more!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Rhapsody. Audio

I ordered a Square Pizza/delivery last night. First time customer for Emmy Sq. I was AMAZED at how much I liked the pizza. This will now be my go to pizza.

Food: 5

Recommended dishes: MVP Pizza

Loading...