There pizza, I mean, what can I say, a big pile of dough to eat, wow. I’ve never seen so much dough in my life….except when I look down at my stomach. There toppings, (I’m vegan so…at least I thought was when I came here) the toppings….well, on to the next thing. The sauce….i brought a microscope so I could see it. It was tasty, a bit bitter but tasty. I’m guessing canned, yeah, canned tomatoes. Overall I’d rate this place a 10, no I’m kidding I can’t do that,(even though I’d love too) this place is an 8, no I’m kidding again. This place should go back to hell, you know, where it came from.
Bradley Weprin
Unfortunately waited 20 minutes beyond expected time and watched people who ordered 35 minutes after me receive their orders. Cold, soggy pizza sans the pepperoni that I ordered was no bueno!
eddy c
Great food! Kevin made sure we all had a great time.
Just WOW! I stopped by this place after a long day of walking around. Everything looked so good. The manager Kyle was so helpful with suggestions and being funny and patient with my indecisive self. I went with the Colony pizza which was so good! That little kiss of honey with the perfectly done crust made it extra delicious. Cannot wait to come back and try more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rhapsody. Audio
I ordered a Square Pizza/delivery last night. First time customer for Emmy Sq. I was AMAZED at how much I liked the pizza. This will now be my go to pizza.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: MVP Pizza
Nicole Schindel
My husband has celiac disease, and since Emmy’s in Park Slope opened, this was one of our favorite go to spots for gluten free pizza.
A few weeks ago my husband ordered a gluten free pizza at the restaurant in person. After waiting for over an hour for the pizza, when it arrived I questioned if it was the gluten free pizza (the only reason I questioned it was because we ate their regularly and I know what the gf and regular pizza looks like.) The waiter assured us this was the gluten free pizza. We asked them to double check in the kitchen. When he returned the waiter told us that the kitchen was out of gluten free dough so they chose to just make it on regular dough (without telling or asking us if it was ok.)
If we did not know (and pushed back to double check the pizza,) my husband would have been very sick. It was very disappointing for a restaurant to be so careless and unapologetic with an allergy. I would not recommend eating here with celiac disease.
I’m writing this review primarily because of how much the service impressed me at this location. We all know Emmy Squared hits. Their pizza is phenomenal. But the special attention to service and patrons with small children is unmatched. Thank you! Oh and a negroni and the Big Ang FTW.
Kid-friendliness: They offer crayons and coloring books but more than that the staff is overly friendly and accepting of patrons with small children
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad
Ryan Snowden
We took the time to travel here. Please update your hours :0
The food is good, but they cut off pickup orders basically every single night. Don’t ever plan to place an order to go. Weekend. Weeknight. Doesn’t matter. This is a make a reservation type situation.
Zachary Simpson
Pizza was a bit too salty and very undercooked. The amount of garlic and the flavor overall was nice.
Food: 2
Recommended dishes: MVP Pizza
I enjoyed everything about this place, the people the food, I had a bad experience at the Williamsburg location and almost gave up on the business entirely but this location made me fall in love with it again. I will definitely be back
Rich Lowe
Sat solo at the bar. Bartender was friendly and great to chat with. Pizza was awesome and so was the cheeseburger. I’ll be back for both.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Abigail Gerdts
Burger was cooked well but too spicy to eat Caesar chicken salad was pretty good. Just Ok overall. Very kind staff.
There pizza, I mean, what can I say, a big pile of dough to eat, wow. I’ve never seen so much dough in my life….except when I look down at my stomach. There toppings, (I’m vegan so…at least I thought was when I came here) the toppings….well, on to the next thing. The sauce….i brought a microscope so I could see it. It was tasty, a bit bitter but tasty. I’m guessing canned, yeah, canned tomatoes. Overall I’d rate this place a 10, no I’m kidding I can’t do that,(even though I’d love too) this place is an 8, no I’m kidding again. This place should go back to hell, you know, where it came from.
Unfortunately waited 20 minutes beyond expected time and watched people who ordered 35 minutes after me receive their orders. Cold, soggy pizza sans the pepperoni that I ordered was no bueno!
Great food! Kevin made sure we all had a great time.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Absolutely obsessed with this pizza!! So yummy.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Just WOW! I stopped by this place after a long day of walking around. Everything looked so good. The manager Kyle was so helpful with suggestions and being funny and patient with my indecisive self. I went with the Colony pizza which was so good! That little kiss of honey with the perfectly done crust made it extra delicious. Cannot wait to come back and try more!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered a Square Pizza/delivery last night. First time customer for Emmy Sq. I was AMAZED at how much I liked the pizza. This will now be my go to pizza.
Food: 5
Recommended dishes: MVP Pizza
My husband has celiac disease, and since Emmy’s in Park Slope opened, this was one of our favorite go to spots for gluten free pizza.
A few weeks ago my husband ordered a gluten free pizza at the restaurant in person. After waiting for over an hour for the pizza, when it arrived I questioned if it was the gluten free pizza (the only reason I questioned it was because we ate their regularly and I know what the gf and regular pizza looks like.) The waiter assured us this was the gluten free pizza. We asked them to double check in the kitchen. When he returned the waiter told us that the kitchen was out of gluten free dough so they chose to just make it on regular dough (without telling or asking us if it was ok.)
If we did not know (and pushed back to double check the pizza,) my husband would have been very sick. It was very disappointing for a restaurant to be so careless and unapologetic with an allergy. I would not recommend eating here with celiac disease.
Dietary restrictions: Celiac disease , gluten free
Service: 1
I’m writing this review primarily because of how much the service impressed me at this location. We all know Emmy Squared hits. Their pizza is phenomenal. But the special attention to service and patrons with small children is unmatched. Thank you! Oh and a negroni and the Big Ang FTW.
Kid-friendliness: They offer crayons and coloring books but more than that the staff is overly friendly and accepting of patrons with small children
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad
We took the time to travel here. Please update your hours :0
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
This place is closed down
Restaurantji Recommends
The food is good, but they cut off pickup orders basically every single night. Don’t ever plan to place an order to go. Weekend. Weeknight. Doesn’t matter. This is a make a reservation type situation.
Pizza was a bit too salty and very undercooked. The amount of garlic and the flavor overall was nice.
Food: 2
Recommended dishes: MVP Pizza
I enjoyed everything about this place, the people the food, I had a bad experience at the Williamsburg location and almost gave up on the business entirely but this location made me fall in love with it again. I will definitely be back
Sat solo at the bar. Bartender was friendly and great to chat with. Pizza was awesome and so was the cheeseburger. I’ll be back for both.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Burger was cooked well but too spicy to eat Caesar chicken salad was pretty good. Just Ok overall. Very kind staff.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Loading...