Honestly, 6-7years ago I would've gave this place a 5 star rating hands down but I'm basing this off my last experience about a month ago
Last time I ordered here, my cheese steak was chopped so thin the consistency was of a sloppy joe. It was almost grainy. They got their meat from creekstone farms when I ordered, I'm not sure if that's the reason why but as far as cheesesteaks go, it completely sucked. It was not worth the $24.00 for the sandwich, which brings me to next point
When I first started ordering here the sandwiches were about $17 then it crept up to over $20 and to me it was worth it because you're getting the philly experience without going to philly. Fine. But now you guys have competition in NYC like Gs and Danny&Cooper that are giving a better philly experience at a cheaper price. At G's, you get more sandwiches and sides options, even the option of just getting a half sandwich for 11 bucks
All I'm saying, this place needs to get back to the consistency it was at 7 years ago, get cheaper, add more variety or at least add a cooper sharp cheese option.
You guys aren't the only steak slingers in the city anymore. So I'm going to avoid that $24 price tag like the plague and I advise everyone else to do the same. You go to angelos in philly today and they gave you a MUCH larger sandwich for $16.
At this point this place is getting away with ROBBERY everyday, don't do it to yourself unless you're starving and have money to blow
King Power boss 1
I paid $28 For a small cheesesteak, small fries And a wallet and a cup of cheese sauce The cheese sauce is the best thing It doesn’t compare the real Philadelphia Stadium food at best
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
Joe R
One of the better cheese steaks I've had outside of philly. A little expensive in my opinion, but still really yummy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Irfan Ali
It was good but not worth the trip all the way from Times Square!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
J D
Tiny sandwiches at wild prices. Decent cheese steak.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
T. A. Tuho
I’ve heard time and time again that Fedoroff’s had the best cheesesteaks for NYC and after eating my way through Philly this past year and hitting all the top cheesesteak shops, I was really excited to try this place out. I really wanted to like this place, but sadly it just fell short. The service and food was a bit slow which I didn’t mind, but I found it quite expensive. There weren’t any prices displayed so I had to ask what the prices were when ordering. The cheesesteaks come in a 6” or 8” size, which I found a bit weird. There was a Tuesday cheesesteak special so it was $12.95 for a 6” (no idea what it normally costs) or $21 for an 8”! I get that NYC prices are higher, but I usually get a 12” in Philly for $15 so these prices are a bit baffling to me.
The sandwich flavors itself were decent, but the bread was completely wrong. It was way too soft and flattened and fell apart as I held it, making a mess. It just ended up being a big sloppy mess with cheese whiz all over my hands by the end and meat fallen out. The meat itself was fine, nothing special. Overall, very disappointing especially because I had such high hopes. The onions were cooked well though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Ryan Fedyk
Tasty sandwiches which scratch the itch. We got the Philly cheesesteak and pork roast sandwich and now I wanna try them all
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Giana Ganesvoort
Price is now INSANE almost $30 for a sandwich. These restaurants need a reality check
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
salvatore polito
Place smelled like B.O. At first i thought it was the hipsters but turned out to be the very low quality of meat that they use. Truly the worst steak sandwich i ever had. Huge disappointment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
MONICA CARRILLO
Amazing sandwiches! Definitely some of the best sandwiches Brooklyn has. Their cheesesteak catering looks amazing as well.
Brooklyn has tons of sandwich spots, but this one stands out. The roast pork sandwich is incredible, possibly one of the best sandwiches in Brooklyn. I also love the fact that they offer sandwich catering platters. Perfect for office lunches or any gathering. Highly recommended!
ELLERBY
Put a cape around the neck of this place. Because it was SUPER cooooooolllll.... i really enjoyed everything about my experience here. With the exception...of one thing. The meet itself was missing atleast a pinch of some salt. I made a promise to give a REAL review...and that's what I'm doing. Was the sandwich fantastic to look at?.... that would get a hard HELL YEAH!!!!. Did it smell just as appetizing?...again a HARD HELL YEAH. When I say everything else was great....it was Tony the Tiger GREAT. EVEN the Crispy fries and delicious fountain drink that the guy behind the counter didn't take him anything to convince my brother and I to add it to our sandwich....lol great guy. This place is small but really nice. I enjoyed myself, like I said the only thing I would change is a lil seasoning please on the meat please..and thank you....
Parking: There are 2 other great establishments in the area so parking can be a bit troublesome.
Tiny so call Philly Cheesesteak please! Never get my hopes up high. I can take a $10 bus to Philadelphia by 4 $12 stuffed from the front to back! Get back on the bus and make 4 sandwiches out 1 from Philly these guys are selling 1/4 sandwich. It called quality and quantity. The advertisement is fake.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Almi
Meh. The roast pork sandwich is good, and the steak sandwich is average at best. Don't get the crazy hype.
If I could give a 3.8, I would versus a solid 4. Stick with the Roast Pork. Full of flavor, Roasted and minced garlic and juicy. Comes with delectable spicy sautéed Broccoli Rabe and Provalone on a sloppy hero. Should eat it right away because the bread gets super soggy. If you can't, have extra hoagie at home. The Cheesesteak is plentiful but desperately needed seasoning. Took home and reheated with seasoning and Pepperoncinis. Fries needed help, limp bizkits & I don't mean the group. Fries should stand on their own before piling them up with cover-up items. These barely passed the test. Overall, worth trying but not relying on totally.
Honestly, 6-7years ago I would've gave this place a 5 star rating hands down but I'm basing this off my last experience about a month ago
Last time I ordered here, my cheese steak was chopped so thin the consistency was of a sloppy joe. It was almost grainy. They got their meat from creekstone farms when I ordered, I'm not sure if that's the reason why but as far as cheesesteaks go, it completely sucked. It was not worth the $24.00 for the sandwich, which brings me to next point
When I first started ordering here the sandwiches were about $17 then it crept up to over $20 and to me it was worth it because you're getting the philly experience without going to philly. Fine. But now you guys have competition in NYC like Gs and Danny&Cooper that are giving a better philly experience at a cheaper price. At G's, you get more sandwiches and sides options, even the option of just getting a half sandwich for 11 bucks
All I'm saying, this place needs to get back to the consistency it was at 7 years ago, get cheaper, add more variety or at least add a cooper sharp cheese option.
You guys aren't the only steak slingers in the city anymore. So I'm going to avoid that $24 price tag like the plague and I advise everyone else to do the same. You go to angelos in philly today and they gave you a MUCH larger sandwich for $16.
At this point this place is getting away with ROBBERY everyday, don't do it to yourself unless you're starving and have money to blow
I paid $28 For a small cheesesteak, small fries And a wallet and a cup of cheese sauce The cheese sauce is the best thing It doesn’t compare the real Philadelphia Stadium food at best
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 5
One of the better cheese steaks I've had outside of philly. A little expensive in my opinion, but still really yummy
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
It was good but not worth the trip all the way from Times Square!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tiny sandwiches at wild prices. Decent cheese steak.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
I’ve heard time and time again that Fedoroff’s had the best cheesesteaks for NYC and after eating my way through Philly this past year and hitting all the top cheesesteak shops, I was really excited to try this place out. I really wanted to like this place, but sadly it just fell short. The service and food was a bit slow which I didn’t mind, but I found it quite expensive. There weren’t any prices displayed so I had to ask what the prices were when ordering. The cheesesteaks come in a 6” or 8” size, which I found a bit weird. There was a Tuesday cheesesteak special so it was $12.95 for a 6” (no idea what it normally costs) or $21 for an 8”! I get that NYC prices are higher, but I usually get a 12” in Philly for $15 so these prices are a bit baffling to me.
The sandwich flavors itself were decent, but the bread was completely wrong. It was way too soft and flattened and fell apart as I held it, making a mess. It just ended up being a big sloppy mess with cheese whiz all over my hands by the end and meat fallen out. The meat itself was fine, nothing special. Overall, very disappointing especially because I had such high hopes. The onions were cooked well though.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Tasty sandwiches which scratch the itch. We got the Philly cheesesteak and pork roast sandwich and now I wanna try them all
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Price is now INSANE almost $30 for a sandwich. These restaurants need a reality check
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Place smelled like B.O.
At first i thought it was the hipsters but turned out to be the very low quality of meat that they use. Truly the worst steak sandwich i ever had. Huge disappointment.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 4
Amazing sandwiches! Definitely some of the best sandwiches Brooklyn has. Their cheesesteak catering looks amazing as well.
Restaurantji Recommends
Brooklyn has tons of sandwich spots, but this one stands out. The roast pork sandwich is incredible, possibly one of the best sandwiches in Brooklyn. I also love the fact that they offer sandwich catering platters. Perfect for office lunches or any gathering. Highly recommended!
Put a cape around the neck of this place. Because it was SUPER cooooooolllll.... i really enjoyed everything about my experience here. With the exception...of one thing. The meet itself was missing atleast a pinch of some salt. I made a promise to give a REAL review...and that's what I'm doing. Was the sandwich fantastic to look at?.... that would get a hard HELL YEAH!!!!. Did it smell just as appetizing?...again a HARD HELL YEAH. When I say everything else was great....it was Tony the Tiger GREAT. EVEN the Crispy fries and delicious fountain drink that the guy behind the counter didn't take him anything to convince my brother and I to add it to our sandwich....lol great guy. This place is small but really nice. I enjoyed myself, like I said the only thing I would change is a lil seasoning please on the meat please..and thank you....
Parking: There are 2 other great establishments in the area so parking can be a bit
troublesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak, Stella's Scrapple Egg & Cheese, Roast Pork, Cheese Whiz, Cherry Peppers, Sandwich, French Fries, Cheesesteak Sandwich with Fries
Tiny so call Philly Cheesesteak please! Never get my hopes up high. I can take a $10 bus to Philadelphia by 4 $12 stuffed from the front to back! Get back on the bus and make 4 sandwiches out 1 from Philly these guys are selling 1/4 sandwich. It called quality and quantity. The advertisement is fake.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Meh. The roast pork sandwich is good, and the steak sandwich is average at best. Don't get the crazy hype.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak, Roast Pork
If I could give a 3.8, I would versus a solid 4.
Stick with the Roast Pork. Full of flavor, Roasted and minced garlic and juicy. Comes with delectable spicy sautéed Broccoli Rabe and Provalone on a sloppy hero. Should eat it right away because the bread gets super soggy. If you can't, have extra hoagie at home.
The Cheesesteak is plentiful but desperately needed seasoning. Took home and reheated with seasoning and Pepperoncinis.
Fries needed help, limp bizkits & I don't mean the group. Fries should stand on their own before piling them up with cover-up items. These barely passed the test.
Overall, worth trying but not relying on totally.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak, Roast Pork
Loading...