Gold Star Beer Counter
176 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 955-5031
Customers' Favorites
Beer Cheese
Craft Beer
Sandwich
Menu
Photos
+22 photos
+21 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
I stopped into Gold Star today for an early lunch and was absolutely blown away by how amazing the grilled cheese with tomato soup was! Best grilled cheese I have ever had. I paired it with the dark lager they had on tap and man oh man - was it the perfect combo. 5 Stars for Gold Star!
What a fun place to have a beer. While there outside seating weather permitting, the inside is warm and comfortable ith a great atmosphere. Nice selection of beer; we enjoyed a stout with hints of coffee and maple syrup that was perfect for a cold night. The fact that the alcohol content was 12.3% helped warm us up. Check it out if you are in that area of Brooklyn.
Gold Star Beer Counter nails what most places miss. The music is local and right — unexpectedly amazing — like someone actually thought about it instead of hitting play on some corporate streaming service. You can feel it’s picked by the same personalities you see at the bar, not a marketing team in another time zone. The vibe is warm, unforced, and human. No branding exercise, no playlist ‘strategy,’ just a room that knows exactly who it is and lets you enjoy it
You May Also Like
Cheryl's Global Soul - 236 Underhill Ave
![]()
Soul Food, Comfort Food, Coffee & Tea, Caribbean, Vegan
Mumbai Place - 655 Vanderbilt Ave #3829
![]()
Indian, Halal, Seafood, Vegetarian