Island Pops

Name: Island Pops
Address: 680 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, New York, 11216, US
Telephone: (347) 365-6737
Price range: $
Rating: 4.6

$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
680 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn
(347) 365-6737

Menu Order Online

About Island Pops

Island Pops is a charming spot that attracts ice cream lovers with its wide variety of seasonal flavors, including vegan options like Island Coconut ice cream paired with vegan banana bread—a heavenly combination. The shop offers popular flavors such as sorrel rum, black cake, and Ponche de Crème (trini egg nog), with generous chunks of black cake adding a pleasant surprise to the ice cream. The atmosphere has Caribbean vibes, enhanced by afrobeats music, creating a lively and friendly environment. While the portions are small, the flavors are unique and thoughtfully crafted, showing effort to bring Caribbean tastes to life. Customers can sample a few flavors before deciding, and the staff provides helpful, welcoming, and friendly service with detailed descriptions of each flavor. A highlight is their rum and raisin ice cream, reminiscent of homemade flavors from Guyana, and the homemade banana bread is considered divine. There is a small outdoor seating area, but no indoor seating, which is worth considering during hot days, as ice cream can melt quickly outside. Overall, Island Pops offers delicious treats and a fun, Caribbean-inspired experience for those willing to try new flavors.

Recent visitors praise the friendly environment and the quality of the ice cream, noting that the flavors are authentic and flavorful. Some mentioned that the sorrel rum flavor is outstanding, with a strong, slightly sour taste and a hint of spice from the rum or other spices used for the sorrel. Others enjoyed the soursop ice cream, which had enough guanabana flavor to be unique, and appreciated that the ice cream was not overly sweetened. Several customers expressed a wish for the shop to open a location outside of Crown Heights, suggesting LES or Manhattan as ideal spots. Many friends and families have visited and loved their experience, highlighting the creamy texture, great taste, and friendly service. Overall, Island Pops is a small but delightful place offering a variety of Caribbean-inspired flavors, with a lively atmosphere perfect for those looking to try something different.