Lenny & John's Pizza is a Flatbush staple. Food is always freshly prepared, tastes good and is served in a timely fashion. The staff consistently checks in to make sure diners have what they need. Highly recommend for either dine in or to go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kraig DeMatteis
Lenny & John's is a local Flatbush institution slinging slices forever. They expanded from a typical pizza counter to a sit-down restaurant. Best for order-ahead, take-away or table service, the pizza and food are good but their rice balls are amazing. Hits the spot kind of place and open late.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Patryk Braganza-Gallagher
So this was a solid pizza place. Granted, I only had a slice, but it was a specialty slice (chicken bacon ranch) and it was a dammed good slice. It had the right proportions for back, chicken and ranch, and it went through to the crust (unlike some places that skimp on toppings). Will definitely visit again. And the slice was a good size too.
Food: 5
Service: 4
Moe
This place is good even when they get back around so we can sit on and eat your pizza this place
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 2
Muyinjon Turobov
Old review: (The service was good, and there were friendly people, but the only thing about the restaurant is there was a stench of, I think, piss or something. It was a weird stench, and I did not like it. When I was eating, that stench I could smell it, so it was just not a pleasant experience. But I think overall, it's not a bad place. I think they might need to clean up their garbage can regularly. Maybe it might remove the stench. But it was a weird piss-smelling stench. I did not like that. And the pizza was all right.)
New review: instead of investigating their own restaurant for the stench. And maybe take out the garbage is regularly. They have insulted me. Saying that I need ENT. My nose is perfectly fine. Also, review is real. If you’re trying to defend your own business, maybe you should say we will investigate and we’ll make sure this will not occur not attack me for pointing out something obvious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slices
Nyasha Williams
Third time ,will not be back expensive tasteless. Will stick to Mancini in Bay Ridge it's worth the drive...Disappointed with Lennys and John...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
Cassi Brat
The pizza is what got me addicted and them I realized how delicious everything on the menu is as well 😋 Other than the pizza their Lasagna is the best I've had outside. Now the meatballs are topnotch!!! Big, moist, and seasoned perfectly! You can't go wrong here.
An absolutely unforgettable dining experience. The food alone was outstanding. The zucchini sticks were perfectly crispy and seasoned just right. The Alfredo was rich, smooth, and incredibly comforting. The chicken marsala was tender, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Every dish felt thoughtfully prepared and full of care.
What truly made the night exceptional was our server, Nicole. From the moment she came to our table, she elevated the entire experience. She was incredibly kind, attentive, and genuinely warm, making us feel welcomed and valued the whole evening. Her positive energy and professionalism stood out, and on top of that, she was absolutely beautiful inside and out. Her makeup was flawless and complemented her confidence and grace perfectly. She carried herself with such kindness and poise that the night felt truly special and memorable.
This was our first time coming back with my husband in years, and thanks to Nicole’s care and the incredible food, it felt like a truly meaningful night. The service continues to get better every visit, and the quality of the food never disappoints. Experiences like this are why we will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Leslie Latchman
All the pizza 🍕 and everything is delicious 😋. The chocolate must try
Pizza was barely warm when picked up. The overall taste and texture is okay. Nothing special.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
kyla
i visited lenny and johns recently and was serviced by nicole, she was incredibly warm and welcoming and her amazing attitude made the delicious food even more enjoyable! would definitely come again
I ordered from Grubhub, and man, it was one of the worst linguini ala vodka. This store is not passionate about the food it serves. All they did was throw unseasoned sauce on top of my pasta and didn't even mix it into the bottom, which is dried pasta. No flavor, nothing. Highly disappointed
Food: 1
Chloe Mullen
I’ve been going to Lenny & John’s for decades. Since I was a child. Their food is delicious. I love their chicken parmigiana and baked ziti. Oh and their garlic knots are big and tasty. Their square pizza is my favorite. Highly recommend this place. I pray they stay around for decades to come.
Amazing Legendary Pizza 🍕
Lenny & John's Pizza is a Flatbush staple. Food is always freshly prepared, tastes good and is served in a timely fashion. The staff consistently checks in to make sure diners have what they need. Highly recommend for either dine in or to go.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Lenny & John's is a local Flatbush institution slinging slices forever. They expanded from a typical pizza counter to a sit-down restaurant. Best for order-ahead, take-away or table service, the pizza and food are good but their rice balls are amazing. Hits the spot kind of place and open late.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
So this was a solid pizza place. Granted, I only had a slice, but it was a specialty slice (chicken bacon ranch) and it was a dammed good slice. It had the right proportions for back, chicken and ranch, and it went through to the crust (unlike some places that skimp on toppings). Will definitely visit again. And the slice was a good size too.
Food: 5
Service: 4
This place is good even when they get back around so we can sit on and eat your pizza this place
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 2
Old review: (The service was good, and there were friendly people, but the only thing about the restaurant is there was a stench of, I think, piss or something. It was a weird stench, and I did not like it. When I was eating, that stench I could smell it, so it was just not a pleasant experience. But I think overall, it's not a bad place. I think they might need to clean up their garbage can regularly. Maybe it might remove the stench. But it was a weird piss-smelling stench. I did not like that. And the pizza was all right.)
New review: instead of investigating their own restaurant for the stench. And maybe take out the garbage is regularly. They have insulted me. Saying that I need ENT. My nose is perfectly fine. Also, review is real. If you’re trying to defend your own business, maybe you should say we will investigate and we’ll make sure this will not occur not attack me for pointing out something obvious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slices
Third time ,will not be back expensive tasteless.
Will stick to Mancini in Bay Ridge it's worth the drive...Disappointed with Lennys and John...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 3
The pizza is what got me addicted and them I realized how delicious everything on the menu is as well 😋 Other than the pizza their Lasagna is the best I've had outside. Now the meatballs are topnotch!!! Big, moist, and seasoned perfectly! You can't go wrong here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza Slices, Chicken Parm, Baked Ziti, Fettuccine Alfredo
An absolutely unforgettable dining experience. The food alone was outstanding. The zucchini sticks were perfectly crispy and seasoned just right. The Alfredo was rich, smooth, and incredibly comforting. The chicken marsala was tender, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. Every dish felt thoughtfully prepared and full of care.
What truly made the night exceptional was our server, Nicole. From the moment she came to our table, she elevated the entire experience. She was incredibly kind, attentive, and genuinely warm, making us feel welcomed and valued the whole evening. Her positive energy and professionalism stood out, and on top of that, she was absolutely beautiful inside and out. Her makeup was flawless and complemented her confidence and grace perfectly. She carried herself with such kindness and poise that the night felt truly special and memorable.
This was our first time coming back with my husband in years, and thanks to Nicole’s care and the incredible food, it felt like a truly meaningful night. The service continues to get better every visit, and the quality of the food never disappoints. Experiences like this are why we will definitely be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
All the pizza 🍕 and everything is delicious 😋. The chocolate must try
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza was barely warm when picked up. The overall taste and texture is okay. Nothing special.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
i visited lenny and johns recently and was serviced by nicole, she was incredibly warm and welcoming and her amazing attitude made the delicious food even more enjoyable! would definitely come again
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chicken Parm Pizza, Baked Ziti
I ordered from Grubhub, and man, it was one of the worst linguini ala vodka. This store is not passionate about the food it serves. All they did was throw unseasoned sauce on top of my pasta and didn't even mix it into the bottom, which is dried pasta.
No flavor, nothing. Highly disappointed
Food: 1
I’ve been going to Lenny & John’s for decades. Since I was a child. Their food is delicious. I love their chicken parmigiana and baked ziti. Oh and their garlic knots are big and tasty. Their square pizza is my favorite. Highly recommend this place. I pray they stay around for decades to come.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...