Luckybird Bakery

163 Montrose Ave, Brooklyn
(917) 412-9455

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Julianna Pillemer

Amy makes an absolutely exquisite wedding cake! We were floored by how stunningly beautiful it was, with fresh flowers that matched our wedding day blooms. The cake itself was delicious – highly recommend the vanilla with fresh berries and cream. Amy is also super lovely and easy to work with, and even went to pick up the flowers from our florist the day before the wedding! All in all, can’t recommend Luckybird more!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Dare Ogundipe

Luckybird made an amazing cake for my mom's birthday, and decorated it with a gorgeous, understated floral arrangement. We got the pear cake and it was a huge hit - nobody had had that particular flavor before.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lauren Hackney

The best cakes in Brooklyn!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Alyson Warendh

Amy made the most wonderful cake for our small wedding and even coordinated getting it to the restaurant in the city where we had our dinner. So amazing! And even worked with my guests various allergies and food requirements. Highly recommend the Meyer Lemon Cake. So yummy and so special!

Vicky Muñoz

Orders taken by email

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Bakery, Vanilla Rose Cake

Albert J Zicca

Fast communication and she was able to squeeze me in on a 2 day turn around. Chocolate chip

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kathryn Ferraro

It has been four weeks since our wedding and my mom is STILL talking about the cake. She stole three extra slices from the venue and had cake for breakfast three days in a row. I think she’ll be talking about this cake for the rest of my life. She might drive me crazy but…she’s right. The cake Luckybird made for our wedding was the best cake I’ve ever had. That’s not an exaggeration. It really was next level. We ordered a fully frosted chocolate cake with seasonal berries and crème fraiche, and it was simply divine. Sweet but not too sweet, decadent but still light, and totally addicting. I cannot tell you how many people have reached out to me specifically to compliment the cake!Besides her incredible skills as a baker, Amy is also a lovely person to work with. Throughout the entire process, she was friendly, communicative, and kind. She was quick to answer my questions and super professional. If we ever throw another special event and need a cake, I will 100% reach out to Luckybird! In fact, I’m really trying to find a reason to order a second wedding cake, just for myself  THANK YOU SO MUCH!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Katie Evans

Amy created the most amazing cake for our wedding. The cake tasted delicious and was also so beautiful. We went with the Vanilla Rose option for the flavor. Our guests were raving about how good it tasted. There were many other tasty flavors to pick from too.We loved Amy's use of seasonal florals for the cake design. Amy looked at a photo of our other wedding florals and was able to pick the most perfect flowers for our cake. I loved the white dahlias that were featured on our cake so much! I highly recommend Luckybird Bakery!

Megan Fullagar

We ordered a cake for our Brooklyn wedding and it was such a hit! Wedding cakes aren't always delicious, but let me tell you - this cake was incredible. Plus, it was beautiful. Thank you so much for making us such a gorgeous and tasty cake!

Bijan Sardari

Ordered a wedding cake for delivery to a restaurant in Manhattan. Perfection all around, delivered on time, cake looked amazing, and tasted even better than it looked.Highly recommend luckybird. Great job all around.

Alyson W

Amy made the most wonderful cake for our small wedding and even coordinated getting it to the restaurant in the city where we had our dinner. So amazing! And even worked with my guests various allergies and food requirements. Highly recommend the Meyer Lemon Cake. So yummy and so special!

Angela Arancio

The best cake you’ll ever have. I’m not exaggerating. I eat a lot of cake. I know good cake. This was exceptional. My husband and I tried all the so called “top bakeries” in the city. None of them compared to Lucky Bird. After our tasting I emailed Amy (the owner) to tell her this and was counting down the days to our wedding to have more of it! We went with the two tier almond cake. Not only was it beautiful to look at. It was delicious! We had so many guests ask for the name of the bakery. When we saw our family during the holidays they were still raving about it. Don’t even hesitate to get your wedding cake from Luckybird. The only problem is you’ll be looking for excuses after your wedding to order another! Also, communication was great and so was effortless delivery on their part.

Mallory Ferraro

I worked with Amy the weeks leading up to my wedding and she was great. Her communication was quick, concise and follow through was perfect. I had my cake delivered the day of, without issue and it was honestly the best f-ing cake I've ever had. I'm serious, It was SO good. Would love to reorder for every anniversary. She does such a wonderful job with keeping their cakes unique and beautiful. I had a vision and she literally brought it to life. Would definitely recommend them for any event where you want a little pizzazz. Thank you so much!

Kacie Keegan

We hired Amy to make our wedding cake and it was absolutely incredible. Our guests are still talking about how yummy it was (which is rare for wedding cakes!)Also, the seasonal flower decorations on top are simply stunning and the cake looked as good as it tasted.We loved working with Luckybird Bakery and can't wait to pick up more cake for special occassions and anniversaries!

Christina Flores

I had my wedding cake made with Luckybird bakery and I could not be happier. I sent Amy a few pictures of what I wanted the cake to look like and she delivered perfectly. The cake tasted exactly how the sample cake did. I was very pleased. Amy communicated very well and answered all of my questions. I would highly recommend luckybird bakery for any event where you will need a cake.

Loading...