It's a great place to pregame for games/events at Barclay's. My only complaint is how crowded it can get!
Erich Schneider
Owner was rude to customers and his waitstaff.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Darren Giles
Visiting from the UK and taking a walk down 5th Ave so decided to pop into McMahon’s. Barman Jerry was an amazing host and full of knowledge when giving us ideas for our stay and an around nice guy. I would highly recommend popping into McMahon’s for the great service and superb choice of drinks. Thank you Jerry, you are a true gentleman.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alyssa Del Gaizo
Jerry is the best!! food is amazing and service was even better. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
hector Santiago
The food was delicious ? the drinks were good. I would definitely go back next time I'm in Brooklyn.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bangers and Mash, Shot Hennessy VSOP, McMahon's Burger with Fries, Buffalo Wings, Roast Beef
Olivia L.
This is a solid pub in the area. It's just off Atlantic Ave, near the Barclays center. The inside is very spacious and it seems great for groups. When we walked in, they weren't playing the premier league game, but they happily put it on when we asked. The service was very attentive and consistently checked up on us, even when the bar started getting pretty busy. We ordered the wings and they were so delicious. They were so juicy and covered in sauce. I usually don't like wings and wouldn't order them, but these changed my mind. For drinks, I got a cider and it was as expected. My partner got an ale, which apparently tasted stale and as if they didn't clean the pipes. He tried a few other beers and said the same. I couldn't really taste the difference, but something to keep in mind if you're very familiar with beer. I'd keep this place in mind if you need a sports bar in the area!
Mark Nalibotsky
Christine was super dope.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Andre Olivier
Came here after a Nets game and enjoyed a tasty fish and chips. The fish was battered great and was especially crispy. The loaded fries were ok the cheese was not 100% melted but other than that the fries were crispy and had the right amount of salt. The service was great and we were seated
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Andre O.
Came here after a Nets game and enjoyed a tasty fish and chips. The fish was battered great and was especially crispy. The loaded fries were ok the cheese was not 100% melted but other than that the fries were crispy and had the right amount of salt. The service was great and we were seated promptly
Dmac T.
Went there with about three friends last week. Service was great until we met Cory, the bartender. So we were having drinks and Cory decides to run our bill, not informing us. Meanwhile we are still at the bar drinking. My friends card declined due to banks making sure it's not fraudulent activity. Cory then has an attitude, my friend cakks his bank and everything is fixed, so charge went through. So I ask Cory for another drink after that, he says "I don't want to serve you anymore, because I SEE NO CASH TIP on the table". I said "excuse me, you work in a social establishment and that's extremely unprofessional ". Obviously we were still drinking and was going to leave him a tip. He had an attitude towards us which we were the only black people in the establishment. Mind you he is black as well. He needs to be retrained or released from his position. We can chat about this over the phone if the owner reads this. I would never attend this place again.
Love this pub. Great f&c! Excellent service by Jerry! Will most definitely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Priscilla Vela
Perry at McMahon Public House is hands down a 5-star bartender! He's not just attentive; he's practically psychic, always knowing what drink you need before you do. With his welcoming smile and helpful attitude, Perry turns every visit into a great time. Cheers to McMahon for having such an awesome bartender! ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings
Clara Beltran Moreno
Good atmosphere
Tom B.
Very close to Barclays Center. Hung out here on a Friday night after driving some friends in for a Nets game. This gave my friend and I time to waste since we didn't have our own tickets. The place is packed pregame since it's obviously well known. But we still found the last two seats. Even at its busiest, the service was prompt and wait staff was very friendly and attentive. The food was above average and prices were better than I expected for NYC. Beers are around $6-8 each, which is pretty much what you'd expect to pay elsewhere in a New York suburb. Food prices were also pretty reasonable compared to any suburb in the surrounding area. The place emptied out pretty steadily once the game started, but there are lots of TV's to hang out, watch the game, or just chill. Parking is expectedly tricky, so your best bet is a parking garage. Definitely a great spot to arrive early and relax before a game, or spend some time with friends.
Henry R.
Great food, atmosphere and drinks. The decor is top notch. The only thing bad about this place is that it's so good it gets crowded. Try the calamari!!!!
It's a great place to pregame for games/events at Barclay's. My only complaint is how crowded it can get!
Owner was rude to customers and his waitstaff.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Visiting from the UK and taking a walk down 5th Ave so decided to pop into McMahon’s. Barman Jerry was an amazing host and full of knowledge when giving us ideas for our stay and an around nice guy. I would highly recommend popping into McMahon’s for the great service and superb choice of drinks. Thank you Jerry, you are a true gentleman.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jerry is the best!! food is amazing and service was even better. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food was delicious ? the drinks were good. I would definitely go back next time I'm in Brooklyn.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Bangers and Mash, Shot Hennessy VSOP, McMahon's Burger with Fries, Buffalo Wings, Roast Beef
This is a solid pub in the area. It's just off Atlantic Ave, near the Barclays center. The inside is very spacious and it seems great for groups. When we walked in, they weren't playing the premier league game, but they happily put it on when we asked. The service was very attentive and consistently checked up on us, even when the bar started getting pretty busy. We ordered the wings and they were so delicious. They were so juicy and covered in sauce. I usually don't like wings and wouldn't order them, but these changed my mind. For drinks, I got a cider and it was as expected. My partner got an ale, which apparently tasted stale and as if they didn't clean the pipes. He tried a few other beers and said the same. I couldn't really taste the difference, but something to keep in mind if you're very familiar with beer. I'd keep this place in mind if you need a sports bar in the area!
Christine was super dope.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Came here after a Nets game and enjoyed a tasty fish and chips. The fish was battered great and was especially crispy. The loaded fries were ok the cheese was not 100% melted but other than that the fries were crispy and had the right amount of salt. The service was great and we were seated
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Came here after a Nets game and enjoyed a tasty fish and chips. The fish was battered great and was especially crispy. The loaded fries were ok the cheese was not 100% melted but other than that the fries were crispy and had the right amount of salt. The service was great and we were seated promptly
Went there with about three friends last week. Service was great until we met Cory, the bartender. So we were having drinks and Cory decides to run our bill, not informing us. Meanwhile we are still at the bar drinking. My friends card declined due to banks making sure it's not fraudulent activity. Cory then has an attitude, my friend cakks his bank and everything is fixed, so charge went through. So I ask Cory for another drink after that, he says "I don't want to serve you anymore, because I SEE NO CASH TIP on the table". I said "excuse me, you work in a social establishment and that's extremely unprofessional ". Obviously we were still drinking and was going to leave him a tip. He had an attitude towards us which we were the only black people in the establishment. Mind you he is black as well. He needs to be retrained or released from his position. We can chat about this over the phone if the owner reads this. I would never attend this place again.
Restaurantji Recommends
Love this pub. Great f&c! Excellent service by Jerry! Will most definitely
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Perry at McMahon Public House is hands down a 5-star bartender! He's not just attentive; he's practically psychic, always knowing what drink you need before you do. With his welcoming smile and helpful attitude, Perry turns every visit into a great time. Cheers to McMahon for having such an awesome bartender! ? ?
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings
Good atmosphere
Very close to Barclays Center. Hung out here on a Friday night after driving some friends in for a Nets game. This gave my friend and I time to waste since we didn't have our own tickets. The place is packed pregame since it's obviously well known. But we still found the last two seats. Even at its busiest, the service was prompt and wait staff was very friendly and attentive. The food was above average and prices were better than I expected for NYC. Beers are around $6-8 each, which is pretty much what you'd expect to pay elsewhere in a New York suburb. Food prices were also pretty reasonable compared to any suburb in the surrounding area. The place emptied out pretty steadily once the game started, but there are lots of TV's to hang out, watch the game, or just chill. Parking is expectedly tricky, so your best bet is a parking garage. Definitely a great spot to arrive early and relax before a game, or spend some time with friends.
Great food, atmosphere and drinks. The decor is top notch. The only thing bad about this place is that it's so good it gets crowded. Try the calamari!!!!