A neighborhood favorite that goes beyond. They kept us all fed during Covid and we have not forgotten. Thanks for being the diner we can count on.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rafaela Lara
excellent food and service I recommend it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
mimi tann
Reviews are all over the place on Mex Carroll's Diner. Can tell you this though, our meals were definitely 5 stars. Didn't look at the reviews before going here and glad we didn't as we might have passed it up. We were meeting with an attorney nearby and when we left we asked her about it. She noted she has eaten there many times and it was very good. She also mentioned it was a "Mexican Diner". Didn't quite grasped what was meant by this, but when we got the menu we understood. Whoa, tremendous menu. Over 20 different types of omelettes, 7 different eggs benedict variations, at least twenty different burger styles, pasta dishes, etc. Something for everyone. Never knew something like a "Mexican Diner" existed. Nice concept.
As mentioned previously our meals were 5 star. The same could be said for the service and dining atmosphere. We ate outside in their backyard courtyard. Pleasantly decorated and comfortable. Surrounded by greenery and most of the tables had large umbrellas to keep the sun from beaming down on you. No issues with the service provide by the wait staff. On our way out we were wished a good a good day. We had brunch which was an order of Huevos Rancheros and Eggs Benedict. Had a choice of red or green salsa to go with the Huevos Rancheros. Went with the green which was perfect. Not too spicy, but not bland either. It came with refried beans and yellow rice. Both were a delight. Ordered a fresh squeezed orange juice that was as fresh squeezed should be...in other words really good. Mexican Diner with tons of Mexican breakfast choices and what does my wife order...Eggs Benedict! Well, I guess that's the point of a diner. Lots of choices. Verdict on the Eggs Benedict was a thumbs up. Very good with no complaints.
BTW...Might have to put some of the one star reviews in context. One person left a one star because they wouldn't let him use the bathroom. Just came in off the street and wasn't going to order anything. Really? Also there are complaints about the prices. We thought they were reasonable especially considering the portion size. Check out the menu and you decide.
Kid-friendliness: Has a kid's menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jonathan Raybaud
Beautiful place, wonderful staff, but their food is unseasoned and their menu prices are off (expect everything to be $2-4 more expensive than it is on the menu). The chicken we got was horribly overcooked (to the point of being hard) as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Tamir Duberstein
These people have forgotten how to be human.
The place was empty at 12 pm on a Sunday and they flatly refused to let me use their restroom without a purchase.
Well within their rights, of course.
Service: 1
Ted Cadieu
I had there protein omelet w home fries very good size came quick w my 3 other family members. Never been in that part of Brooklyn but it was recommended some one street to check it out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American, Mexican
Ghia
I haven't been here for dinner yet, but for breakfast and lunch, brunch, etc. Awesome. This place makes you want to come back and try something new. They offer both American and Mexican on their menu, staff great, food - delicious, outdoor seating, and I can get my tequila neat with my horchata aguas frescas!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American, Mexican
Rebecca Valbrun
I LOVEEEEEEE THE FOOOD AMAZING I WOULD EAT THERE EVERY SINGLE DAYYY LIKE THE PEOPLE THERE AARE SO NICE KIND AND WELCOMING.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Garth Rathkey
I am consuming one of the worst breakfasts I’ve eaten in years. The English muffin on my Benedict is so stale and hard I can’t cut through it with a steak knife. My side of sausage is so dry and over cooked I decided to throw it out. The order took 20 minutes past the time the website stated it would. That would not have been an issue if the food had been edible but it wasn’t so I’m including it. They did follow our requests for items being on the side and extra sauces. The delivery person was friendly. I will never eat here again though.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Nicole Brun
Good Mexican food. Huge beer selection. On site or to take away. We tested both!
Honestly I'm ashamed I haven't left a review sooner. We've had breakfast and lunch here but for the first time had dinner delivered tonight. I got the ribeye, seasoned and cooked perfectly, my gf got the meatloaf both were absolutely delicious. The sauteed broccoli was seasoned and cooked perfectly and the mashed potatoes were creamy. I've never had bad food here only delicious food. The service is always 10/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chilaquiles Verdes with Steak, Steak Mexican Style, Enchiladas Verdes, American, Burger, Quesadilla Al Pastor, Mexican, Two Eggs and Cheese, Home Fries
Jonathan Flores
The food was terrible it honestly made me and my girlfriend sick. The shrimp wasn’t seasoned and was not cooked correctly while the rice also tasted bland and the beans lacked flavor! I ordered a burger and asked for medium and ended up receiving rare which wasn’t a big deal but the cooks need to learn how to correctly cook the meat. The servers on the other hand were very friendly and welcoming
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Nick Esposito
Best diner in the area , a hidden gem in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American, Mexican
J C
This is our go to place, excellent food and drinks. Me and my family have been going here since day 1 that they have opened.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Craig Goldon
Great breakfast food. Excellent service with a friendly
A neighborhood favorite that goes beyond. They kept us all fed during Covid and we have not forgotten. Thanks for being the diner we can count on.
Food: 5
Service: 5
excellent food and service I recommend it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Reviews are all over the place on Mex Carroll's Diner. Can tell you this though, our meals were definitely 5 stars. Didn't look at the reviews before going here and glad we didn't as we might have passed it up. We were meeting with an attorney nearby and when we left we asked her about it. She noted she has eaten there many times and it was very good. She also mentioned it was a "Mexican Diner". Didn't quite grasped what was meant by this, but when we got the menu we understood. Whoa, tremendous menu. Over 20 different types of omelettes, 7 different eggs benedict variations, at least twenty different burger styles, pasta dishes, etc. Something for everyone. Never knew something like a "Mexican Diner" existed. Nice concept.
As mentioned previously our meals were 5 star. The same could be said for the service and dining atmosphere. We ate outside in their backyard courtyard. Pleasantly decorated and comfortable. Surrounded by greenery and most of the tables had large umbrellas to keep the sun from beaming down on you. No issues with the service provide by the wait staff. On our way out we were wished a good a good day. We had brunch which was an order of Huevos Rancheros and Eggs Benedict. Had a choice of red or green salsa to go with the Huevos Rancheros. Went with the green which was perfect. Not too spicy, but not bland either. It came with refried beans and yellow rice. Both were a delight. Ordered a fresh squeezed orange juice that was as fresh squeezed should be...in other words really good. Mexican Diner with tons of Mexican breakfast choices and what does my wife order...Eggs Benedict! Well, I guess that's the point of a diner. Lots of choices. Verdict on the Eggs Benedict was a thumbs up. Very good with no complaints.
BTW...Might have to put some of the one star reviews in context. One person left a one star because they wouldn't let him use the bathroom. Just came in off the street and wasn't going to order anything. Really? Also there are complaints about the prices. We thought they were reasonable especially considering the portion size. Check out the menu and you decide.
Kid-friendliness: Has a kid's menu
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Beautiful place, wonderful staff, but their food is unseasoned and their menu prices are off (expect everything to be $2-4 more expensive than it is on the menu). The chicken we got was horribly overcooked (to the point of being hard) as well.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
These people have forgotten how to be human.
The place was empty at 12 pm on a Sunday and they flatly refused to let me use their restroom without a purchase.
Well within their rights, of course.
Service: 1
I had there protein omelet w home fries very good size came quick w my 3 other family members. Never been in that part of Brooklyn but it was recommended some one street to check it out.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American, Mexican
I haven't been here for dinner yet, but for breakfast and lunch, brunch, etc. Awesome. This place makes you want to come back and try something new. They offer both American and Mexican on their menu, staff great, food - delicious, outdoor seating, and I can get my tequila neat with my horchata aguas frescas!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American, Mexican
I LOVEEEEEEE THE FOOOD AMAZING I WOULD EAT THERE EVERY SINGLE DAYYY LIKE THE PEOPLE THERE AARE SO NICE KIND AND WELCOMING.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I am consuming one of the worst breakfasts I’ve eaten in years. The English muffin on my Benedict is so stale and hard I can’t cut through it with a steak knife. My side of sausage is so dry and over cooked I decided to throw it out. The order took 20 minutes past the time the website stated it would. That would not have been an issue if the food had been edible but it wasn’t so I’m including it. They did follow our requests for items being on the side and extra sauces. The delivery person was friendly. I will never eat here again though.
Food: 1
Service: 2
Good Mexican food. Huge beer selection. On site or to take away. We tested both!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Honestly I'm ashamed I haven't left a review sooner. We've had breakfast and lunch here but for the first time had dinner delivered tonight. I got the ribeye, seasoned and cooked perfectly, my gf got the meatloaf both were absolutely delicious. The sauteed broccoli was seasoned and cooked perfectly and the mashed potatoes were creamy. I've never had bad food here only delicious food. The service is always 10/10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Chilaquiles Verdes with Steak, Steak Mexican Style, Enchiladas Verdes, American, Burger, Quesadilla Al Pastor, Mexican, Two Eggs and Cheese, Home Fries
The food was terrible it honestly made me and my girlfriend sick. The shrimp wasn’t seasoned and was not cooked correctly while the rice also tasted bland and the beans lacked flavor! I ordered a burger and asked for medium and ended up receiving rare which wasn’t a big deal but the cooks need to learn how to correctly cook the meat. The servers on the other hand were very friendly and welcoming
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Best diner in the area , a hidden gem in the
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: American, Mexican
This is our go to place, excellent food and drinks. Me and my family have been going here since day 1 that they have opened.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great breakfast food. Excellent service with a friendly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...