Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream

Name: Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream
Address: 1397 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn, New York, 11226, US
Telephone: (973) 640-3200
Price range: $
Rating: 4.7

$ • Ice Cream

Hours:
1397 Nostrand Ave, Brooklyn
(973) 640-3200

Menu Order Online

About Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream

Mr P's Homemade Ice Cream offers unique and Caribbean-inspired flavors that are a must-try for tropical fruit lovers. The ice cream has a smooth, almost silk-like consistency that is truly delicious. With vegan options available, like coconut or oat milk-based treats, there is something for everyone. Customers praise the great service, noting that the owner is punctual and friendly. Flavors such as cherry soursop, beet/ginger, soursop, and mauby are popular choices, with some customers mentioning that the peanut and coconut flavors are highly recommended. The shop sells flavors not easy to find elsewhere, including grape nut and a well-made peanut ice cream that tastes spot on.

The ice cream parlor is a popular spot with the locals, and there can be a line, but the wait is worth it. The ice cream is fresh and has an authentic taste without a heavy cream feel, with a more natural texture. Customers can mix and match flavors in different cup sizes, ranging from 4 oz to 32 oz. The owner fills the tubs to the brim, and while cones are not always visible, customers can ask if they are available. The shop also offers milkshakes, and some visitors have traveled from other areas just to enjoy the flavors. Overall, the shop is praised for its cleanliness, great service, and delicious flavors.