Simple, decent selection of flavors, large sizes at affordable prices, easy in and out
Saint Ray
Nasty, icy soft serve. You’re better off with the trucks on the street.
Katelyn Saul
Amazing service and very nice! Delicious ice cream!
Mei BH
Delicious ice cream and reasonable prices. Cailey was super friendly and sweet. Will return to try other unique flavors.
Carlos Chinchilla
The ice cream is delicious but the staff could be friendlier. The tip request is too high too.
Manav Shahi
Came here a while ago during their limited time breast milk ice cream popup. Surprisingly one of the best ice cream I’ve had in the city - super simple vanilla honey caramel tones and not too sweet, it’s a shame that flavor isn’t available anymore. Haven’t been back here since but big fan of the unique flavors and dedication to the marketing moment with the boxes and art on the walls.
Julia Mimidinovski
$15 ice cream for ONE ICE CREAM from the truck - out of a machine… btw this is regular old soft serve ice cream. are you kidding me? $15!! plus tax that’s hourly wage in nyc crazy . The prices were so tiny and in the corner (basically hidden) - taking advantage of people
Amy T
We order the coffee flavor and it was delicious, the views from the window were amazing.
M M
OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is such a fun and creative spot! The flavors are unique, playful, and really stand out compared to typical ice cream shops. Everything tasted super fresh and creamy, and you can tell they put thought into balancing flavors.
The shop itself has a cool, welcoming vibe, making it a great place to hang out with friends or just treat yourself. Definitely one of the nicest ice cream places I’ve tried—worth stopping by if you’re in the area!
chloe march
Ice cream was chill the only thing that was horrible was the cheap white spoon that was given for my nearly $12 ice cream I had to eat it with 1/3 of a spoon not a fan. Will bring my own spoon next time…
Simple, decent selection of flavors, large sizes at affordable prices, easy in and out
Nasty, icy soft serve. You’re better off with the trucks on the street.
Amazing service and very nice! Delicious ice cream!
Delicious ice cream and reasonable prices. Cailey was super friendly and sweet. Will return to try other unique flavors.
The ice cream is delicious but the staff could be friendlier. The tip request is too high too.
Came here a while ago during their limited time breast milk ice cream popup. Surprisingly one of the best ice cream I’ve had in the city - super simple vanilla honey caramel tones and not too sweet, it’s a shame that flavor isn’t available anymore. Haven’t been back here since but big fan of the unique flavors and dedication to the marketing moment with the boxes and art on the walls.
$15 ice cream for ONE ICE CREAM from the truck - out of a machine… btw this is regular old soft serve ice cream. are you kidding me? $15!! plus tax that’s hourly wage in nyc crazy .
The prices were so tiny and in the corner (basically hidden) - taking advantage of people
We order the coffee flavor and it was delicious, the views from the window were amazing.
OddFellows Ice Cream Co. is such a fun and creative spot! The flavors are unique, playful, and really stand out compared to typical ice cream shops. Everything tasted super fresh and creamy, and you can tell they put thought into balancing flavors.
The shop itself has a cool, welcoming vibe, making it a great place to hang out with friends or just treat yourself. Definitely one of the nicest ice cream places I’ve tried—worth stopping by if you’re in the area!
Ice cream was chill the only thing that was horrible was the cheap white spoon that was given for my nearly $12 ice cream I had to eat it with 1/3 of a spoon not a fan. Will bring my own spoon next time…
Restaurantji Recommends
It’s hype
I tried it. I took one bite just to try it. It tasted like salted caramel. Its cool just for the hype but its just average ice cream lol.
Sooooo good! Very unexpected but so so delicious.
amazing flavor and incredible branding - worth the trip for sure!!
Okk wooww — this place is seriously adorable and the boob-flavored ice cream is SO good! Obsessed with this pop-up!! 🍨💅💫
Loading...