I’ve been going to Petee’s Pie for many years and for the first time ever I had a bad experience with the quality of the pies. Not too sure if someone new was hired for production services but I came to this location on Sunday night and ordered 4 different slices of pie, my friend ordered another 5 slices, all 9 for us to share and taste. We were both super excited because I’ve been raving about how much I love their pies. We got strawberry rhubarb, guava mascarpone, lemon merengue, coconut custard, apple and 2 pecan pie slices. For starters, the bottom crust of all the pies were slightly underbaked and opaque. They didn’t have that beautiful, golden crisp crust we all know and love in a pie. Not too much of a big deal but two major issues we had is the strawberry rhubarb tasting like it was kept from the day before as to not waste it.. we could tell because the butter was almost cheesy in flavor and the top and bottom crust was very, very soft. The other issue was that the coconut custard was severely over baked and was reminiscent of scrambled eggs. :((( the guava mascarpone however, was exceptional. I love Petee’s and I hope this review helps push the production team to further investigate their quality control. Love you guys. Thanks!
Ji_Hea Kim
Two window seats that can fit 4-5 each, a couple of barstools, coffee, selection of teas, and top notch pies
Chelsi
Love their pies, perfect crust, however…
Tonight, my friends and I felt for a treat and decided to order in from Petee’s. Tell me why I opened the bag (didn’t even open the container) and 1/3 of my slice is missing 😒Why would you sell a pie slice that’s not whole?! I obviously can’t eat the rest because what if I just got someone’s half eaten pie…? This is weird man, just don’t sell the slice.
Shiyu C
Tried the cherry pie, it was mid. The staff was good, tho.
Hana Le
My partner and I come here regularly for pie and for coffee/chai since we live nearby. You really can't go wrong with any option but we are partial to the the Maine Blueberry Pie. Staff is always very kind and friendly and even though there is limited seating, we can usually find a spot to sit. Love that they are open late as well.
Blake R
Everything here was cute and cozy, service was fast and served gracefully. I got a hot chocolate and a chocolate pie slice. The pie slice was heavenly, extremely tasty. Although the hot chocolate tasted more like steamed milk than hot chocolate, tasty nevertheless.
Portia Jones
I can be very particular about pies and this is probably the only spot in NYC that not only has a consistent selection of a variety of pies, but each one is stellar every single time. I have my favorites (I always order at least one cherry slice), but have never been disappointed. Must try!!!
Lina Hsiao
I have NEVER had a bad pie. Blueberry is perfect if you want to go back to basics. Salty chocolate chess is great if you are going to share bc of how DENSE it is (but it is so good) lavish chocolate is perfect if you like chocolate and you are going to eat it ALONE. Cherry is perfect for after a home cooked meal (like a homey stew). Key lime is perfect to share with friends ( or coworkers) for those days you just wish you were back on the old citrus farm ( also good paired with summer stew) banana foster is my favorite for when I’m feeling wacky and whimsical. Sometimes I wish I could be baked into the pecan pie.
Alexandra Riesbri
I don’t live in nyc but every time I come here I pass by Petee’s. I would even say that I prefer their banana pie to the banana pudding from magnolia. The space is small but there’s a small counter that allows you to eat in place of take out your favourite slice.
Wandered in here and had the Salty Chocolate Chess pie and it was insanely good! Like if my stomach had no limit I would eat the whole pie! Super decadent and creamy!!! I paired it with the maple whipped cream (that they also make in house)!! Also appreciate their effort to have high quality and ethical ingredients!! The staff is also super sweet and welcoming! Also great at giving recommendations!!
-
I don't like to use extremes. But Petee's pies are likely the best pies I've ever had (tried pecan, pumpkin, cherry, blueberry and chocolate chess)
Candace Cooks
Excellent brown butter honey pecan pie!! So delicious! The crust was from scratch and flaky! Yum, yum yum! Can’t wait to try it again!
Shaquana L
Walked down Myrtle so many times and never came in. Today I decided to walk in and try the Blueberry sliced pie. Very delicious, tasty, fresh and perfection in a slice. Crafted and made with ?. I will be returning to tey the many various crafted baked goods.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wild Blueberry Pie
Cal DeJesus
Really delicious pies! I had the key lime, brown butter pecan and cheesecake. So much love went into these pies, you can taste it! The staff are very nice as well!
I’ve been going to Petee’s Pie for many years and for the first time ever I had a bad experience with the quality of the pies. Not too sure if someone new was hired for production services but I came to this location on Sunday night and ordered 4 different slices of pie, my friend ordered another 5 slices, all 9 for us to share and taste. We were both super excited because I’ve been raving about how much I love their pies. We got strawberry rhubarb, guava mascarpone, lemon merengue, coconut custard, apple and 2 pecan pie slices. For starters, the bottom crust of all the pies were slightly underbaked and opaque. They didn’t have that beautiful, golden crisp crust we all know and love in a pie. Not too much of a big deal but two major issues we had is the strawberry rhubarb tasting like it was kept from the day before as to not waste it.. we could tell because the butter was almost cheesy in flavor and the top and bottom crust was very, very soft. The other issue was that the coconut custard was severely over baked and was reminiscent of scrambled eggs. :((( the guava mascarpone however, was exceptional. I love Petee’s and I hope this review helps push the production team to further investigate their quality control. Love you guys. Thanks!
Two window seats that can fit 4-5 each, a couple of barstools, coffee, selection of teas, and top notch pies
Love their pies, perfect crust, however…
Tonight, my friends and I felt for a treat and decided to order in from Petee’s. Tell me why I opened the bag (didn’t even open the container) and 1/3 of my slice is missing 😒Why would you sell a pie slice that’s not whole?! I obviously can’t eat the rest because what if I just got someone’s half eaten pie…? This is weird man, just don’t sell the slice.
Tried the cherry pie, it was mid. The staff was good, tho.
My partner and I come here regularly for pie and for coffee/chai since we live nearby. You really can't go wrong with any option but we are partial to the the Maine Blueberry Pie. Staff is always very kind and friendly and even though there is limited seating, we can usually find a spot to sit. Love that they are open late as well.
Everything here was cute and cozy, service was fast and served gracefully. I got a hot chocolate and a chocolate pie slice. The pie slice was heavenly, extremely tasty. Although the hot chocolate tasted more like steamed milk than hot chocolate, tasty nevertheless.
I can be very particular about pies and this is probably the only spot in NYC that not only has a consistent selection of a variety of pies, but each one is stellar every single time. I have my favorites (I always order at least one cherry slice), but have never been disappointed. Must try!!!
I have NEVER had a bad pie. Blueberry is perfect if you want to go back to basics. Salty chocolate chess is great if you are going to share bc of how DENSE it is (but it is so good) lavish chocolate is perfect if you like chocolate and you are going to eat it ALONE. Cherry is perfect for after a home cooked meal (like a homey stew). Key lime is perfect to share with friends ( or coworkers) for those days you just wish you were back on the old citrus farm ( also good paired with summer stew) banana foster is my favorite for when I’m feeling wacky and whimsical. Sometimes I wish I could be baked into the pecan pie.
I don’t live in nyc but every time I come here I pass by Petee’s. I would even say that I prefer their banana pie to the banana pudding from magnolia.
The space is small but there’s a small counter that allows you to eat in place of take out your favourite slice.
Best pies ever.
Restaurantji Recommends
Wandered in here and had the Salty Chocolate Chess pie and it was insanely good! Like if my stomach had no limit I would eat the whole pie! Super decadent and creamy!!! I paired it with the maple whipped cream (that they also make in house)!! Also appreciate their effort to have high quality and ethical ingredients!! The staff is also super sweet and welcoming! Also great at giving recommendations!!
I don't like to use extremes. But Petee's pies are likely the best pies I've ever had (tried pecan, pumpkin, cherry, blueberry and chocolate chess)
Excellent brown butter honey pecan pie!! So delicious! The crust was from scratch and flaky! Yum, yum yum! Can’t wait to try it again!
Walked down Myrtle so many times and never came in. Today I decided to walk in and try the Blueberry sliced pie. Very delicious, tasty, fresh and perfection in a slice. Crafted and made with ?. I will be returning to tey the many various crafted baked goods.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wild Blueberry Pie
Really delicious pies! I had the key lime, brown butter pecan and cheesecake. So much love went into these pies, you can taste it! The staff are very nice as well!
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Key Lime Pie
Loading...