Surf City Pizzeria

$ • Italian, Pizza, Wraps

Hours:
837 Surf Ave, Brooklyn
(718) 676-4460

About Surf City Pizzeria

Surf City Pizzeria is a solid pizza spot in Coney Island with a great atmosphere and cool vibes. Reviewers call it the best pizza in Coney Island, Brooklyn, and possibly New York City. The food receives high praise, with specific highlights including the diablo slice, Gramma slice, square pepperoni, classic pepperoni, Sicilian BBQ chicken pie, meat lovers pizza, french fries, and calamari, all rated extremely highly. Anything with their vodka sauce comes highly recommended.

The service is described as amazing, unbeatable, very friendly, and pleasant, with fast and great service from great people. The restaurant is family-run and offers ample seating, comfortable even for large groups or those with a baby stroller. The space is ample and the location is great. Overall, it is a crazy solid pizza spot with the best food in Coney.

Customers' Favorites

Surf City Pizzeria Reviews

3.9
284 ratings
Restaurantji Rating
5
58%
4
12%
3
6%
2
5%
1
19%
Food
4.0
Atmosphere
4.1
Service
4.0

Share your opinion about Surf City Pizzeria

Restaurantji Rating

I had the pleasure of grabbing food to go. I love the food. I miss going there. I am in Florida and the more I eat here the more I miss Surf City.

Yes I would recommend Surf City Pizzeria.

The pizza was awesome & the cheesecake was divine!! Cheese sticks were great. I could have eaten a bowl of the marinara sauce. Great service!!

Read All Reviews(284)

Menu

Add a Menu
Surf City Pizzeria Menu
Surf City Pizzeria Menu

Photos

Add a Photo
Surf City Pizzeria
Surf City Pizzeria
View All Photos

Hours

Monday 11:30AM - 8PM
Tuesday 11:30AM - 8PM
Wednesday 11:30AM - 8PM
Thursday 11:30AM - 8PM
Friday 11:30AM - 8PM
Saturday 11:30AM - 8PM
Sunday 11:30AM - 8PM
Updated on: