Bar 1818

3139 Sheridan Dr, Amherst
(716) 398-4502

Recent Reviews

Gary B.

Drinks were too tiny and took too long, if I come back I will drink beer. Menu and pricing deceiving, if you ask for sides they are not an upcharge but full price and they leave out the original sides... even when I asked to keep them if its a full side charge. Broiled fish was way over done and soo very small and dry, one skinny little dried out fish on a huge empty plate. Mashed potatoes (3.99) cold and dry. Tuna was ok... but it comes with literally nothing for $15.99 .. soy sauce is the side, my wife requested 2 sides thinking they came with.. nope, $3.99 for small bowl of rice, $3.49 for little broccoli. Battered fish fry was adequate. Ambiance was ok and I liked that. In sum, really expensive for what you get, service was ok.

Lisa Geartz

We always pop in if we are nearby. Their unique selections of beer and cocktails has never disappointed us. The food is good too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Richard Rost

Surprisingly good for a bar in a grocery store... But I like it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Chuong Phu

Such good, much yum.

Tom Storm

Way better than you'd expect for a bar in a grocery store. Free pool table, good food, good cocktails and a good selection of local beers on tap.

Honky Tonk Guy

Never open, hours were confirmed by business online but we went here and they were closed. Got yelled at by employees for trying to go in. What a waste…

Hector G.

Chicken wings (Texas BBQ) are WACK and I'm positive all their wings are similar. Cauliflower tacos were cool , different but the tortillas were cold and diminished the meal. Beer selection is on point. Don't sit by the bar on summer evenings, the giant windows will make you uncomfortable.

Buffalo Guy

Never open, hours were confirmed by business online but we went here and they were closed. Got yelled at by employees for trying to go in. What a waste…

Josephine Andrews

Had an meeting there, was a great place!!

Vicky B.

This place was awesome! Neat atmosphere, and friendly service. There's bar and table seating. Menu is limited (burgers and small plates), beer list contains about 10 local beers, and there's also wines and cocktails. Order and pay at the bar. Food was absolutely delicious and came out pretty quickly! I loved the burger and was impressed with the very generous portion of fries! I'd love to come here again!

Jennifer Stoll

Meals came out 15 minutes apart with only two other people in the restaurant. Food was ok.

ClutchTastic

Beyond burger and regular pub burger review. Truffle fries review. All are garbage now. You pay a dollar for a powder that's added to the fries, not like the description. Beyond burger is now half the size it once was, literally. Ordered with lettuce bun. Before was a baby butter lettuce leaf now, it's a wrinkled nasty lookin lettuce leaf with no hardiness. Beef patty tasted like meatloaf with no seasoning. They now smash the patties which kills any flavor it would have had. Even the texture was horrendous. Ordered to go. Will not order from this menu ever again. We used to be regulars. Not anymore.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Review Time

This is the new menu. Food is delicious

Cactus L.

it takes a real unskilled professional to undercook french fries. the burger was good but they only offer a real meat burger and a fake meat burger. the real beef burger was really good hence the 3 stars. if the french fries had been cooked all of the way this could have gotten a better rating. the chicken sandwich is just on par and nothing special, same with the fish.

Clutch Tastic

New menu cauliflower nachos were great. The raw jalapeños were too strong. Needs to be grilled. Beyond burger cooked perfectly.

Load More