Black & Blue Steak and Crab, Buffalo NY
5493 Sheridan Dr, Amherst
(716) 839-2525
Customers' Favorites
Oysters on the Half Shell
Dry Aged New York Strip
Filet Mignon and Shrimp
Crab and Lobster Fondue
Sweet Potato Dumpling
Peanut Butter Dessert
Chocolate Truffles
Wagyu Meatballs
Mashed Potatoes
Chopped Salad
Menu
Photos
+96 photos
+95 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This has been my family's go to “nice” restaurant for years. The steak was cooked perfectly which was very nice, however they changed the fries and they were crunchy & terrible. My guest's placemat was falling apart on the corner and should have been thrown out and not used. After we payed our bill we continued to chat and we had empty water glasses for the rest of our evening while we sat next to empty tables. The single special sounds okay, but nothing else...
Everything was a good experience with the major exception being the quality of the steaks, which is a pretty big deal at a steak house. The rub way too salty and the medium rare steaks just were not tender and juicy. Our table of three had a very enjoyable Daou Cabernet, two filets and a ribeye along with calamari appetizer (the dipping sauce has a kick) and a couple of shared sides. Tab with tip was just north of $400 - the steaks made it a disappointing value.
Delicious meal. Very accommodating to celiac allergy, they even have gluten free roll for start of meal and brought out with fresh hands, separate plate and butter. We'll be back!
You May Also Like
Rachels Mediterranean Grill - 5493 Sheridan Dr
![]()
Mediterranean
Inchin's Bamboo Garden - 5415 Sheridan Dr
![]()
Asian Fusion, Indian, Chinese, Vegan