Cookies & Cream On Elmwood

929 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo
(716) 381-8699

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Steven Caldwell

I've only ever popped in for a soft serve cone when the craving hits, but the staff is quick and friendly, and the prices are reasonable, and you get a lot of ice cream on the cone. it's nice to have in the neighborhood

Sebastian Engels

Make sure to ask for the cookie to be warmed up! The Sea Salt Caramel + Macadamia Cookie combo slaps đŸ€©đŸ€©

John Logal

Google and the sign on the door says they're open on Sundays but when we got here they were closed. Next time!

Nique

I came here and they locked the doors 45 minutes early. There’s no storm or anything so I wasn’t sure why. The Google hours says one thing and I get all the way here and the doors are locked while the people are inside looking at me. Terrible!

*CORRECTION- after sitting outside of the building for 45 minutes (we were getting ready to pull off) we noticed a Caucasian couple being let in and served. Prior to that, myself tried to go in and the door was locked. Another African American approached and tried to go in and was not let in. It wasn’t until the Caucasian couple approached and tried to open the door that the door was opened. I went in and was greeted as if I wasn’t supposed to be there. Unbelievable!

Brianna Collier

The ice cream sandwich is the star of the show and fyi it can definitely be shared between two people!

Taylor Pitts

Either your hours are wrong on Google or you closed more than 15 minutes early tonight...

Nicholas Caruso

Cookies were amazing! But I'm really sad they didn't have the snackbar cookies

Holly Mosher

Cute place, ice cream was good & creamy.

Sarah Parry

Been here twice loved the ice cream and vibe which is why we came back but the service has been bad both times. Aloof confused teen girls. There’s GF cookies on the menu but both times they’ve said they’re all out and when I asked when they have them they said they had no idea. And then we got sundaes and they accidentally charged us extra for something, didn’t notice till we brought it up, and didn’t know how to fix it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 1

Brian Marciniak

A little expensive but good and a vibe for the Elmwood Village.

Max Hochman

Turned us away 20 minutes before listed closing time.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

John Dukat

Great dessert spot! Would be 5 if that duck machine was on mute.

evelyn y

poor service teenage employees goofing around had to wait 10 minutes just for a scoop of ice cream

Maggie Peter

Delicious delicious cookies! My favorite is the macadamia cookies, it’s soft and melts in your mouth. The ice creams are also great! The strawberry cheese cake ice cream flavor tops it off for me.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cookies & Cream

Brooke Z

Super cute little place, and while I appreciate that they’re pretty much the only ice cream place in the neighborhood, I can’t say I’m blown away. It says “shakes” on their window but they don’t serve shakes, disappointing and confusing right off the bat. The ice cream was gritty almost, like it thawed and was refrozen. The girls at the counter were nice but not super helpful to a couple folks who’d never been here before.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 2

Loading...