Hearth + Press

665 Main St, Buffalo
(716) 262-0866

Recent Reviews Order Online Reserve

Customers' Favorites

Kafana Dessert Pizza and Cannoli Siciliani
Truffle Burratta Caprese
Traditional White Pizza
French Press Coffee
Four Cheese Pizza
Margherita Pizza
Cast Iron Cookie
Calabrian Wings
Pepperoni Pizza
Meatball Pizza

Menu

Starters
Hot Pepper Dip
Blend of cheeses, banana peppers, sausage, served with a side of crostini
Calabrian Wings
Calabrian chili, Buffalo hot or Charred BB
Roasted Potatoes
Meatballs & Sauce
Hummus
Kalamata olives, EVOO, bread
Meat & Cheese plate
Parmagiano, fontinella, fresh mozz, accompaniments, bread

Salad
Goat Cheese Fruit Salad
Crumbled goat, arugula, walnuts, fruit, balsamic
Mediterranean Salad
Mesculin greens, fresh mozz, kalamata, sliced tomato, onion, house dressing
Rocket Salad
Arugula, parm, balsamic
Caprese Salad
Fresh mozz, sliced tomato, basil, EVOO, balsamic

Small Sides
Blue Cheese
Sliced Bread
House Salad
Warm Olives
Red Sauce

Toppings
Chicken
Prosciutto
Salami
Meatball
Shrimp
Sliced Steak

Pasta
Sausage Penne
Red Sauce, whipped ricotta, finished with EVOO, parm and basil
Meatball Penne
Red sauce, fresh mozz, finished with EVOO, parm and basil
Vegetarian Penne
Red Sauce, fresh mozz, finished with EVOO, parm and basil
Pesto Walnut Gnocchi
On a bed of arugula, finished with EVOO, parm and basil
Steak Gnocchi
Roasted mushrooms, cream sauce, finished with EVOO, parm and basil
3 Meat Gnocchi
Salami, sausage, proscuitto, red sauce, finished with EVOO, parm and basil
Shrimp Penne
Roasted mushroom and red peppers, cream sauce, finished with EVOO, parm and basil
Chicken Gnocchi
Finished with EVOO, parm and basil

Pizza
Calabrese Pizza
Fresh mozz, pepperoni, parm
Cheese Pizza
sauce and cheese
Margherita Pizza
basil, fresh mozz, EVOO
Funghi Pizza
mozz, parm, EVOO, roasted mushrooms and garlic
Prosciutto Pizza
fresh mozz, tomato, finished with arugula EVOO
4 Cheese Pizza
Fontina, goat, fresh mozz, parm, honey
Traditional White
EVOO, garlic, oregano, parm, mozz, onion, tomato
Sauasage Pizza
Fontina, roasted reds, parm
Roasted Veg Pizza
Eggplant, mushroom, roasted reds, tomato, goat, parm
Buf Chicken Pizza
Mozz, crumbled bleu cheese, chicken and hot sauce
Za'atar Pizza
EVOO, fontina, fresh mozz, kalamata, tomato, oregano, thyme, sumac, sesame
Buffalo Pizza
Mozz, meatballs, stuffed peppers, pepperoni
3 Meat Pizza
Fontins, goat, fresh mozz, parm

Dessert
Cast Iron Cookie
Fudge Brownie
Gelato 1 scoop
Tiramasu
Baklava

Photos

Photo credit: facebook
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+57 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+56 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

I really wanted to like this place more. The atmosphere was very quaint and warm. All of the food we ordered needed more love though. The potato appetizer was still raw when it arrived, the side salad was unremarkable and the Margarita pizza needed flavor. Also ordered the baklava and it came out cold and hard to cut. We went during the dinner rush so service was a little slow.
July 2025
We stopped in for dinner before a show at Shea's, they were booked but had space available at the bar.
The bartender was wonderful. He was incredibly busy, but we never felt neglected.
The food was outstanding, and the pilot grigio was one of the best I've had. We will definitely be back to try the baklava!
June 2025
Cannot brag enough about this spot. Super cool layout and atmosphere. Damien was phenomenal. Incredibly kind, great advice and great conversation. Meatballs here absolutely blew me away! Great job guys! Will be back.
May 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

42 North Brewing Company - 674 Main St
Brewery
Shea’s Bistro & Bar - 658 Main St
Italian, American, Vegetarian
The Bijou - 643 Main St
American, Italian, Cocktail Bar, Wine Bar, Vegetarian

Hearth + Press

665 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14203
(716) 262-0866