I've been in Buffalo for about 3 and a half years now and Mister Pizza is my favorite place I've found so far in a city full of great pizza places. The Elmwood location has a small lobby, so not much space to eat there, and late nights on weekends it can get a bit rowdy with the younger crowd coming from some of the local bars, so if you want a whole pizza, it's best to order online or by phone and pick it up.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Double Pepperoni
Mel D
Hubby wanted more cheese. We got the Sicilian with an olive oil base sauce. The crust was a bit bland so go for one of the flavors for crust. Also the medium was quite large, more than enough for two people. We got it to go. There’s a very small shelf and some stools for eating in or waiting for your order. No menus or prices were available but the customer service was nice and helpful, especially on a snowy, busy evening.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
Mehrab Jian Manzur
Taste of food: ExcellentTime of service: Takes longer than usualAtmosphere: Always took out, never dine
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Bellatrix Lestrange
Pizza is ALWAYS 10 out of 10 for sure!! My go to pizza place, even before I moved to Buffalo. Well worth the drive from NT in my opinion. Perfect amount of dough cheese and sauce!Don't mind the yellowish pic, my camera is terrible.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Trey Zilberg
Unfortunately last night we ordered 2 pizzas at around 11pm and they tasted like dish soap. Not sure if they just forgot to rinse the pans but they were inedible. My girlfriend and myself love Mister Pizza but I guess tonight was not the night to order from here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Rick Kraft
Ordered two sheet pizzas to get delivered to get in time for lunch. Was told about an hour and 15 minutes which was totally fine (called at 11:05). Over two hours later finally arrived (1:30), driver told us they had just called him in and the pizza was cold and rubbery.
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ramon Santiago
My childhood favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kelly Brown
Ignorant. Horrible customer service. Could have the best pizza in the world. And all the customers in the world. This lovely woman and her family and extended family will not be ordering here. Enjoy your money. I can see it's not making you happy.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Kingdom Krump
Destroy my pizza , over amounts of meat and olives
Paul Sickau
pizza was cold when pickedcheese was like chewing rubberdough so toooo thinall in all will nevet go toMister Pizza
Wasn’t impressed with their basic cheese and pepperoni pizza. Actually, it was quite bad.
Food: 3
Eric Poole
Used to be the best pizza in Buffalo now it’s barely average. 11:40am and they serve cold slices. They don’t even make their own blue cheese anymore.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
Lori Foglia
What happened to Mr. Pizza. 2 hrs for a delivery on a large 1/2 cheese and pepperoni and 20 wings. Called at an hour and 20 minutes said just got out of the oven and would be leaving in 5 minutes. Only to arrive cold.
Food: 2
Eric T.
Waited for over 2 hours for cold pizza and wings. I wouldn't recommend.
Daniel Gunderud
Love-hate relationship with Mr Pizza. The food is mostly good, and the service is gruff but good. The sauce is top-notch, but not always (consistency issues). And good mozzarella.They need a dedicated phone person so you don't get the "Mr Pizza Elmwood, please hold - click".... I feel bad for the front-end staff.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust
I've been in Buffalo for about 3 and a half years now and Mister Pizza is my favorite place I've found so far in a city full of great pizza places. The Elmwood location has a small lobby, so not much space to eat there, and late nights on weekends it can get a bit rowdy with the younger crowd coming from some of the local bars, so if you want a whole pizza, it's best to order online or by phone and pick it up.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Double Pepperoni
Hubby wanted more cheese. We got the Sicilian with an olive oil base sauce. The crust was a bit bland so go for one of the flavors for crust. Also the medium was quite large, more than enough for two people. We got it to go. There’s a very small shelf and some stools for eating in or waiting for your order. No menus or prices were available but the customer service was nice and helpful, especially on a snowy, busy evening.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: White Pizza
Taste of food: ExcellentTime of service: Takes longer than usualAtmosphere: Always took out, never dine
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Pizza is ALWAYS 10 out of 10 for sure!! My go to pizza place, even before I moved to Buffalo. Well worth the drive from NT in my opinion. Perfect amount of dough cheese and sauce!Don't mind the yellowish pic, my camera is terrible.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Unfortunately last night we ordered 2 pizzas at around 11pm and they tasted like dish soap. Not sure if they just forgot to rinse the pans but they were inedible. My girlfriend and myself love Mister Pizza but I guess tonight was not the night to order from here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 5
Ordered two sheet pizzas to get delivered to get in time for lunch. Was told about an hour and 15 minutes which was totally fine (called at 11:05). Over two hours later finally arrived (1:30), driver told us they had just called him in and the pizza was cold and rubbery.
Food: 1
Service: 1
My childhood favorite.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ignorant. Horrible customer service. Could have the best pizza in the world. And all the customers in the world. This lovely woman and her family and extended family will not be ordering here. Enjoy your money. I can see it's not making you happy.
Atmosphere: 1
Service: 1
Destroy my pizza , over amounts of meat and olives
pizza was cold when pickedcheese was like chewing rubberdough so toooo thinall in all will nevet go toMister Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Wasn’t impressed with their basic cheese and pepperoni pizza. Actually, it was quite bad.
Food: 3
Used to be the best pizza in Buffalo now it’s barely average. 11:40am and they serve cold slices. They don’t even make their own blue cheese anymore.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 3
Service: 1
What happened to Mr. Pizza. 2 hrs for a delivery on a large 1/2 cheese and pepperoni and 20 wings. Called at an hour and 20 minutes said just got out of the oven and would be leaving in 5 minutes. Only to arrive cold.
Food: 2
Waited for over 2 hours for cold pizza and wings. I wouldn't recommend.
Love-hate relationship with Mr Pizza. The food is mostly good, and the service is gruff but good. The sauce is top-notch, but not always (consistency issues). And good mozzarella.They need a dedicated phone person so you don't get the "Mr Pizza Elmwood, please hold - click".... I feel bad for the front-end staff.Dietary restrictions: Gluten free crust
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 3