Mister Pizza Elmwood
$ • Pizza, Chicken Wings, VeganAbout Mister Pizza Elmwood
Customers' Favorites
Pizza with Cheese and Margherita Pepperoni
Beer Battered Fish Dinner
Philly Cheese Steak Pizza
Double Pepperoni
The Works Pizza
Chicken Finger
Chicken Wings
White Pizza
Fried Dough
Large Pizza
Mister Pizza Elmwood Reviews
328 ratings
Share your opinion about Mister Pizza Elmwood
I can’t say enough good things about Mr. Pizza! Their food is absolutely amazing—whether you’re in the mood for their delicious pizza, crispy wings, or hearty subs, they always deliver top-notch quality and flavor. 🍕🍗
Thank you for not only serving great food but also for supporting local youth sports like the Amherst Thunder 10U girls’ softball team. Your generosity makes such a difference in our community!
If you haven’t tried Mr. Pizza yet, don’t...read full review
Thank you for not only serving great food but also for supporting local youth sports like the Amherst Thunder 10U girls’ softball team. Your generosity makes such a difference in our community!
If you haven’t tried Mr. Pizza yet, don’t...read full review
I have to say, I was really nervous about returning to order a pizza after the restaurant changed ownership back in March 2026. It was my birthday and I decided to place a take out order for my favorite custom pizza. After the first bite, I had to call the restuarant and tell them how delicious it was! I took one bite and it was a symphany of flavors, I tasted this buttery, savory, amazing rush of flavor! It was fresh, the crust was perfect, the sauce and everything was in perfect...read full review
Rob is the best! The pizza was incredible and the staff were so friendly! Love this place!
Hours
| Monday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Tuesday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Wednesday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Thursday | 10AM - 11PM |
| Friday | 10AM - 12AM |
| Saturday | 10AM - 12AM |
| Sunday | 10AM - 11PM |
Mister Pizza Elmwood is a restaurant that is open late, making it a convenient choice for those arriving in Buffalo at odd hours. They offer a wide selection of pizzas, wings, and hearty subs that have received mixed reviews. While some customers praise their amazing food and delicious taste, others find it just average. However, the food is consistently noted for its top-notch quality and flavor, especially the pizza with its perfectly cooked crust and the crispy wings.
Customer service at Mister Pizza Elmwood is frequently highlighted, with mentions of friendly delivery drivers and quick service. Despite previous concerns about cleanliness, many reviews express a positive experience overall. Additionally, the restaurant supports local youth sports teams, which has earned appreciation from the community. For those looking for great food in a late-night setting, Mister Pizza Elmwood is a top choice to consider.