50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Buffalo

“Amazing food and a fun friendly atmosphere! the co owner came out to greet us and we thought that was SO cool! highly recommended!!“

“Popped in for their one year anniversary where they were offering up dollar slices and I got the New York style and it was solid. Definitely looking forward to visiting again to check out some of their cocktails. I really like their business model and that they are a tip-less establishment because of their practices in paying their employees which is cool.“

“Had the best dinner out in a very long time. Sea Bass special. Not sure I would have ordered it if the dish was written out. Too many things added in that I ultimately didn't know what they were. Not a big pesto fan and the dish came in a bath of creamy green with an odd looking chutney of sorts on top. The green was a fantastic pesto tinged super flavorful sauce and the topping was a grand mix of sweet, savory and nut crunch, a fantastic meal.“

“Best pizza around! Quality is always consistent.“

“I love this restaurant. Food is delicious 😋.“

“shout out to your Kenmore location! Super fast delivery today very kind delivery man made my night when he thanked me for leaving him a tip. Tips have become such standard practice for everything it was nice to get a thank you!And as always great food at reasonable prices!“

“The BEST Italian food ever. I've been many, many time in the restaurant as well as caterer food for the Christmas Holidays for years and years. I wouldn't choose anywhere else. Thanks for such great service and being so friendly. Lorenzo gets an A+++“

“Went there for the first time and all of us had the fish fry dinner. It was all perfectly cooked and tasted amazing. We will definitely be back another time to try the pizza and wings.“

“I accidentally purchased a gift card here thinking it was a different Brick Oven location (my mistake!). When I called, they were so gracious and told me returning it wouldn’t be an issue. We decided to give it a try instead and wow, we’re so glad we did. The food was absolutely delicious and the service was outstanding. Everyone was friendly and attentive. It’s not local to us, but we’re in the area often and will absolutely be back. So happy we discovered this place!“

“I absolutely would recommend Johnny’s. Our party of 9 walked in and was instantly greeted with the warmest Buffalo welcome during half time. We were out celebrating my son’s 12th birthday, it also happened to be an employees birthday. They brought out a piece of cake(his favorite too!) right before serving us with 4 huge pizza pies and appetizers. We live over an hour away and cannot wait to come back. Thank you guys, fantastic dining experience we appreciate it!!! ❤️💙“

“Just had a sausage sub, chicken finger sub, and steak sub. Just delicious. Thanks“

“Great for a fast and delicious slice of pizza.“

“Just had a sausage sub, chicken finger sub, and steak sub. Just delicious. Thanks“

“Although I am typically a traditional cheese and pepperoni pizza eater, I was in the mood for something not so traditional. I decided to try the General Tso pizza. Once again Mustachio's exceeded my expectations. The chicken pieces were meaty and perfectly coated. The sauce was flavorful with just a little 'kick' to it. The crust as always was exceptional. Thank you Mustachio's for making my quest away from the traditional a tasty experience!“

“Definitely recommend!! Just had the best hot wings I’ve had in YEARS! Whatever you guys are doing, keep it up! Seriously, your cooks absolutely rocked our socks off tonight. The wings were spicy with a nice after burn and they expertly walked the line between well-sauced but not slimy. The pizza was great too, as well a couple subs we ordered. Pizza works also has great chicken fingers, fries and onion rings. They have been very reliably great the past year or so with fast service“

“WORK FROM HOME !!! • work on Monday - Friday, or Thursday to Saturday 2/3 hours daily, Learn trade on the foreign exchange market through our trading platform earn very highly everyday DM FOR MORE INFO ℹ️“

“Order well done / thin crust. Best pie I had in Buffalo, compared to the thick“

“Best place for pizza in Buffalo... Michael you are not only amazing...but so kind and generous!!! I wish you could have seen the faces of my students and they devoured that antipasto as well as the pizzas!!! Ann thank you for coming in early to deliver...you're the best! Service and food are over the top!“

“Great food and beautiful atmosphere! Been here many times and it's been a great experience every time!! Enjoyed Mothers day with my large family today and we had a wonderful brunch buffet! Great service all around!!!“

“Not from the area and knowing where to go, it's down the street and tried it out. Their food is really good and I have not had anything there I don't recommend. I'm a big fan of their subs and the taco crunch I tried last night was really good. Thank you for the great food and service! I'd add photos but I already ate it so I recommend buying some and taking your own photos!“

“Ed is a GOAT. Highly recommend.“

“Just had the slice and salad lunch combo from the Union Rd. location. Very good.“

“This is my favorite place for pizza, subs, wings, and salads. I am moving about an hour away which means I will have to stop here every time I come back to the area. Service is great...food is fabulous...you really get what you pay for and then some. I highly reccomend.“

“Everything I've ever tried at Mayback's has been delicious. From the breakfast pizza to the regular pizza. This is one of the only places in the 716 that makes good chicken fingers (the honey mustard ones are divine) and a good cheese steak. The fish fry is the best I've had in years. If you want a real treat try the turkey sub with pickles and extra meat. The freshest salads I've ever had. Food is amazing, prices are great, and everyone who works there is friendly. They've got something for everyone. Easily my favorite place to get food in Buffalo.“

“The service is always friendly. It’s a family owned place, true to the Buffalo roots. Great homemade blue cheese and the slices are huge. I work around the corner and they’ve always treated me well, never a bad experience. Prices are reasonable and I’ll be honest- they deserve your business.“

“Stopped in the Plaza and grabbed Lunch in Orchard Park NY. I love this place. Salad is always Fresh. Happy Friday!“

“The service/hospitality absolutely matches the quality and flavor of food. When you think of real good pizza and wings this place is top 3 100%. Before stoping at a huge chain it’s 1000% worth trying!“

“The best NY style pizza in Buffalo! It’s a little bit of a drive but definitely worth it. Straight up Cheese pizza was #1. Best I’ve had in a long time.“

“Great pizza, kind staff. I'll never get pizza from anywhere else, this place is #1! 👏🏻👏🏻“

“I have been ordering pizza and subs for over a year now. First time I have had a problem ordered a pizza yesterday and it was over cooked was dry like no cheese and no pepperoni.“

“We was in the buffalo area and was looking for a good pie. Figured we would check it out. Pizza was very good but the sauce was a little sweet for my liking. But if I was in the area again I would have it again.“

“I love this place! The food is delicious and the owners and staff are amazing and very friendly! I look forward to placing an order and enjoy it often, supporting this business makes me happy and they never disappoint! Highly recommend you try Ricotta’s Pizza on Niagara St. It’s the best! My favorites: double steak hoagie, chicken finger sub, garlic parm fries, pepperoni pizza by the slice, full pizza with hot peppers, green olives, mushroom & onion. So many great other options but these are a few I have ordered many time. Definitely my spot! Love it! Thank you Ricotta’s for your quality and service!“

“undeniably the best pizza I've ever Had, super proud to be slinging pies here these Days,“

“Great people clean establishment. Found myself taking a long drive to the west side of buffalo for La-Nova's BBQ on the pit wings.
Emergency pizzeria in my experience is closer the wings are great but nobody will ever duplicate a la-nova BBQ wing.“

“First the Turkey club, then I went and tried the steak hoagie, ham is usually my go to. Every order is perfect and delicious, there's a a guy named Don and a Ryan I'm pretty sure that's their names .I try to order when they are working, since I had a bad experience ordering when a girl was working, no offense but I asked for a lightly toasted roll and it was burnt and hard as a rock lol other than that. Mr subs is delicious!!!!“

“Great experience overall! Been trying to get by and try this pizzeria for a while, live in NF and trek to Buffalo weekly. Was completely with the stop! Friendly, quaint, and pizza was excellent! Love the Detroit style as ingredients were fresh and pizza baked to perfection for us honestly. Will definitely return!“

“We held our Company employee picnic just this past weekend. Everything was perfectly set up, the food was excellent, the grounds were perfect for bounce houses, balloon creations, basketball, and ice cream truck, corn hole, horseshoes. There was something for everyone. Bartender and customer service people were helpful and happy. Not sure if they had a hand in the weather, but that was perfect too. Our party was over 400 strong. We'll be sure to book again next year! Highly recommended.“

“Okay, first thing you have to try the cookies. I know it’s a pizzeria, but the chocolate chip and peanut butter cookies are on another level. I don’t know what they put in them, but they are seriously outstanding.

Now the pizza? That’s a whole different game. It’s absolutely delicious classic New York–style: thin, not greasy, and with the perfect amount of pepperoni. You can really taste the quality.

Honestly, I don’t get pizza anywhere else anymore. Pro tip: if you take it home and heat it up, it’s still amazing (and super quick). Highly recommend this place!“

“I have been a customer for over 30 years.. I love love love the pizza..the dough and sauce are the best..The wings are big and always cooked too perfection along with subs and other menu items!! I highly recommend Bob and Johns“

“Conveniently located, delicious food, peaceful atmosphere, reasonable prices, huge portions, friendly & thoughtful service, clean atmosphere.“

“Had a great time watching the Sabres vs Montreal. Great atmosphere, great food, attractive waitresses.“

“The Buffalo chicken deep dish with blue cheese is slammin'! Nice, big slices. it's light, not too heavy..Felt like I could eat a whole pie !“

“we found this place a cpl weeks ago and have ordered from at least 2x a week now. my favorite is their massive burger. it is so dam big I can only eat 1/2 and save the other. but their mini fried doughs are out of this world!!! They're like mini clouds of powdery chewy air. legit my favorite place.“

“The food is always amazing! Got a taco pizza today and omg so good and thick and heavy! The service is always great and the ordernis always right and the prices are really fair! I live in Florida now and come visit and they never fail me! Keep it up everyone the food is delicious!! Thanks for always being so friendly too! I highly recommend this place to everyone who wants good pizza and more!“

“I was calling around my favorite semi truck and trailer parts suppliers and was pointed to this company for flanged frame bolts. Got everything I needed to get my cross members replaced in my 2000 international 9400. Glad to know they are here for the next project.“

“The food was The bomb, the drinks was the bomb, the waitress was the bomb !!“

“I love this place so much! The pricing is very reasonable, and it’s the only place where I can find an amazing fish fry for under $20. Support your local mom and pop shops because this place is absolutely amazing! 10/10 all the way around.“

“Young man who runs the counter most of the time, Jacob is very nice. Go there a few times and he'll start to recognize you. But their burger and fries, is the best deal in town. Way better than any fast food place and you get so much more than you would. Other places. $8.99 for a ton of fries and a fresh burger can't be beat“

“First time in Buffalo and this place was recommended for ‘authentic’ Buffalo style pizza. Excellent, friendly service, great value. Staff recommended the pepperoni and cheese as well wanted to experience the authentic Buffalo pizza. The sauce was slightly sweet and the pepperoni was not like the usual pepperoni, it wasn’t salty, and had a very mild spice kick to it (not hot) very happy that we tried this place and would definitely recommend them to others“

“food was delicious and people were awesome!“