50 Best Pizza Restaurants in Buffalo

“Mel was awesome! She went above and beyond to make it a fun date night for my wife and I. We HIGHLY recommend the ahi tuna. The Wasabi sauce is a must try with it! The homemade blue cheese is also incredible!Drinks A++. Nothing bad about this experience at all and we will be back very soon!“

“Popped in for their one year anniversary where they were offering up dollar slices and I got the New York style and it was solid. Definitely looking forward to visiting again to check out some of their cocktails. I really like their business model and that they are a tip-less establishment because of their practices in paying their employees which is cool.“

“Had an amazing experience here with 4 of us and a toddler. Service was great, food was out of this world, and the atmosphere was cozy. Can't wait to come back! Had the best French onion soup I've ever had and an Alfredo pasta that I've been dreaming about.“

“A great experience! WORD OF ITALIANS!We happened upon this restaurant by chance as it was close to our hotel and we couldn't leave happier. Really great food, we tried both the pizza and the homemade ravioli (super recommended!). After several days in the US eating burgers all the time we were really happy to find a place that made us feel right at home. The waiters were friendly and helpful and the owner even helped us with advice on what to visit in this area. I recommend it to anyone making a stop in Phoenix!“

“Went there this week while attending a film festival. Hands down one of my favorite dining experiences. The food is TOP NOTCH. Had the Margherita pizza and Macaroni Al Forno. Tried my girlfriend’s meatballs. All Unreal. Also, Felix is one of the best owners and the care and love at this place was amazing to see. Can’t wait to visit Buffalo again just to eat here again!“

“Tried this Pizzeria for the first time tonight, will definitely be back! Got a Large Cheese and Pepperoni, 10 Fingers with Fries, Single order (12) Garlic Parm Wings, order of Pizza Logs. Everything was very good! Staff were very polite and got people in and out. The 2 ladies in front of me were referred to by name so I assume they are “regulars”. I pay attention to things like that, repeat customers are a sign of good food and value (at least to me). Prices were VERY REASONABLE!! Would have paid considerably more at most places. I have gotten pizza from probably 20-30 different places in Western New York. Don’t mind going “out of my way” for good food at a good price and this place was worth my trip!“

“The food here is always good, I've never gotten a bad meal here all though this portions are big and I typically get the fettuccine Alfredo and I can get two more meals off of my leftovers. The staff is always nice and the restaurant its self isn't bad.“

“Went here for dinner on Wednesday night. As soon as I walked in the door, the smell of fish hit my face which wasn’t a good sign. But I was with my mom and I didn’t want to disappoint her, so decided to stick with this place and see how the food was. We got the pork trilogy, which is basically Sunday sauce, the flavor of the meat was good it just needed more salt. We also got the special pizza which was sopresatta, that was very yummy. We got the burrata salad appetizer, which was my mom’s favorite, it was interesting and pretty good. I’ve never had burrata with roasted apples under it, but I would eat it again. We finished with creme brulee because it’s our favorite and it was great. Our server was kind of standoffish. All in all this was a decent experience but it left a little to be desired.“

“Placed my first order tonight at Mustachio’s. My grilled chicken sub was absolutely DELICIOUS!! You can tell they use high quality chicken and it was cooked perfection. Perfect amount of lettuce and oil on a toasted, fresh sub roll. I’ve stopped going to other places because the quality of their chicken declined so Mustachios is now my go to pizzeria. Slice of pizza was also A++.“

“I ordered pizza for pick up at 7:45pm. They close at 8pm. But because of work, I was 30 minutes late to pick it up. So the owner was forced to wait for me to close. And still he greeted me with a smile and kindness. I felt horrible for being that late and holding them all, but they didn't show a hint of frustration and it was all smiles and great customer service. And when I got home, the pizza was still hot, AND delicious! They make it hard to go anywhere else to get pizza for me. Absolutely LOVE this family and this business!“

“I was here in Buffalo during Thanksgiving break, so I came here with my cousins to get some pizza. We ordered off the phone, they made the pizza perfect and on time! I came here a few times previously when I was in Buffalo, absolutely delicious Everytime! Wonderful customer service, definitely recommending to anyone wanting halal food or just yummy pizza! ?“

“This place is amazing! Came to buffalo for a hockey game and found this gem. Food is incredible and the service is even better - the people that run the spot are the most thoughtful and kind people around. Will be going back when I’m back in the city.“

“This place is why I love local places!I’ve been going here for almost a year and not once have I had an issue with anything I’ve ordered! Fries are always crispy on the exterior and fluffy on the inside, burgers are always on point (especially with the burger sauce), the gyros are some of the best in the area, and their chicken is always cooked perfectly!The staff have always been courteous and kind to myself and my brother, and they definitely show the love for what they do.I couldn’t recommend this place enough for anyone to try!“

“I finally got to Imperial this past weekend while I was in town for a visit. I went with my brother and we had a couple of beers at the bar and got some pizza and wings to go. Excellent all around, and I will definitely be going back again next time I'm in Buffalo.“

“Such an awesome spot! My and a large group of friends came here for my birthday and we had such a great time. The drinks and food are phenomenal as well as the atmosphere. The bar staff was super friendly and personable. Even when my group became loud they handled the situation professionally. I cannot recommend them enough.“

“BEST PIE IN AND AROUND BUFFALO!!! THE TOPPINGS ARE TOOOOO GENEROUS AND THE FLAVOR IS ONE TO SAVOR!!! THE ONLY COMPLAINT I HAD WAS TOOO MANY SELECTIONS I WANTED TO TRY AND NOT ENOUGH ROOM IN MY BELLY!!! GREAT BILLS/SABRES ATMOSPHERE AND IF YOU'RE LUCKY THE OWNER SITS DOWN TO EAT WITH YA AND YOU HAVE ONE OF THE BEST CONVERSATIONS IN YOUR LIFE!! ILL BE STOPPING HERE EVERYTIME I COME CLOSE TO THIS CITY!! BUFFALO HAS A GEM IN JOHNNY'S PIZZERIA & RESTAURANT!! THANKS MARK FOR A MEMORABLE AND DELICIOUS TIME!! TILL WE MEET/EAT AGAIN MY FRIEMD!“

“Hands down one of the best Italian restaurants in Buffalo. All of the locations are amazing, go above and beyond. Food is always delicious and cooked perfectly. My go to for lunch at work (the salad….are you serious SO YUMMY!) and the dinner. Just do yourself a favor and eat here. I never go out of my way to leave reviews, but I had to for them, I cannot say enough good things!“

“I recently had the pleasure of dining at Roost, located on Niagara Street in Buffalo, NY, and I must say, the experience was nothing short of phenomenal. From the moment I walked in, I was struck by the modern and stylish atmosphere of the place. It felt perfect for both a casual meal and a special celebration.The seasonal menu was a highlight, showcasing a commitment to local ingredients that I deeply appreciate. It's clear that Roost supports the local economy by choosing fresh, high-quality ingredients, and this philosophy shines through in every dish. I was impressed by the creativity and innovation of the menu. Each dish offered a new experience, blending familiar flavors with exciting twists that tantalized my taste buds.Chef Martin Danilowicz’s expertise was evident in every bite. His approach to cooking—melding classic techniques with innovative ideas—resulted in dishes that were both comforting and utterly unique. The craft cocktails and local beers at the bar were the perfect accompaniment to our meal, contributing to a truly memorable dining experience.The service at Roost was impeccable. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, adding a personal touch to our evening that made us feel truly welcome.In conclusion, my visit to Roost was an exceptional dining experience. The combination of delicious food, inviting atmosphere, and outstanding service has firmly established it as a must-visit destination in Buffalo. I can’t wait to return and see what Chef Danilowicz and his team have in store for the next season!“

“I work in the area and love this spot. Cup and char pepperoni on the pizza and it was done to perfection! Subs are also very tasty. I've tried multiple kinds of subs, and all have been satisfying, but once I tried the stuffed banana pepper option added to my sub it ruined me for subs any other way . The peppers take the sub over the top! Try this place if you haven't been there yet!“

“Great food (I won't shut up about their pizza), great service (everyone is so nice and just want you to eat well)! The prices are so friendly to one's wallet, especially when factoring in how GOOD the food is! Each bite of the various food I'd gotten here had me thinking "This would be $x more somewhere else." Highly recommended. Definitely taking my little family here next time we're in Buffalo!“

“This is the third time I have been here to enjoy an evening of entertainment, beer and great food. I have not been disappointed! Every meal has been delicious and the service is very attentive,and all of this on a Tuesday. This venue has so much to offer.“

“There are certainly no shortage of great pizzerias to choose from near South Buffalo, but Desi's is my first choice now after having tried quite a few. Ordering is super convenient through the Slice app and they always have it ready very quickly. As others have mentioned, the owner works in the kitchen and has personally prepared every pizza I've ordered. He's incredibly hard working and kind, and he remembers his regulars. Also, the pizza is plain great - one of the few Buffalo joints that actually cooks the pie long enough instead of giving you something that is too doughy or bread-like.You could pay a fortune for a pizza from Imperial, but for my money I'd much rather support Desi's and get a great product for a fair price. Don't forget to tip well if you can! ✌️“

“Okey dokey, these guys are great. Super friendly, great food. If you're thinking "it's a restaurant in a beer store" yeah it is. Guess what, best wings I've ever had and they're priced well. Don't get all snobby and think you can't get great food at a place like this. Thier menu has allot to offer if you want to go outside of late nite drunk food but the late nite drunk food is also great. Support this awesome Allentown business!!!!“

“The gluten-free pizza was very good. The crust was the thinner type so I'm not sure they make it but it was actually very tasty. It wasn't a thick fluffy pan pizza Detroit style crust but it did taste very good. My partner got regular pizza and he loved it. I like their sauce it wasn't too sweet but it still had some sweetness. The wings or meaty. We got extra sauce and it definitely was very saucy what you really like. Definitely will be going back! The only sad thing I am one of those weirdos who likes ham pineapple and mild pepper rings on my pizza. They don't have pineapple and mild pepper rings.“

“I dealt with this gentleman i believe his name was Sean or Sheen or Shawn. I am a frequent customer with many different food locations yet have never received such amazing customer service from a late night hotspot. The moz sticks & wings that this young man made were phenomenal, i have never been so impressed. I will be back to this location and would highly recommend to friends and family. If you go, ask for shawn. The food is truly loved.Kid-friendliness: Amazing customer service. I would bring my child here to enjoy a late night dish.“

“They generally have good food; however, in the past 2 years, the quality of their pizza has dropped significantly. The crust is almost nonexistent, the toppings are scant. Last night we ordered a large pizza: cheese, pepperoni, and banana peppers. The cheese and pepperoni were a good amount (i.e. not great), the banana peppers were almost nonexistent. The quality has suffered and not up to the standards they had when they were located on Center Road. It appears that profit has outweighed quality: Less dough per pizza equals more money in the pocket. The price has increased to almost $60 for a large pizza and a double order of wings. It used to be $40. Less product for more money. I do understand that the cost of doing business has increased, but the quality should not suffer related to that. I would think that, with the current influx of travelers for the eclipse, they would want to put their best foot forward. And, for the current loyal customers, i.e. us, they would want to maintain them. We have been loyal to Pasquale's for well over 20 years. You need to rethink your attitude toward product.“

“My office just recently moved into the area and I'm so glad to have discovered this gem that is within walking distance. Great menu, great food and most importantly great service. When moving office locations one of my main concerns was where to eat and finding this wonderful family-run business has been the best part of the relocation. 5 stars!“

“Seriously the pizza here is the best. Fingers are always cooked to perfection! My oldest child is severely autistic and nonverbal has feeding issues and can't eat pizza so I'm glad they have that meatball dinner which he CAN eat. The menu says it comes with 4 meatballs but they always outdo themselves and give him at least 6! Amazing! They're delicious and always piping hot when they arrive. One time we left a really nice note while ordering online and they snuck in a FREE pizza coupon in the pizza box. What a nice surprise. Staff are amazing too. I love that WiseGuys is always out there in the community, helping out. That's why I think they stand out from the rest. Not many pizza joints are as generous. The drivers are always kind! We always make sure that we give the drivers at least a $20 tip because they rock at what they do!“

“Had a Galentines dinner here with 12 of us. Great options on the specials menu, fresh food, tasty, and the price is right. Some housemade pasta, delish cacciatore with super fresh veggies and sausage, and pastries basically anything you want. Highly recommend for a casual lunch or dinner. You'll have leftovers for sure! Yaaay!Vegetarian options: Gluten free and plenty of options for ovo lacto vegetarians for sure.“

“We are from the Northtowns and were picking up a friend from nearby Mercy Hospital when we learned there would be a delay so we found Imperial Pizza where we had an unexpected lunch. We had no idea what to expect and what an unexpected wonderful time we had! The Reuben Pizza was fantastic and the ambiance and the service were equally fantastic! Highly recommended!“

“I'm a fan of this small local chain I don't know why I don't come to them more often. I've done both pizzas and salads. Because pizza is my favorite food group. I probably prefer those to the salads, but the salads are great and easy to take out with Easy parking.“

“The pizza is delicious. The dining area looks way better being freshly painted. It's a pick-up or delivery pizzeria but has the accommodations to eat in.Vegetarian options: I'm not sure but our friend we took out for her birthday. She's a vegetarian . This is her favorite pizza ours, too. She orders hers with olives. They have plenty of vegetables to choose from.Parking: It's not huge, but we never had a problem with parking ever.“

“I can say easily this pizza was top notch! Ordered on Super Bowl ? first time ever trying here, and all I can say is WOW! Super delicious, and well worth every penny. You gained another customer! Thank you so much for making some good pizza! Anyone interested in trying this place out, you will NOT be disappointed!“

“This was our second stop on our Wing Trail in Buffalo. It was a high recommendation from our waitress at Gabriele's Gate. It was dead when we got there at around noon on a Thursday, which was unusual. But the Garlic Parm wings were really good. Saucy, crispy, and very savory. And the Bucket O Beers was a great deal for a bunch of really good beers.“

“The food is excellent !! we did have to wait a bit for service...but we came in while the St Paddys day parade was going in..so the place was packed. The Charlie wings are fantastic..and the beef on weck pizza was on point. Will definitely go again.“

“shout out to your Kenmore location! Super fast delivery today very kind delivery man made my night when he thanked me for leaving him a tip. Tips have become such standard practice for everything it was nice to get a thank you!And as always great food at reasonable prices!“

“Came into Buffalo really late last Friday for the Bills game. We wanted some pizza and everything else around us was closed. This place was open and had some really tasty pizza. The owner thought I was a dolphins fan because I said I came in for the game, but once we cleared that up we had a nice little chat too. Would definitely get pizza here again next time I'm in town.“

“Ordered online with the slice app for a 1 pm delivery to my work and the food came right on time. Everyone really enjoyed it! I will say there are a lot of choices in the area but quality and consistency are key for getting a return customer. Thanks again it was totally worth it!“

“We're renting an apt in Kaisertown while waiting to close on a house in Depew. Molino's is right around the block from our apt, so decided to give it a whirl, despite the mixed reviews. We were pleasantly surprised. The wait time was short-about 20 minutes. Sandwiches were good,(We got the royal and the white pizza) and the all the way pizza was tasty. Not as good as Picasso's kitchen sink, but way better than some others. Plenty of toppings. Their crust is good too. Not a traditional Buffalo crust, but it's homemade and has a good chew to it. I assume the breadsticks are made out of the same dough, but they need some seasoning on them. Marinara sauce was good, and the cheesy garlic bread was loaded with cheese. I'd skip the sticks next time. They have some of the best prices in town, and offer up some good specials, but they close by 8, so no late night craving fulfillment from Molino's. Note also-this is strictly a carryout or delivery joint-there's nowhere to sit and eat here.“

“Went here pick up a Doordash and wow the way I was treated just amazing my granddaughter is in children's hospital and immediately he said prayers to her and my family then cause of his kind heart he gave me 3 slices and 2 drinks for me and my grandson after I only asked how the pizza tasted I just meant him and wow was greeted with open arms it brought tears to my eyes AND THE PIZZA WAS SO SO SO SO MMMM MMMM Delicious if anyone wants to know how the pizza is you must try it your gonna say mmmm mmmm and it's down to earth people there 0 to 10 its 15 + awesome place awesome pizza ty again for prayers that means more than anything else to me“

“Mr. Submarine has done it again, we were very satisfied with the 2 sheet pizza's and 2 buckets of wings (bbq and honey mustard) with celery and 2 amazing tubs of blue cheese and all for my daughters birthday party! This is the only place I will order from for get-togethers and party's, the prices and quality cannot be beat! Also, thanks to the employees at this pizzeria for their professionalism when taking my order all the way to the delivery, there isn't anything bad I can say about this place, I love their subs, pizza, wings...everything is so good and always fresh, so this is why I wanted to write an awesome review because these guys rock the pizzeria business, keep up the great work!“

“Everything I've ever tried at Mayback's has been delicious. From the breakfast pizza to the regular pizza. This is one of the only places in the 716 that makes good chicken fingers (the honey mustard ones are divine) and a good cheese steak. The fish fry is the best I've had in years. If you want a real treat try the turkey sub with pickles and extra meat. The freshest salads I've ever had. Food is amazing, prices are great, and everyone who works there is friendly. They've got something for everyone. Easily my favorite place to get food in Buffalo.“

“ordered through Slice. said order was on the way 15 min after ordering. we live 5 min away so after 40 min more we inquired about our food. they said it was eroute and will be here in 5 min. after 20 more min we asked again. suddenly the slice app cncelled our order and refunded us per ricottas for miscomunication. so over a hour and a half for 1 salad?! and we never even got it lol. Very unprofessional“

“My boyfriend and I are from Texas and never had New York style pizza. I found this on Google and saw the big slice and wanted it. 10/10 pizza, folded like it needed and I'm a crust girly and 100/10 I didn't know it could be that good!! 1000% “

“i bought a 2 litter docter pepper here and they let me share it with my dog vincent in the pizza lobby they even gave me a bowl to pour the docter pepper in for vincent ive never seen my dog so happyVegetarian options: they have 2 litters of docter pepper which is my favorite beverage because does not have any eggs, beef, milk, or mammals in its 23 flavours and I think that makes it veegan“

“It is what you would expect from a children's party spot.I think they have a really good selection of games. Small area in the back for the smaller kids in your group.My personal favorite is the photo booth. Included with the gaming bracelets. Nice little souvenir for your hundreds of dollars spent.Now for the food: I expected it to be overpriced, and it is. $16.99 for chicken nuggets, but it did say it was a serving for 2. When I got the nuggets, there were 8. Not exactly 2 servings for an 11 and 8 year old. The nuggets were pretty good though. I got the $11.98 salad bar and I did enjoy it. It's basic, but very clean and well stocked. It's also all you can eat which is nice since we were there for about 3 hours.The location was nice and clean and it is large enough that the kids didn't have to wait to play their favorite games.Dietary restrictions: The chicken wings are dairy free, but the nuggets are not!“

“Our 1st time and wow the food was delicious! The service is amazing, our waitress Donnie was super sweet and attentive! we will definitely be back! It was totally worth our 25 min drive We eat a lot of wings and hands down their garlic parm is fantastic!“

“We were informed it would be at least an hour wait. It ended up being closer to 1.5 hours, but oh… so worth the wait! The 3 cheese steak sub and the stinger chicken sub were very good! My daughter got the wings and was impressed with them as well.“

“I thought the gluten free pizza was good it's a thin crust and it seemed made in house and not out of a box or the freezer. I was disappointed in the wings they were just okay and not spectacular. My partner had regular pizza and he thought it was average. I personally thought their sauce was really good and not too sweet“