16 Best Pizza Restaurants in Tonawanda

JT's Pizza Pizza • $
1161 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Jumbo Chicken Wings
Cheeseburger Sub
Pepperoni Pizza
Garlic Bread
Fried Dough

“First off i gotta say this is gotta be the cleanest pizzeria I've ever been in. The food is always so good actually its really good, i havent had everything they offer but i gotta point my regulars, the rib sub and crinkle cut fries they have is amazing and the taco pizza delicious, chicken wings are also REALLY good, i usally order 20 or more cause i bring the left overs( if I don't eat them all at once) for my lunch the next day with a slice or two. Really great people there, always smiling and always great to conversate with. Oh and the fryed dough , love it Wish they would deliver to lancaster but I don't mind driving 20 mins for good food a couple times a week. Who wants to cook after working hard all day, Plus I dip into the fried dough before I get home but don't tell anyone.“

4.6 Superb56 Reviews
Fatman's Pizza Pizza • $
2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Finger Sub
Chicken Wings
Large Pizza

“We had the poor mans lasagna pizza, stuffed Hungarian peppers, and a stake sub, and a chef salad plus a stinger sub, order of crispy fresh cut fries. Everything was cooked perfectly. Each dish was delicious. I would highly recommend Fatman's Pizza for lunch and or dinner. Great place with friendly staff. Thank you so much.“

4.5 Superb61 Reviews
Olisi's New York Style Pizza • $
2352 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Cheddar Broccoli Pizza
Slice of Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Single Slice of Pizza
Meat Deluxe Stromboli
Pizza with Mushrooms
Stuffed Steak Pizza
Philly Steak Pizza
Slices of Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza

“Let's start off by saying I'm a thin crust girl. Pizza is a very controversial subject in Buffalo and some people prefer thicker crust. There are some serious pizza reviewers who will tell you this place is one of the best, and I have to agree. It's a good thin slice where all the topping won't slide off and you can eat it how it's supposed to be ate. The sauce isn't too sweet like some places and the cheese is good. The people who work there are really helpful as well.“

4.4 Superb65 Reviews
Palumbo's Pizzeria Pizza • $
1065 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Steak & Cheese Sub
Mozzarella Sticks
Cheeseburger Sub
5 Jumbo Fingers
Pizza and Wings

“Absolutely love Palumbos! The only thing I don’t like is that they’re not open 24/7 ? I’m writing this review so upset I can’t get their pizza right now and have to settle for some place else! I absolutely love the pizza, their subs , their prices & the owners & workers!! They’re just really a great atmosphere with really good energy & even better food. They better not ever close!! You guys are awesome ?“

4.7 Superb26 Reviews
Gino's Pizza Place Pizza • $
351 Fries Rd, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Wings
Cheese Pizza

“Gino's Pizza in Buffalo, New York, is an absolute gem! The moment I walked in, I was greeted with warm and friendly staff, creating a welcoming atmosphere. The aroma of freshly baked pizza filled the air, and the anticipation was worth it. Their pizza is simply out of this world – crispy crust, perfect blend of cheese, and delicious toppings that left my taste buds dancing with joy. The menu offers a great variety of options, ensuring there's something for everyone. The portion sizes are generous, and the prices are reasonable. Whether you dine in or take it to-go, Gino's will undoubtedly leave you craving for more. If you're in Buffalo, don't miss the chance to savor their delightful pizza – a true culinary delight!“

4.4 Superb39 Reviews
Franco's Pizza Pizza • $$
600 Delaware St, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Pepperoni Pizza Slice
Barely Any Sauce
Chicken Sandwich
Chicken Wings
Heart Pizzas
Medium Pizza
Large Pizza

“I had a large order to place for my daughters bday. I went in a few days before and they were able to get my order into the system in advanced.I was nervous that maybe my food would be cold by time I picked it up, but we arrived on time for pick up. Our food was made well! It was hot and fresh. I was very happy with it. I will return here again if I ever have a large orderCustomer Customer service was also great..ty!!“

4.2 Good93 Reviews
Franco's Pizza Pizza • $
2306 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Single Order Chicken Fingers Medium
Chicken Finger Pizza Slice
Slices Pepperoni Pizza
Buffalo Crispy Chicken
Philly Cheese Steak
Chessy Breadsticks
Cheese Pizza Slice
Personal Pizza
Chicken Hoagie
Chicken Wings

“Pizza and wings were great! Lots of value and the medium pizza is really like a large! The wings were good too. They were crispy and saucey. The only compliant was the estimated time for arrival was an hour window and with staying at a hotel it was hard to receive the order timely for planning and the food was there just after the window given. Better arrival time accuracy would have helped.“

4.2 Good66 Reviews
Raintree Bar and Grill Bar & Grill • $
2970 Colvin Blvd, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Special-Chicken Artichokes Spinach Alfredo Sauce and Bruschetta
Chicken and Chive Pizza
Poutine Pot Roast
Hot BBQ Wings
Fish Fry

“Ordered 3 different sauces on wings and some fingers too. All were excellent. Ordered extra crispy wings - cooked perfect. Were attempting to go to a " Wing Trail" establishment but they were closed. This was a recommendation so tried them out. SHOULD be on the Wing Trail list. Service was good, just short staffed like everywhere. Comfortable atmosphere with lots of space, no wait. Will certainly be back againKid-friendliness: Family friendly environment with dining area separate from bar“

4.2 Good44 Reviews
La Hacienda Brighton Pizza • $
900 Brighton Rd, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Loads of Meat Stromboli
Pizza and Wings Buffet
Yummmmmmmmmyyyy Pizza
Stuffed Pepper Pizza
Chicken Finger Pizza
Chicken Finger Sub
French Onion Soup
Chicken Hoagie
Spaghetti Parm
Kids Fish Fry

“Best restaurant sauce I've had in a long while. The meatball tasted like meat, not like breadcrumbs and fillers. Stuffed shells were delicious. The restaurant seemed more like a cafeteria but was comfortable but bright. Definitely a family friendly atmosphere.“

4.2 Good40 Reviews
DiPaulo's Pizzeria Pizza • $
571 Brighton Rd, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Finger
Chicken Wings
Garlic Bread
Steak Sub

“It's pretty good pizza, sweeter sauce, which helps it stand alone without toppings. But I'd say the meat on top helps balance that sweetness. Wings, again solid. But I wasn't blown away, sauces seemed thin. It was on there but very lightly dressed.“

4.1 Good53 Reviews
Candyman Pizza Pizza • $$
2347 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Woodfired Meatballs
Quattro Formaggi
Pizza Margherita
Pepperoni Pizza
Candyman Pizza
White Pizza

“My favorite bar/restaurant in all of Buffalo, for a well-rounded night! I'm surprised it's not a common recommendation on wing lists as their wings, especially the weck wings, are 10/10. I'd recommend going Wednesday-Saturday so you can also get the Candyman pizzas (any of them, candyman style!), and sitting on the Candyman side for craft cocktails or Caputis side for a great beer menu. The section between Caputi's and Candyman has a pool table, dart boards, and a couple pinball machines so it really is the perfect spot for friends, dates, or even just to go by yourself and mingle with the staff and regulars.“

4.1 Good43 Reviews
John's Pizza & Subs Pizza • $
1436 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

The Stinger Sandwich
Chicken Finger Sub
Chicken Sandwich
Cheese Pizza
Party Pizza

“First time in a long time. Too long. Cup and char was great. Maybe :30 too long. Soft bite no tear which I really enjoy. Great taste sauce cheese. I very much enjoyed this pizza. Also treated us to 20 wings medium. Also very good. Crispy saucy. Large cheese pepperoni 20 wings $41 with a coupon. Definitely won’t be waiting so long to order again. Thank you“

4.1 Good38 Reviews
A Touch of Italy Italian • $
630 Delaware St, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Platter Trio Lasagna Stuffed Shells and Chicken Parmigiana
Small Cheese Pepperoni and Green Pepper Pizza
Spaghetti and Meatballs
Eggplant Parmigiana
Spaghetti Parmesan
Fettuccine Alfredo
Margarita Chicken
Chicken Marsala
Baked Spaghetti
Chicken Alfredo

“We ordered out and they have outstanding food.My only issue was... that mushrooms were asked for on a steak sub. The response was we cant do mushrooms.There are mushrooms for pizzas, mushrooms for tortellini alfredo, and chicken marsala, yet no mushrooms for a steak sub?!Again great food but that is very confusing!“

4 Good95 Reviews
Plaza Pizzeria On Main Pizza • $
260 Main St, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Small Pepperoni Pizza

“I moved out of the area back when Plaza Pizzeria was still on Hinds.Started ordering from day one, back in the late 70's. They had excellent, quality food then, and still do,without a doubt.Saturday I ordered my special "Super Steak " sub & OMG....I went back in time, could not believe nothing has changed, after all this time. It's been 10 years since I had anything from there. So happy I found my go to place again. NOBODY is consistent as Plaza. Never a problem with anything. Super Steak Sub, Ham sub & Pizza was my usual. Thank God for wonderful people who work hard to keep good food consistent.Thanks guys,Ken & Kate Kosciolek“

3.9 Good20 Reviews
Colosso Taco & Pizza Express Mexican • $
66 Main St, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Cheese Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Finger
Broccoli Bites
Colosso Taco
Chicken Taco
Onion Rings
Steak Hoagie

“This restaurant has the most accommodating and lovely people ready to assist you with your order. The food always arrives as ordered...CORRECT and TIMELY... It has been my pleasure to recommend your restaurant to others. I also choose your restaurant to order from when I have company over for an informal meal. So. ..in case you have not noticed....I adore you!!!! Thank you for your quality and ethics which are equally as important as the food. Also it is so fabulous that you read the comments and respond to your customers. It allows us to know you care. Please remain true to your style as you are wonderfully ," slaying " it !!!!!!!“

3.9 Good62 Reviews
T.C. Wheelers Bar & Pizzeria Pizza • $
341 Wheeler St, Tonawanda

Customers` Favorites

Large Cheese and Pepperoni Pizza
Dill Pickle Pizza Large
Stuffed Banana Peppers
Wings on the Pit - Hot
The Sampler Platter
Chicken Finger Sub
Small Cheese Pizza
French Onion Soup
Chicken Parm Sub
Bruschetta Bread

“A bar restaurant that’s mostly a bar. Very friendly and welcoming staff. The bar tender had great descriptions for the food we asked about. It really helped out. I ordered a pizza with half cup and char pepperoni and half cup and char sausage. I never knew about the sausage type. Good crust, a lot of cheese plenty of meat toppings. Also ordered the bourbon chicken wings on the pit. They were sticky sweet and had a back note of light heat. They were very good.“

3.7 Good80 Reviews
map Map