20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Tonawanda

“Olisi's New York Style is a popular spot for locals and visitors alike. The food is always delicious, whether you order a slice or a whole pie. With a nice parking lot, it's convenient to stop by for lunch. Known for their thin crust pizza, this place stands out among Buffalo's pizza scene. The toppings stay put, the sauce isn't too sweet, and the cheese is great. The staff is friendly and helpful, making it a must-visit in town.“

“Fatman's Pizza is a restaurant that offers delicious pizza and wings. The pizza has a generous amount of toppings, with the cheese being fully melted. The crust is crispy, almost well-done, and the restaurant has been praised for consistently delivering great pizza in four out of five orders. The white pizza with onions, tomatoes, spinach, and cherry peppers is particularly popular. In addition to pizza, Fatman's offers Cajun BBQ wings and maple bacon wings, which have also received positive reviews. The restaurant has a loyal customer base, with some customers visiting every Friday for over seven years. The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is welcoming, making for an enjoyable dining experience.“

“JT's Pizza is a family-owned restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience. The restaurant features a stylized, Hollywood-inspired atmosphere, with framed posters adorning the walls. The pizza is described as delicious, and the Patelillos are a particular highlight. Customers praise the friendly and patient staff, who are helpful in navigating the payment system. While some customers have experienced longer-than-expected wait times for their orders, the overall consensus is that JT's Pizza is a recommended destination for those seeking a tasty slice of Buffalo-style pizza.“

“Gino's Pizza Place serves delicious and tasty pizzas that remind customers of other beloved pizzerias. The peperoni slices are a highlight, and the sicilian style and white pizza are also popular. The buffalo chicken pizza and cheese and pep calzone are must-try items, with the latter being incredibly large. The chefs are old-school and the atmosphere is fun, making it a highly recommended spot. The chicken finger could use improvement, but overall, Gino's Pizza Place is a great choice for pizza lovers.“

“Palumbo's Pizzeria is a popular spot, offering delicious pizza, subs, and friendly service. The atmosphere is energetic and welcoming, making it a great place to grab a quick lunch or dinner. They offer a variety of options, including single wings, mozzarella sticks, and a buffet, and are known for their perfect orders and reasonable prices.“

“Franco's Pizza is a bustling restaurant that stands out as one of the finest chain pizza restaurants. They offer delicious food, including highly recommended cookies. The restaurant provides great customer service, allowing for advanced ordering and timely pickup. Although service can be improved, the food is consistently hot, fresh, and well-made. Despite some minor issues, Franco's Pizza is a reliable choice for large orders and quick pickups, with pizza that is consistently good.“

“John's Pizza & Subs is a popular restaurant known for its delicious pizza and wings. A customer, who used to visit the place during their college years, still enjoys the pizza and wings after 15 years. The pizza has a great taste with soft bite and no tear, and the wings are crispy and saucy. Another customer appreciated the roast beef sub, which they believe is the finest in town. The roll is exceptional, the meat is good, and the condiments are fresh. The sub is large and tasty, making it a popular choice among customers. The staff is professional, and the establishment is clean and updated with convenient off-street parking. Overall, John's Pizza & Subs offers great food and service, making it a must-visit place for many.“

“Franco's Pizza is a reliable choice for parties and gatherings. Their online ordering system is quick and easy, and their presentation is impressive. The party pizza is a hit, and their wings are a must-try, sauced to perfection and cooked just right. For those with dietary restrictions, Franco's offers a surprisingly large and tasty gluten-free pizza option, although note that it's not cooked in a separate oven. Overall, Franco's consistently serves enjoyable food that's sure to please.“

“La Hacienda Brighton is a beloved restaurant that consistently exceeds expectations. With a wide range of menu options, including pizzas, meatballs, baked ziti, chicken parmesan, and antipasto, it's a great choice for any occasion. They cater to diverse tastes and dietary needs, offering gluten-free options and a variety of salads. Their all-you-can-eat pasta on Tuesdays is a standout deal, offering high-quality food at an unbeatable price.“

“Candyman Pizza is a popular local pub known for its delicious food and friendly service. The honey garlic parm wings and chicken Caesar wrap are customer favorites, but everything on the menu has received positive reviews. The pub is a great spot for groups and often hosts sports teams. They offer seasonal specials and rotating desserts, as well as a variety of board games, a pool table, and darts. The bar is well-stocked with a selection of draft beers and unique cocktails. The pub is also known for its delicious pizza, including a plant-based pepperoni option. The atmosphere is described as having an amazing vibe with Grateful Dead inspired artwork.“

“Plaza Pizzeria On Main serves great-tasting pizzas with the perfect balance of sauce and cheese. The crust is good, and prices are reasonable. The menu also features standout options like the steak sub, which is crispy and flavorful. With outstanding service and a well-rounded menu, this mom-and-pop-style restaurant is a great choice for a satisfying meal. Try the sausage royal or a small pizza with broccoli and pepperoni for a delicious experience.“

“DiPaulo's Pizzeria offers pizza, calzones, and wings. However, recent reviews mention issues with the food's quality. The boneless wings were disappointing and did not taste like chicken. The calzone arrived with a soggy bottom. The pizza had a good crust but lacked enough sauce, and customers found it to be overly cheesy. The wings were described as just decent. Some customers may not choose to return due to these concerns.“

“Molinara's N.Y. Pizza & Caffe is a local favorite that serves traditional New York-style pizza with a twist. Their semi-sweet sauce is a must-try, adding a hint of sweetness that elevates the flavor of their pizzas. The restaurant is known for its generous toppings and perfect cheese-to-topping ratio. Orders are ready quickly, usually within 30 minutes, and the service is always friendly. While some dishes, like the roast beef sub, may need improvement, their pizza is consistently excellent. With a cozy dining room and convenient takeout options, Molinara's is a great choice for pizza lovers.“

“T.C. Wheelers Bar & Pizzeria is a welcoming establishment, known for its friendly and helpful staff. The menu offers a variety of food, with a focus on generous portions of well-prepared dishes. Standout options include their pizza, which can be topped with unique sausage and pepperoni varieties, as well as their bourbon chicken wings. The restaurant is suitable for kids, but those with mobility concerns should be aware that wheelchair accessibility is difficult. Overall, T.C. Wheelers is a great spot for a meal or gathering, with a bar area and generous servings of delicious food.“

“Raintree Bar and Grill is a family-friendly restaurant with a comfortable atmosphere and great service. The menu offers a variety of delicious options, including the crispy Wings Chargrilled and amazing Poutine pot roast. Customers recommend trying the wings with different sauces and enjoying the fantastic pizza. The restaurant is considered a hidden gem, with guests praising the attentive waitress and overall dining experience. If you're looking for a place with tasty food and a welcoming environment, Raintree Bar and Grill is a must-visit spot in Tonawandas.“

“Joe's New York Style Pizza serves good food, particularly for pizza and deli lovers. The atmosphere is welcoming and service is generally quick. However, some customers have experienced poor customer service from staff members. The menu offerings include a variety of options, including steak pizza and chicken fingers. Prices may be steep for some, but fans of thin crust pizza may find it worth the cost.“

“John's Pizza & Subs offers delicious food and a lively atmosphere with good music and TVs. The Western chicken finger sub can be made less messy upon request. Service is generally friendly, but delivery may not always be available. This location stands out for its fluffy pizza crust and tasty cup and char pepperoni, as well as its satisfying chicken and steak Philly subs. It's an underrated spot for pizza and subs, recommended for a satisfying meal.“

“A Touch of Italy serves large portions of homemade Italian dishes, including lasagna and stuffed shells platter, which are "to die for". The restaurant offers fresh and delicious side salads. While the food is outstanding, some customers have noted inconsistencies with menu options and a sweet sauce.“

“Little Caesars Pizza offers great pizza at a fantastic price, with fast and excellent service. Despite not being traditional pizzeria pizza, it is still highly rated. Customers appreciate the hot and tasty za, especially when compared to other chain options. Recent improvements in management and staff have enhanced cleanliness and efficiency, making it an even better dining experience.“

“Colosso Taco & Pizza Express is a popular restaurant known for its accommodating and friendly staff, who are ready to assist customers with their orders. The food is consistently served as ordered, on time, and with great quality and attention to detail. Customers have praised the restaurant for its responsiveness to customer feedback and its commitment to providing a satisfying dining experience. The menu at Colosso Taco & Pizza Express is extensive, featuring a variety of options, including tacos, pizza, wings, subs, burritos, and more. The "Stinger Taco" is a particular favorite among customers, but the restaurant encourages diners to order what they're feeling at the moment. The restaurant's atmosphere is described as a "small rainbow space" with arcade games to entertain customers while they wait. While the food is generally considered tasty and satisfying, the overall dining experience can be hit-or-miss. Some customers have reported feeling neutral about the food and the dining-in experience, with the ambiance not always being worth the effort. However, for those looking for a quick and affordable taco fix, Colosso Taco & Pizza Express can be a convenient option, especially on Taco Tuesdays. Overall, the restaurant is a reliable choice for those craving tacos or other classic American fare, though it may not be the most memorable dining experience.“