What are you looking for?

Pizza Restaurants in Tonawanda

4.6 - 99 votes

Hours: Closed today

1065 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda
(716) 332-1010

Papa Johns Pizza

Great food, friendly service, and good atmosphere. Whether you're dining in or taking out, if you're in the area, make Palumbo's your spot... More reviews

4.4 - 157 votes

Hours: 10:30AM - 9PM

351 Fries Rd, Tonawanda
(716) 836-8020

Papa Johns Pizza

Three words- Old World Pizza. Don't know if any other places in the area that makes this kind and it's a favorite in my entire family (I'm... More reviews

4.4 - 150 votes

Hours: 12 - 9PM

2712 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda
(716) 693-7477

Papa Johns Pizza

I enjoyed the cheese and crust but the sauce is SO sweet. It reminds me of ketchup. Explains why my husband loves the pizza - he puts ketchup on everything. More reviews

4.3 - 126 votes

Hours: 11AM - 9PM

2352 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda
(716) 837-6767

Papa Johns Pizza

This place has truly NYC style pizzas. We ordered supreme deluxe and it was worth the drive from the Williamsville area. The pizza was very thin, with a ... More reviews

4.2 - 166 votes

Hours: 9AM - 9PM

571 Brighton Rd, Tonawanda
(716) 835-6161

Papa Johns Pizza

Super friendly staff, yummy pizza and the BEST wings in the Buffalo area. Will be back soon.Food: 5/5 More reviews

4.9 - 24 votes

Hours: 11AM - 11PM

1161 Sheridan Dr, Tonawanda
(716) 404-3030

Papa Johns Pizza

JT pizza on Sheridan is amazing! The pizzas are beautiful & delicious. The employees there take such pride in their food. I also had their home-made ... More reviews

4.1 - 194 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

630 Delaware St, Tonawanda
(716) 695-3355

Papa Johns Pizza

Ordered take out for friends. So much food and delicious. Would definitely go back. The sauce did not burn my stomach. More reviews

4.1 - 190 votes

Hours: 11:30AM - 9PM

2970 Colvin Blvd, Tonawanda
(716) 695-3504

Papa Johns Pizza

Good food moderately priced. Great place to meet friends when I am in Buffalo. Very accommodating to setting up tables for a large group of friends on sh... More reviews

4.1 - 158 votes

Hours: 10AM - 10PM

1436 Niagara Falls Blvd, Tonawanda
(716) 832-4343

Papa Johns Pizza

Solid pizza actually. Crust was thin but good flavor and the sauce they use is also good. Price was a little steep but it was arguably worth it. More reviews

4 - 182 votes

Hours: 11AM - 10PM

900 Brighton Rd, Tonawanda
(716) 832-3026

Papa Johns Pizza

I was a La Hacienda Brighton virgin until last night. I wanted to try someplace different. I'm getting sick of the same ol same ol ! So, I came to Y... More reviews

View on map