10 Best Pizza Restaurants in Amherst

“This place is a hidden gem! Great food, wide variety of menu choices, and exceptional customer service. I highly recommend ordering from here.“

“I've been going here for years. It's a takeout pizza shop. That's why only 3 stars for atmosphere. But always friendly service and high quality food. It's our go to for pizza. We like the sauce and excellent choice of toppings of high quality. I just had a turkey sub for lunch and like the pizzas, it was very good. It was tasty with a nice flavored oil dressing and excellent roll.“

“Franco's Pizza and subs are among the very best in our area. The pizza crust is perfect, the sauce is authentic and loaded with delicious mozzarella and pepperoni.
Sub sandwiches are the best in our area.
Service is always customer focused and friendly.
Franco's is our top choice for pizza and subs!“

“The absolute best pepperoni (well done double pep) pizza in the Buffalo area. Crust has fabulous texture and flavor. Sauce is good, not overwhelming. The pepperoni crisps up and isn't wafer thin.
I no longer live in the area but when there I take a few home with me.“

“Definitely recommend! Had a baby shower for my daughter in law this past weekend at My Tomato Pie. We corresponded with Tony on the banquet plans. Great communication, quick replies, very easy to deal with. Beautiful and well lit banquet room. Banquet server was right there for anything we needed. Everyone complimented the food. I wish I had more time to go back for seconds. Our banquet server was Rachel. I was surprised to see 1 server for a 35 person banquet but she was ahead of the game the whole time. We had everything we needed when we needed it. Very affordable too!“

“I have been a customer of bocce’s for over 20 years. Tonight I picked up a pizza, mushroom and pepperoni, and it was the best pie I’ve had there! There were so many toppings evenly distributed for every slice of the pie. The pizza was cooked to perfection. My business will continue to go with bocce’s, and I will definitely let people know to go with them in the future.“

“Today was super busy, line out door around the building due to 3.14 day. My online ordered was prepared and waiting when I arrived. Tasty as always. Utensils etc missing however“

“2025 Saturday October 25th around 1:30 pm
Everything was fantastic pizza was great breadsticks were super good if you guys can keep up this consistency I could see you bringing back the good name of Pizza Hut like back in the days of old.. establishment was nice and clean inside pearing back into the kitchen it looked clean. All the employees looked clean and well groomed. Was really really happy it's been a while since we've hit a good Pizza Hut so I was surprised when I came to leave a review and only seen 3.6 stars... keep up this consistency like what I had and make everybody's else's experience thebsame and hopefully you'll get back up to 4 plus stars..“

“05/28/26: Picked up a mobile order. It's was an expensive splurge. The wings were good and the fries also. The wings where not too hot, they had taste, not just burning heat. For a treat once in a while it's worth the stop. ~Would return.“