14 Best Pizza Restaurants in Amherst

“This place is a hidden gem! Great food, wide variety of menu choices, and exceptional customer service. I highly recommend ordering from here.“

“My husband has officially declared this the best pizza in Buffalo!! We loved it so much that we’ve already been back several times; the sauce 🍕🍅oh my God, tell me how they make that sauce!! I’m so glad I found this pizzeria.“

“Very good pizza & I don’t like buffalo style pizza like that! This was really good. I got the stinger (has chicken and steak) & chicken finger pizza both were really good!! Got those two of the speciality slices, a drink, and a cookie for 18$. The ingredients are good quality too!! Will be back and recommend it“

“Today I was nearby and tried their food for the first time. The personal pizza was so delicious. Mine included red sauce, mozzarella, spinach, pepperoni, and sweet peppers. Inside the building was nice, even though I did take out instead of dining. The mens restroom was clean, and thank God they had paper towels rather than the air drying machine (for touching the door handle afterwards). There was a friendly young lady at the front register also. My only recommendation is adding basil to the pizza topping menu. I'll definitely return here regardless.“

“I ordered a double chesse and pepperoni pizza. It didn't seem as loaded up as it was in the past. I called and they dropped another off to my house 35 mins later. Pizza is amazing and service is even better!! Great pizza in amherst!! Highly recommend it. Families favorite pizza!!“

“The absolute best pepperoni (well done double pep) pizza in the Buffalo area. Crust has fabulous texture and flavor. Sauce is good, not overwhelming. The pepperoni crisps up and isn't wafer thin.
I no longer live in the area but when there I take a few home with me.“

“Today was super busy, line out door around the building due to 3.14 day. My online ordered was prepared and waiting when I arrived. Tasty as always. Utensils etc missing however“

“Bocces on Hopkins - 5 stars because I always love the food. A better system to determine who is there first for a take out order would be good. Even as simple as enter from the right, there’s no direction and it’s a little tense in there!“

“THANK YOU so much for your generous donation to Our Lady of Peace church’s Wines Around the World Event. We greatly appreciate your donation. With out your support we could not help the Breast Cancer Network, Sleep in Heavenly Peace and St. Lukes. Support Local Businesses!“

“It is a great store! Just recently started shopping there more since I have one just around the corner now.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ THE CREW AT PAPA JOHN’S = STRAIGHT UP AWESOME 🍕🙌😄

I DoorDash here all the time, and these guys are ALWAYS on point. 💯
Every visit: big smiles, good vibes, and super helpful energy. 😁✨
They treat people with respect, they hustle, and they make the pickup process smooth every single time. 🚗💨📦

It’s rare to find a team that stays this friendly and consistent — especially with how busy it gets. 🔥👏
Seriously, shoutout to this whole crew. Y’all make my nights way easier, and I appreciate every one of you. 🙏🍕💛“

“I had a great experience ordering from Pizza Hut. The website was easy to use, and the order was ready right on time. Everything was hot and fresh, especially the pizza. If I had one suggestion, it would be to add a little more barbecue sauce to the boneless wings, but they were still good. Plus, the portion sizes meant I have plenty of leftovers for tonight. I also ordered from the seven dollar menu, which was a great value.“

“I’ve tried different types of pizza here, and every time I visit, I’m never disappointed. The dough is always fresh and well-made, and both the cheese and sauce are consistently high quality. It’s clear they use good ingredients and know how to make a great pizza.“