11 Best Pizza Restaurants in Amherst

“This place is a hidden gem! Great food, wide variety of menu choices, and exceptional customer service. I highly recommend ordering from here.“

“I've originally grown up on NYC/Jersey pizza but living in Bflo.in upstate NY I had never known how gr8 Mattina's pizza was until I had it 2-yrs ago and couldn't stop ordering it baked light quick well done on top and their sauce is Amazing if only they would put Xtra sauce when you pay Xtra for it is rlly the only thing I've noticed that they don't do anymore. I have to drive 3-hrs to get their pizza now since I moved to Hilton.Pls.dont bogart on the sauce bring back your proud pizza so my guest can be your #1fans of the best pizza this side of New York!“

“Franco's Pizza and subs are among the very best in our area. The pizza crust is perfect, the sauce is authentic and loaded with delicious mozzarella and pepperoni.
Sub sandwiches are the best in our area.
Service is always customer focused and friendly.
Franco's is our top choice for pizza and subs!“

“The absolute best pepperoni (well done double pep) pizza in the Buffalo area. Crust has fabulous texture and flavor. Sauce is good, not overwhelming. The pepperoni crisps up and isn't wafer thin.
I no longer live in the area but when there I take a few home with me.“

“This place felt incredibly homie from the moment we walked in. The customers all seemed like regulars, which actually made me feel right at home. The staff was kind, efficient, and our server checked in on us consistently without ever being overbearing.

But the food was the real star. Every dish we ordered was well‑seasoned, flavorful, and genuinely delicious. Not a single miss on the table. If I can pick one over everything else, it is the chicken Marsala. It is a must! I’ll definitely be coming back.“

“Bocces on Hopkins - 5 stars because I always love the food. A better system to determine who is there first for a take out order would be good. Even as simple as enter from the right, there’s no direction and it’s a little tense in there!“

“Today was super busy, line out door around the building due to 3.14 day. My online ordered was prepared and waiting when I arrived. Tasty as always. Utensils etc missing however“

“We ordered a Grandma T pizza tonight and it was definitely lacking so we called the store and spoke to the manager Melissa , she personally made us a new pizza and delivered it herself! The new pizza was great but the customer service she gave was amazing!! Thank you so much!!“

“2025 Saturday October 25th around 1:30 pm
Everything was fantastic pizza was great breadsticks were super good if you guys can keep up this consistency I could see you bringing back the good name of Pizza Hut like back in the days of old.. establishment was nice and clean inside pearing back into the kitchen it looked clean. All the employees looked clean and well groomed. Was really really happy it's been a while since we've hit a good Pizza Hut so I was surprised when I came to leave a review and only seen 3.6 stars... keep up this consistency like what I had and make everybody's else's experience thebsame and hopefully you'll get back up to 4 plus stars..“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ THE CREW AT PAPA JOHN’S = STRAIGHT UP AWESOME 🍕🙌😄

I DoorDash here all the time, and these guys are ALWAYS on point. 💯
Every visit: big smiles, good vibes, and super helpful energy. 😁✨
They treat people with respect, they hustle, and they make the pickup process smooth every single time. 🚗💨📦

It’s rare to find a team that stays this friendly and consistent — especially with how busy it gets. 🔥👏
Seriously, shoutout to this whole crew. Y’all make my nights way easier, and I appreciate every one of you. 🙏🍕💛“