15 Best American Restaurants in Tonawanda

“Prescott's Provisions offers an exceptional dining experience. The restaurant's interior is charming, and the food is consistently delicious. The chefs and service staff, including knowledgeable waiters, provide top-notch service. The menu features a range of dishes, including wood-fired pizzas and steaks, such as the notable wagyu steak with mushrooms and truffles. The atmosphere is upscale yet casual, making it a comfortable and fulfilling experience for diners. Whether enjoying the patio in the summer or savoring a meal indoors, Prescott's Provisions is a great choice for those seeking a memorable culinary experience.“

“We had a date night in the area and I had heard of Squire’s so we thought we’d give it a try. It’s a quaint place with a dining room on one side and a bar down the other. We stopped on a Saturday night around 6:00 and the dining room was full so we sat at the bar. Rick was running the bar and we was fantastic. Such a nice and helpful guy. It was a pleasure to meet him. I had the pot roast special with fries and gravy while my wife had The Warrior which was a classic Beef on Weck with 5 wings. I couldn’t have cooked it better myself ! Everything was perfect. After our visit this place moved up near the top of places we like to visit. Cozy, casual and quant place to get great food, great service and a glass of spirits !“

“Swiston's Beef & Keg is a popular local restaurant known for its tasty wings, chicken souvlaki wrap, and impressive rodeo beef dish. Customers praise the restaurant's scenic patio overlooking the water and the friendly service, with one reviewer noting the "wonderful" bartender who kept things running smoothly. Overall, Swiston's Beef & Keg offers a enjoyable dining experience that keeps customers coming back.“

“Guud and Evul Vegan Eats is a vegan restaurant with impeccable food and flawless service. The menu offers a variety of delicious options, like the stinger hoagie and mix & match potato skins. The "meatloaf" dinner special is packed with flavor, especially the fresh cheesy broccoli. The build your own sandwich was delicious, with crispy coating and great bun. The waffle fries were a hit too. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, with friendly staff. Customers have described the food as almost a religious experience, coming out piping hot and made to order. A highly recommended spot for vegans and non-vegans alike, with hopes of being featured by Guy Fieri in the future.“

“Mitchell's Tavern is a restaurant known for its outstanding bar food and friendly service. The roast beef and Greek wrap are popular menu items, and the bartenders are praised for their skills. Prices are reasonable, and there are frequent drink specials. The decor is cozy and features Buffalo sports memorabilia on the walls. The pickle chips and fries are highly recommended, but the gravy could be improved. On one occasion, there was an issue with a bone in the pulled pork, but the restaurant handled it well by removing the sandwich from the bill. The roast beef is good, but the level of doneness may vary. Overall, Mitchell's Tavern is a great neighborhood spot with a welcoming atmosphere.“

“Athena's Family Restaurant is a place where one can enjoy great home-cooked meals at reasonable prices. The restaurant is known for its friendly service, with mentions of servers named Niko and Lauren providing excellent service. The menu offers a variety of options, such as strip steak specials, leg of lamb, chicken and beef mixed souvlaki, and kids' spaghetti and meatball. The chicken souvlaki and meatballs are specifically highlighted as standouts. The portions are generous, and the restaurant is a good choice for groups, as seen by a party of seven being accommodated well. However, one reviewer mentioned a deduction for less than well-done lamb preference and the atmosphere. Nonetheless, Athena's Family Restaurant is a recommended place for a hearty and satisfying meal.“

“Fatman's Pizza is a restaurant that offers delicious pizza and wings. The pizza has a generous amount of toppings, with the cheese being fully melted. The crust is crispy, almost well-done, and the restaurant has been praised for consistently delivering great pizza in four out of five orders. The white pizza with onions, tomatoes, spinach, and cherry peppers is particularly popular. In addition to pizza, Fatman's offers Cajun BBQ wings and maple bacon wings, which have also received positive reviews. The restaurant has a loyal customer base, with some customers visiting every Friday for over seven years. The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is welcoming, making for an enjoyable dining experience.“

“Joey's Place is a delightful restaurant serving a variety of dishes with care and attention to detail. The menu offers an array of options, including the artichokes francais, meat-stuffed ravioli, mushroom Swiss burger, chicken parm, and chicken milanese. The portions are generous, with options like the artichokes and chicken parm being quite large. The atmosphere is welcoming, with friendly waitstaff and a nice ambiance. The prices are comparable to other restaurants in the area. Whether dining in or taking out, Joey's Place consistently delivers delicious food that is sure to please even the pickiest of eaters.“

“GFY Bar and Grill is a lively spot with great music, usually no cover charge, and a typical bar food menu. The service is only available at the bar, but tables are available for seating. The restaurant offers free parking, although the spaces are limited. It is wheelchair accessible, with a handicap parking spot and no steps or obstacles to enter the bar or men's room. The atmosphere is fun and friendly, perfect for a night out or a stop after a bike ride.“

“The Gateway Cafe & Grill is a local dining establishment that has received positive reviews from customers. The restaurant is praised for its delicious and fresh food, with highlights including the flight of soups, BLT sandwich, and fish and chips. The staff is described as attentive and helpful, going the extra mile to assist customers, such as directing them to nearby parking. While the prices may be considered a bit steep by some, the overall dining experience is highly recommended, with one customer even stating that the burger they ordered was the best they've ever had. The restaurant caters to dietary restrictions, offering gluten-free bread options. Overall, The Gateway Cafe & Grill is a popular lunch spot known for its friendly service and tasty cuisine.“

“Raintree Bar and Grill is a family-friendly restaurant with a comfortable atmosphere and great service. The menu offers a variety of delicious options, including the crispy Wings Chargrilled and amazing Poutine pot roast. Customers recommend trying the wings with different sauces and enjoying the fantastic pizza. The restaurant is considered a hidden gem, with guests praising the attentive waitress and overall dining experience. If you're looking for a place with tasty food and a welcoming environment, Raintree Bar and Grill is a must-visit spot in Tonawandas.“

“Old Man River is a popular restaurant located by the water, offering a delightful culinary experience in a casual and charming atmosphere. The menu features a variety of options, with standout seafood selections that are fresh and well-prepared. Customers have enjoyed the grilled chicken and cheese burgers, as well as the tasty french fries. While there may have been a slight wait for the food, the friendly and efficient service, along with the scenic waterfront views, make for an overall positive dining experience. The restaurant also boasts a lively atmosphere with great music and craft brews, creating a party-like ambiance for both locals and visitors.“

“Candyman Pizza is a popular local pub known for its delicious food and friendly service. The honey garlic parm wings and chicken Caesar wrap are customer favorites, but everything on the menu has received positive reviews. The pub is a great spot for groups and often hosts sports teams. They offer seasonal specials and rotating desserts, as well as a variety of board games, a pool table, and darts. The bar is well-stocked with a selection of draft beers and unique cocktails. The pub is also known for its delicious pizza, including a plant-based pepperoni option. The atmosphere is described as having an amazing vibe with Grateful Dead inspired artwork.“

“Caputi's Sheridan Pub is a friendly place known for its perfect wings and delicious Salt and Vinegar fries. They serve very tasty pizza with a crisp crust and flavorful toppings like cup and Char pepperoni. The Bourbon BBQ wings are worth the wait, cooked on the pit. With a great atmosphere, drink selection, and one of the best pies in the area, this pub is a must-visit for food lovers.“

“Tim Hortons is a restaurant that prides itself on providing exceptional customer service. The staff, including the drive-thru attendants and window crew, are polite, professional, and friendly. However, there have been instances where orders have been incorrect, with customers receiving incomplete meals or wrong drinks. Despite these mishaps, the staff have been receptive to feedback and willing to make amends. The restaurant's coffee and breakfast items, such as the grilled wrap combo and sausage and egg combo, are popular among customers.“